May 3, 2010 7:00 PM
CS5 Running very sticky
-
Like (0)
Hello,
I've installed InDesign CS5 and it's running terribly when I have graphics placed, especially at high resolution display. It's choppy, sticky - to much to even work with. I've thrown out the SavedData and InDesign Defaults, but it doesn't help. Has anyone else experienced this problem, or have any ideas what I can do. CS4 runs fine.
Thanks,
Adam
Operating system and version? Video specs? Hard drive free space? Memory?
Macbook Pro 17" / 2.93 GH with 10.6.3
4 GB Ram
500 GB HD with 250 available.
NVIDIA GeForce 9600M GT Graphics Card
Also, Illustrator CS5 and Photoshop CS5 seem to be running fine.
Are you using a file that has been created with some older version of InDesign?... I have had some experience of slowing in those cases....
I thought that was the issue at first. But I've created pages from scratch. As soon as I bring in some images or illustrator files, it slows way done. Gets horrible if the display is set to high quality. I created a test user and the same problem occurs.
are you placing images from your local HD or from network?
Local. I've been testing multiple pages in both CS5 and CS4 using the same images. I also created a test user account with same results. Lastly, I uninstalled and reinstalled - Same results.
InDesign CS5 very sticky here too, especially in high resolution display. Extremely annoying... I thought this was built for Intel, you know, faster, blah, blah, blah. Running a 3.06 GHz iMac, Intel Core 2 Duo, 8 GB, OS X 10.6.3, 1 TB hard drive, 774 GB free.
Another thing, perhaps I don't have something set right, but I find this very annoying as well. When I export documents to pdf, there is no progress bar anymore. May sound trivial, but when I'm exporting like 50+ pages, it just sits there. Is it working? Has it locked up? Are we exporting? Hello, what's going on? Ahhhh.... So I just sit there hoping to see the pdf eventually pop up when it finishes.
Does anyone know how to get that progress/status bar back so I can see were I am in the export process?
I think InDesign CS5 exports PDF as a background task. It means that you wont see a progress bar but you can perform other activities at the same time. That wasn´t possible with earlier versions...
that's actually a good thing. there is a status panel you can open that will show you something is exporting/etc, but it no longer requires you to wait while it exports...so you can keep working on other things.
multi-threading.
Can't help with the slowness, which I suspect is related to something else you have running, but PDF export is now a "background task" which means it no longer stops you from doing other things while it finishes. You can get details on background task from Window > Utilities > Background Tasks and while the export is active there is a widget that appears in the Menu Bar the right of the other things that are always there. It resembles a stack of short black bars that appear and disappear while the export is progressing.
It's not something i have running as there is nothing else running during some of my testing. I can have both CS5 and Cs4 open at the same time and see the performance issue happening. CS4 is significantly better, especially with high Rez preview. I wonder if it could be font related? Though I've tested with many different fonts - but maybe one of those running in the background?
I actually just watched my activity monitor while I simply moved images and text boxes around. The CPU% climbed as high as 80%. Stayed between 30-80% ish. That can right. With CS4, it stayed below 40% the whole time. Any thoughts?
I don't know enough about OSX to point you to waht to look for, but allcomputers have a large variety of background tasks running all the time -- som required by the OS, some not, and we often fail to realize that they are there. On the Windows side, for instance, a commonly used bit of online banking securtity software was causing problems, even when users were not engaged in online banking activities.
I'm not saying the program isn't running slowly on your system or on anyone else's, but that, particularly on Macintosh which has far fewer hardware configuations possibilities, a general problem of this sort would have shown up during the testing period and it's far more likely that the slownes issue is realted to something specific on the system.
Cool, thanks. That worked. At least I know where I am in the export now, and agree, continuing to work is a good thing. Nice enhancement.
Still sticky though, and can get very bad in high quality display mode with larger images. To the point of image jumping. That is, moving an image with the mouse, and lagging behind so bad that you have to basically anticipate the sticky, jumpy movements to land it close to where you want it to be.
It happens on new documents, old documents, while nothing else is running, etc. It's only in ID, and can even get very slow responsiveness when trying to resize the window the document is in. In fact, when I was setting up my pallets, I chose to show the mini bridge. Opened the mini bridge and tried to drag it into another pallet area and CRASH! Sent the report to Adobe.
Not sure what to make of it, but there is definitely something going on with my ID CS5. Everything else seems smooth for the most part...
cspann wrote:
Still sticky though, and can get very bad in high quality display mode with larger images. To the point of image jumping. That is, moving an image with the mouse, and lagging behind so bad that you have to basically anticipate the sticky, jumpy movements to land it close to where you want it to be.
