Has anybody else been seeing problems with the audio in Captivate 5? I will record a number of slides, then the audio stops working and reports that there is no audio device. I have to close Captivate and restart it, and then when I auto-calibrate, it comes up with a completely different volume.
I'm using it on a 64-bit machine with Windows 7. I'm wondering if the 64-bit is the issue.
Hi there
I'm very doubtful that 64 bits is the issue. But I would encourage you to report it to Adobe as a bug. (Link is in my sig)
Cheers... Rick ![]()
Helpful and Handy Links Begin learning Captivate 5 moments from now! $29.95 Captivate Wish Form/Bug Reporting Form |
Any update on this issue? I recently upgraded from Captivate 4 to 5 and am having the same frustrating experience. I can only record 4-5 slides at a time before this happens to me and with a large project ahead of me I am considering returning to Captivate 4.
On a separate but related note, I have also had several situations where using the record audio option crashes my entire computer, forcing me to reboot. Anyone else have this problem?
Thanks!
More input...
Recalibrating doesn't seem to prevent the error for me.
Captivate seems to lose its place with the counter that is tracking the audio recordings.
When the error occurs, the message is "unnamed audio clip", whereas when things are working well, the clips are numbered sequentially.
I thought maybe saving might be triggering the audio crashes, but apparently that has nothing to do with the problem. Even if I don't save, the issue comes up every 6 or 7 recordings.
I figure I'm losing almost 5 minutes every time I have to save, exit, re-launch and re-calibrate the mic. What a disappointment!
I am using an older Andrea headset, non-USB, and it worked fine with Captivate 4; no audio "crashes".
--Linda
A new update on this.
I recently installed a new sound card. (Xonar DX - I love it!)
Every now and then, when I've been recording audio for a few slides, the Captivate settings switch the Audio Input Device from the Microphone setting to the Wave setting, and Captivate 5 "loses" the microphone. I switch it back, and continue as usual.
This may be what's been happening all along, but I can't check it now. Maybe the Audio Input Device lost its setting. It would fit with the symptoms.
Thanks for the update.
I will pass this on to the developers:
"Every now and then, when I've been recording audio for a few slides, the Captivate settings switch the Audio Input Device from the Microphone setting to the Wave setting, and Captivate 5 "loses" the microphone. I switch it back, and continue as usual.
This may be what's been happening all along, but I can't check it now. Maybe the Audio Input Device lost its setting. It would fit with the symptoms."
Glad you are enjoying your new sound card.
Regarding sound cards, a question: Since I'm working on a laptop with only a sound chip on the motherboard, would you or any other forum member be willing to recommend a microphone that might "defeat" some of the hissing I get in my recordings?
I'd spend as much as $200 if I felt confident of better sound results.
Thanks!
--Linda
Hi Linda
I'm sure others will chime in on this. But it is my own understanding that you want anything USB connected. If it's USB connected, I understand that the sound card is bypassed as USB devices are totally digital and have their own way of dealing with the audio.
Cheers... Rick ![]()
Helpful and Handy Links Begin learning Captivate 5 moments from now! $29.95 Captivate Wish Form/Bug Reporting Form |
LPWebb wrote:
...but was worried about dating myself...
That's a valid concern! Of all the people I dated. I liked myself the least! ![]()
Cheers... Rick ![]()
Helpful and Handy Links Begin learning Captivate 5 moments from now! $29.95 Captivate Wish Form/Bug Reporting Form |
I have been having the same problem. I have an external sound card that I use when recording narration. When I record narration, after a few successful slides, Captivate will start switching to "wave/midi/cd" as the sound device. I change it back under settings to my sound card and sometimes it works, but most times it will look like it changed, but when I record it will not work. I will go back to settings and see that it switched it back to the wave setting. I keep switching it back to my sound card and it will usually eventually work, but it continues happening. It is taking me three times as long to complete my project as it should. I will also get a message about a sound error when it cannot find any device. I usually end of shutting down and rebooting, but it repeats itself again.
I am using Windows Vista. I had previously had some different sound problems with Captivate 4, and had such high hopes for Captivate 5 . . .
I applied a recent Captivate patch a few weeks ago, but experienced no changes in the sound issues we've been reporting here.
I have sent the Captivate 5 development team a sample of a file where two things have been occurring:
Upon analysis, the team did see the issue, and think that the problem was occurring with very large files. Is that perhaps the case with those of you who are experiencing sound problems?
They also suggested a workaround for the dropped audio, but it did not correct my issue. It only caused drops at the beginning of the affected clips instead.
To fix the problem for the current deadline-driven project,, I re-created around affected 20 slides and then, hoping to avoid re-recording the audio, imported the audio from the problem slide. That corrected the clipping issue, suggesting that perhaps the cause of the problem is somehow in the code and/or the slide -- and not directly in the MP3 file.
I have a large project coming up, and regrettably, I'm going to use Captivate 4 so I don't risk adding uncompensated troubleshooting time to my work.
The developers are aware of all the sound issues. I encourage you to continue to report bug issues at their site, and to post any insights here.
I'm very impressed with some of the new UI features and efficiencies in CA 5, but feel that it is critical that the audio be corrected and thoroughly tested on all user hardware platforms.
--Linda
My files aren't very long - maybe 50-60 slides at most. I don't have the problem with dropped audio, just the dropped sound driver.
I actually start out with a driver list of 5, because of my sound card. Then it drops to 2, choosing the wrong one. If I continue to hang in there, selecting and re-selecting the correct driver, it ends up with none, and no longer recognizes that I have a microphone attached.
Ditto here. Exactly the same issue.
It works fine for 20-30 slides then loses the microphone. I reset it back but find the microphone list has now shortened. It goes fine for a few more slides and then does the same thing. Eventually there are no microphones to choose from and the only way to get back to square one is to reboot.
I'd like to blame something other than Captivate 5 but this issue doesn't occur with Cp4 or any other recording software.
I've already filed a bug report about it.
A patch would be most welcome.
I worked some months back with the developers.
They had me try a workaround in some test files and also took a look at a file I sent them in which I was experiencing the lockup and clipping problem.
Their suggestions for workarounds did not address enough of the audio issues.
Especially with large files, I was still getting clipped endings on some audio, and was also experiencing the lockups and need to re-boot.
Sadly, I've reverted to V4 for my production work because I was losing too many hours to workarounds for a software problem.
Then I noticed that even in V4, I experienced some similiar issues with clipped audio, although not as much as in v5. The lockups do not exist for me in v4.
I did learn over time that if I add silent time at the end of a recording in order to compensate for Captivate potentially clipping the end of a sound recording, I set focus earlier in the track by clicking. That seems to eliminate much of the clipping issues. Sometimes I just record a few seconds or two without speaking, and then of course make that section silent.
I'm not a developer, but my sense is that if any of the code from v4 was used as part of the v5 audio code development, the problem was potentially migrated over.
I know the developers are aware of and workingn on these issues, but I'm not privvy to any specific patch schedule that addresses this further.
It's a fairly new laptop, and everything is up to date. The laptop is usually very quick to process things when using other programs. I have run updates, done disk cleans, defrags, etc... and it doesn't stop the problems with Captivate.
I just got Captivate about 1 month ago, and have loaded all updates, and I check for new ones every day. I have used it quite a bit since that time, and have noticed that the larger my file gets (over 100 slides) the worse the performance gets. Like taking forever just to update a change on one slide.
I am resorting to doing the audio recording outside of captivate, as I can't afford to lose anymore time on my projects.
Yes, we have expereinced this also. We can tell Captivate is not recording becasue there is no VU meter output. I don;t know why this happens, but I now expect it to happen a handful of times when developing 90 slides or so. We go into AUDIO, SETTINGS and check the input device, pre amp levels and reset them. Can Adobe tell us WHY this is occurring? It feels like Captivate is not stable. JR
I totally agree... Captivate is not stable at all! I have resorted to recording audio on a Blank Project, with just one slide. Then I save it as a podcast, instead of adding it right to a slide. Later I'll go back and import the audio to the proper slides.
I thought this might help, however, it does not! Even on a blank project, with NOTHING saved to the project, Captivate CRASHES after 3 or 4 recordings... This is ridiculous... How can Adobe even pretend to say this is ready for Market, and actually charge money for it! It doesn't do what it is supposed to do! Don't they have a Quality Assurance Department??
Captivate could be an Awesome Product, IF it actually worked correctly... but it doesn't. I would not recommend Captivate to anyone until they get it repaired... too much time is wasted dealing with these errors.
Hiya I have just purchased Adobe 5 (May 2011) and very disappointed that mine is behaving like others have described. I have to deliver a project and no device error messages are being displayed and crashing is occurring. I have reported the problem and the response is to try another mic at this stage! Has anyone else had a resolution?
There is no resolution, since Adobe doesn't admit there's a problem. It seems to happen with sound cards, not with built-in sound.
One thing I've found that seems to help a little - my sound card has an application that allows me to switch between the headset and speakers. The first couple of times Captivate loses the microphone, I can click the drop arrow in Settings and re-select the microphone. After doing this a couple of times, the drop-down list loses the microphone altogether. At that point, I can use the sound card application to switch headset to speakers and back again. That seems to re-apply the microphone to the drop-down list, and I can choose it again.
Everything's just a work-around, though.
I have also found, closing down Captivate, and reopening the project, "resets" the software to again recognize the M-Audio interface we are using with our condenser microphone and to accept the channel and pre-amp values that we originally preset. Thanks for sharing and continue luck on your project. Work arounds rock!
Jim Richmond
e-Learning/Career Management Services
Right Management
4000 Piedmont Parkway
High Point NC 27265
United States
Phone +1 919 403 5615
Mobile +1 336 259 9524
www.right.com
Try this: If you are using a condenser microphone and an A/D interface, look up the speaker/microphone source under the "Control Panel" and "Sound/Audio Settings" and select the device you want to use. You should see it in the menu. If you have done that, and Captivate messes with your settings while you are midstream into your project, save what you have, exit Captivate and reopen it, then check all your settings, and reset as necessary. This is what we have to do EVERYtime we work on a new project. It isn't pretty but it works for us at this time. Good luck
Jim Richmond
e-Learning/Career Management Services
Right Management
4000 Piedmont Parkway
High Point NC 27265
United States
Phone +1 919 403 5615
Mobile +1 336 259 9524
www.right.com
Not sure if this will help or not, but I actually received a call from Adobe the other day, regarding my download of the trial version of Captivate 5. My boss purchased it for work, and I downloaded the trial version at home to practice. So I was happy to explain all of my problems with the program to the girl on the other end. I also told her that myself and many others had been posting on the forums about these problems. She told me that she would pass along my comments to their "engineers" and that they had seen the postings on the forum, so they were aware of the problems and were working on it. I halfway believe that is just what she says to anyone with concerns. I do believe that if enough our our complaints are on here, Adobe has to realize it will hurt their sales of Captivate. As much time as Captivate has cost me in production, we would have been better off to buy a more expensive program to start with! We'll see if they actually do something about it now.
North America
Europe, Middle East and Africa
Asia Pacific