It happens on new documents, old documents, while nothing else is running, etc. It's only in ID, and can even get very slow responsiveness when trying to resize the window the document is in. In fact, when I was setting up my pallets, I chose to show the mini bridge. Opened the mini bridge and tried to drag it into another pallet area and CRASH! Sent the report to Adobe.
Not sure what to make of it, but there is definitely something going on with my ID CS5. Everything else seems smooth for the most part...
That sounds like a video memory problem. Does it get better if you resart the computer?
adamgordon wrote:
I actually just watched my activity monitor while I simply moved images and text boxes around. The CPU% climbed as high as 80%. Stayed between 30-80% ish. That can right. With CS4, it stayed below 40% the whole time. Any thoughts?
I think that would be pretty dependent on the document content. With a simple doc I don't get so much as a blip in performace in either version.
Yep, I've shut down, restarted, fixed permissions, cleared the PRAM, etc. Nothing helps.
Here's a real world example. I have three documents opened from an indb file. Total of 32 pages. (Catalog - Images, text) Set the display to high resolution, watch my activity monitor > system memory. At the worst, 2.94 GB remain free, 1.41 GB active. CPU shows at the minimum 50% of CPU idle.
Again, ID is the only one with this sticky problem. Doesn't seem like the those numbers show a struggling processor.
Here's my video info:
ATI Radeon HD 4670:
Chipset Model: ATI Radeon HD 4670
Type: GPU
Bus: PCIe
PCIe Lane Width: x16
VRAM (Total): 256 MB
Vendor: ATI (0x1002)
Device ID: 0x9488
Revision ID: 0x0000
ROM Revision: 113-B8030F-260
EFI Driver Version: 01.00.383
Displays:
iMac:
Resolution: 2560 x 1440
Pixel Depth: 32-Bit Color (ARGB8888)
Main Display: Yes
Mirror: Off
Online: Yes
Built-In: Yes
Connection Type: DisplayPort
cspann, seems like we're having the exact same issue. For me, it acts up with one text box and one image, on high res. preview. I get the same "jumping" of the image when trying to move it around too. Please post any progress you make with this issue. For me, it may be a deal breaker. I'll just keep using CS4, which runs very smoothly. I also tried re-installing CS5 with no luck. I don't see how it's my machine when CS4 can handle the same exact document with little effort.
I having the same problem. CS4 does not have this sluggishness.
Yea, it isn't machine related. Been around the block too many times to believe that one. I've got tons of space and memory as seen above. It's just in ID CS5, everything else works fine, including previous ID CS releases.
I have noticed that even reverting back to Typical Display doesn't entirely relieve the problem. In Typical Display, there is not smooth movement of images. It's just less jumpy than the practically unmanageable image and text box jumping after high res display.
You are correct adamgordon, I will likely have to resume using CS4 as well until some type of solution is found. It was smooth and constant there, as well as CS3 & CS2. I love many of the CS5 upgrades, but seriously, it greatly frustrates my workflow at this point, as I often need to be in high res display to properly render Illustrator images with acceptable clarity to add captions, numbers and proper close placement to other items.
cspann - I've been too busy today to play around with this a lot, but I think the situation is worse if I have an .ai file placed as opposed to a .psd or .jpg or tif. Vector art maybe the culprit? Have you noticed this?
I've noticed it with equal annoyance using ai, eps and tif files. It is much worse depending on file size. Larger is worse of course...
Are any of you using custom keyboard shortcut sets or anything similar that you imported from a previous version? In another thread that's just been linked to keys not working correctly.
What about font managers? (did I ask that already?)
I am not using any custom or otherwise keyboard shortcuts just a wacom tablet and mouse. Use Suitcase Fusion 2 for font management.
No on custom keyboard stuff. I'm using FontAgent Pro. However, when I created a test user, FontAgent was not running.
The problem for me seems to stem primarily from .ai files that are placed. When high quality preview is on, everything is horrible. If I'm just using photo images, although it slows, it's not nearly as bad.
@wwd
Do things improve if you turn off Suitcase?
No change with suitcase off
No custom keyboard shortcuts here. Nothing imported from older files. I use FontDoctor to check for problem fonts, otherwise Apple's Font Book. I notice super stickyness regardless of the presences of ai files or not.
I have found something that slightly seems to help on my end. (Emphasize slightly helps) Going to, View > Grids & Guides, then deselecting everything. This helps with a bit of the jumping in high res. I figure it is like eliminating speed bumps in the road. It makes the ride a little smoother. Maybe it will help you guys a bit.
It's still awful, but just a bit less awful, and I will take any improvement I can get.
How about turning off preflight?
Any cross-references or hyperlinks?
Turning off preflight did not change anything. I tried turning of the snap to grid and smart guides, which doesn't help, but does make the experience seem smoother because of the "not snapping". If I put in a super simple vector file, it's not as bad.
cspann wrote:
Here's my video info:
ATI Radeon HD 4670:
Chipset Model: ATI Radeon HD 4670
Type: GPU
Bus: PCIe
PCIe Lane Width: x16
VRAM (Total): 256 MB
Vendor: ATI (0x1002)
Device ID: 0x9488
Revision ID: 0x0000
ROM Revision: 113-B8030F-260
EFI Driver Version: 01.00.383
Displays:
iMac:
Resolution: 2560 x 1440
Pixel Depth: 32-Bit Color (ARGB8888)
Main Display: Yes
Mirror: Off
Online: Yes
Built-In: Yes
Connection Type: DisplayPort
Your 2560 x 1440 resolution seems to indicate a 27" screen. 256 MB VRAM is probably on the scant side of sufficient for processing this many pixels quickly, though, there may be other aspects of the graphics processing subsystem that compensate well for the pure VRAM amount. I'm comparing that to my MacBook Pro 17" with 1680 x 1050 resolution has 512 MB VRAM - about half the pixels with double the amount of VRAM. Whether or not this is the key factor, there are some other things to consider, that I've not seen mentioned in this thread.
These Pages panel settings and options can consume lots of video processing when the display includes:
* Lots of document pages, with Pages > Panel Options > Page and Master sizes set to large or extra-large thumbnails, and Icons for Transparency, Spread Rotation, and Page Transitions checked (ON). In CS5, there are also page color labels
* Lots of small text, with Preferences > Display Performance > Greek Text below set to a small point size, or even zero points; also, Enable Anti-aliasing turned on; OpenType fonts with many options turned on, like ligatures, positional forms, etc - things that require calculation
* Many complex graphics with display performance set to maximum quality
* Conditional text (pages thumbnails show/hide content according to condition settings)
* Multiple page sizes in one document (CS5)
If CS5 is slower than CS4, the if you've set some new CS5 features, try turning them off.
HTH
Regards,
Peter
_______________________
Peter Gold
KnowHow ProServices
I can have one semi complicated .ai file and nothing else on the page. The only setting you mentioned that would be turned on is high quality preview. With that you cannot move the picture on the screen smoothly without it jumping all around. I can have CS4 open with 20 complicated .ai files and 100 images on a 44 page catalog and it runs beautifully.
adamgordon wrote:
I can have one semi complicated .ai file and nothing else on the page. The only setting you mentioned that would be turned on is high quality preview. With that you cannot move the picture on the screen smoothly without it jumping all around. I can have CS4 open with 20 complicated .ai files and 100 images on a 44 page catalog and it runs beautifully.
Is it possible that there's a newer video driver for your hardware?
I don't think you've mentioned whether the display is integral - like an iMac - or external. I'm not sure that would make a difference, but perhaps there's an issue with the connection between the computer and an external monitor. Are you using more than one display? Are there some other display settings that come into play with multiple monitors, like mirroring, primary and secondary, refresh rates for one or both, etc? Just guessing.
Have you tried exporting the file to IDML and opening that in InDesign CS5? Have you tried the file on another machine running InDesign CS5? What results?
HTH
Regards,
Peter
_______________________
Peter Gold
KnowHow ProServices
I have a 17" Macbook Pro. A unibody model. I also have an external 24" Mac display. Happens on both screens even when I'm not connected to the external. And it's not just one file, it's every file. I can duplicate this every time with the multiple .ai files Ive tested. I don't know if there's a new driver, but mine is not old or bad. As I've stated, CS4 handles the same images placed without issue. Illustrator and Photoshop run fine.
I have not tried exporting to IDML. But I will. And I have not tried another machine. I did create a test user with same results though.
Adam
I'm having the exact same issue with moving graphics around in ID CS5, new or older documents... and that's with 16GB RAM and a 512MB NVIDIA GeForce 8800 GT video card. I've never experienced it in CS4.
Hoping it will get fixed in an update.
Wayne, is it the same for vector files as it is for bitmaps? My issue is significantly worse with .ai files vs. psd's.
Adam
Sent from my iPad
Adam, Huh, hadn't noticed but just checked it out. It's the same with vector and bitmaps. Like you I use place native .ai and .psd files.
I move something with the mouse and curser and it steps across the page.
Regards, Wayne
Not sent from an iPad <heavy sigh>
Why can't there just be a smooth transition. "Literally" on two counts.
Adam
Sent from my iPad
Yeah, sux when you're trying to move something just a little and it's bouncing around like a house fly with a dose of Raid.
peter at knowhowpro wrote:
Your 2560 x 1440 resolution seems to indicate a 27" screen. 256 MB VRAM is probably on the scant side of sufficient for processing this many pixels quickly...
I thought that might be a factor, too, but I've also got a Radeon (different model) with 256 mb VRAM driving a 27" monitor, though mine is only 1920 x 1200, and I see no slowdown.
What are you guys using for mice? The newest Apple mouse does not seem to get along well with ID as far as scrolling, and I think I may have seen some posts about trying to drag page items, too.
adamgordon wrote:
I can have one semi complicated .ai file and nothing else on the page. The only setting you mentioned that would be turned on is high quality preview. With that you cannot move the picture on the screen smoothly without it jumping all around. I can have CS4 open with 20 complicated .ai files and 100 images on a 44 page catalog and it runs beautifully.
If you can package an example of the sticky file and its illustration where we could download it, we can let you know how it works on our CS5 installations.
HTH
Regards,
Peter
_______________________
Peter Gold
KnowHow ProServices
Peter,
Thanks for offering some ideas. Uh, you are correct. It is a 27" iMac. (5 months old) As a side note, this machine rocks! Phenomenal depth and range of color. It's made design work much easier.
Honestly, I cannot speak to the VRAM issue, all I could add is that it works perfectly in CS4, so logic would dictate that the only variable in the equation is ID CS5. Same files, machine, user, etc.
It also may be relevant to note that I use this machine to fly X-Plane 9.0, which is insanely graphic intensive with lots of motion, and the machine handles it superbly. I will very rarely get a motion freeze, but then quickly catches up if it does happen. I have to believe if it can render X-Plane motion okay, ID CS4 okay, PS CS5, AI CS5, etc., then there is something specific to the ID code handling that has changed. (For the worse) It is simply the only variable that has changed.
I further have to stress that I do get other "Sticky" issues on ID CS5 as well. This includes the following:
1. Resizing the document pane can be very sticky or non responsive.
2. I can click out of ID to the desktop or other program, ID refuses to release the screen. I have to click back on ID and then back off for it to deselect.
3. I've had ID crash when pulling pallets into other pallet windows. Report sent to Adobe.
None of this happened in CS4. (And still doesn't) I've reinstalled, deleted preferences and more. Nothing has resolved the issues.
It seems we keep looking at the individual machines for the cause, and I understand that inclination, however, the only program struggling on my machine is ID CS5. I think we have enough reports of this issue that we could eliminate individual systems as a root cause. There are too many setup variables reported, from Mac to PC, various hard drive configurations, processors, RAM amounts, etc., all displaying the same issue.
Furthermore, everyone seems to be saying CS4 worked no problems. This again suggests that the system setups are fine, and that CS5 has some kind of issue as it relates to graphic movement.
As to the below. I do have some of what you mentioned, however, nothing that seems unusual or anything ID & the computer shouldn't be able to handle. I will see if I can post a couple pages to my site. I'll repost that info...
cspann wrote:
It seems we keep looking at the individual machines for the cause, and I understand that inclination, however, the only program struggling on my machine is ID CS5. I think we have enough reports of this issue that we could eliminate individual systems as a root cause. There are too many setup variables reported, from Mac to PC, various hard drive configurations, processors, RAM amounts, etc., all displaying the same issue.
We have less than a dozen users reporting what you are seeing, not hundreds, or perhaps thousands by now, that we would expect from a general bug. I'm not saying there isn't something about CS5 that is a problem, but it most likley is isolated to some particular set of hardware software configurations that trigger it.
Yea, I cant argue with that if there are only a dozen reports.
Here are a couple pages that are sticky. I'd give you more, but the files are just too big. http://www.digitalmarketing1.com/Page-15-16-Folder.zip
cspann wrote:
Yea, I cant argue with that if there are only a dozen reports.
I think this is the only thread so far...
I can't say I'm seeing any major slowdown in the pages you sent, though there doese seem to be a VERY short lag between selecting a frame and having it start to move. Once moving it is normal.
I exported to .idml and opened that in both CS4 and CS5 and the action is definitiely smotther in CS4 for this file. HOWEVER, I have plenty of other files that DON't exhibit this "stickiness" in CS5, both my own and files others have sent, so I think it has to be related to something in the file itself. My instinict is that it may be to do with all the .eps links. Resaving those as PDF or native .ai or .psd might improve things.
North America
Europe, Middle East and Africa
Asia Pacific
Copyright © 2011 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use and Online Privacy Policy (updated 07-14-2009).