can't find the option anywhere.
Thanks.
If you can, please file a feature request for the playhead to keep playing when locating to a new place in the Timeline: http://www.adobe.com/go/wish.
Here's a video that shows the uninterrupted playback feature in action:
http://www.video2brain.com/en/lessons/adjustment-layers-applying-effec ts-and-continuous-playback
i thought playback would helpfully (and requested) continue while i checked timelines, sequences, etc.
The project window and workspaces aren't irrelevant to everyone. Much work was done to continue playback in as many cases as possible, when doing so makes sense.
How would PPro know that you didn't want to switch to that other timeline, or sequence? It would be pretty frustrating if you couldn't interrupt playback to go play a different sequence.
i agree completely.
"It would be pretty frustrating if you couldn't interrupt playback to go play a different sequence." - that would just be idiotic. Thats probably why it doesnt happen.
"The project window and workspaces aren't irrelevant to everyone" - i suspect they are not irrelevent to anyone. Thats probably why they are included.
Now to spell it out, as i think you may not have understand what i meant...
Having playback continue while changing workspace may be a whoop-di-doo for some. But i dont know of anyone who will benefit. Everyone i know has their favorite workspace laid out and thats that.
Having playback continue while clicking on say the timeline, or maybe sequences, say i'm looking for something similar, or reminding myself of clip length...
Now that would have been something to shout about.
[unconstructive comments ignored]
So, if sequence 1 is playing back somewhere near time T, and you decide to click somewhere else in the sequence 1 timeline (time Z), or click on sequence 2's timeline near time Y, you think PPro should ignore those clicks, and keep playing back sequence 1, time T?
That's the behavior you seem to be requesting—yet you also describe it as idiotic. I agree that such behavior would inspire a lot of shouting, but not the good kind.
[deep breath, count to ten...]
i did not "dismiss as idiotic" your description. I agreed with your original comment "It would be pretty frustrating if you couldn't interrupt playback". Maybe you are partisipating with a few conversations at once and genuinely not understanding what i've already said.
For Example - playing a clip in Source and click in Project. source stops. it would be nice to have the option that it doesnt stop.
Example - playing a clip A in Project and clicking on Sequence B. Again it would be beneficial to have the option of not auto-stopping.
i could go on.
To make it crystal, it would give more power to the user (surely the goal of Adobe developers) to have play continue until the USER decides it should stop. Either by option, or choosing to select/play another clip.
This is clearly a case of developers 'choosing' a behaviour, and not implementing options to have it any other way.
Anyway, food for thought.
Example A: agreed, makes sense.
Example B is the case I was trying to confirm.
If clip A is playing, and you click on sequence B in the project window, you want clip A to keep playing? Counter-intuitive to some, but again, I can see why you'd want that.
The case for which I didn't understand the use case, is this: if clip A is playing in source monitor, and you click somewhere in some sequence's timeline, would you actually want clip A to keep playing? Doesn't clicking in a sequence's timeline imply that you want to do/see something in that sequence, and in that case wouldn't you want clip A to stop playing?
playing a clip in Source and click in Project. source stops. it would be nice to have the option that it doesnt stop.
That would be very strange and I'd argue unwanted behavior by most.
playing a clip A in Project and clicking on Sequence B. Again it would be beneficial to have the option of not auto-stopping.
Ditto.
just the other day i was playing a clip searching for a few spoken sentences i needed. I remembered they were there somewhere. So the clip was playing... At the same time i wanted to go through my sequences to find a particular combination of clips/effects/structure that was going to come in handy again...
The only way to multitask was to play the clip in a (non-adobe) player. It would have been nice to not have to switch programs.
At the same time i wanted to go through my sequences
I think that situation would be rare enough to make it a PITA if everyone else had to hit some kind of modifier to make that playback stop when switching to a new sequence. The assumption is that doing so, you will want to play what's in that sequence.
It's a good assumption, I think, for the vast majority of situations.
I have the exact same question, I am used to Final Cut Pro, and like that the timeline keeps playing even if I jump to next edit point for instance. As it is now Premiere behaves like Avid and stops.
I see that Premiere plays even if I switch to other programs, but thatś not the feature I need. (please correct me if I am wrong)
The assumption is that by moving the CTI manually, you want it to be where it ends up. To have it keep playing would be contrary behavior and outstandingly frustrating to the overwhelming majority of editors, I think. Retapping that space bar is not such a huge deal for the miniscule amount of times an editor might need to keep playing.
Hi Elnar,
Please file a feature request if you want playback to behave like that: http://www.adobe.com/go/wish
Just filed a request, thanks for that link. I'll also post it here for the board.
*******Enhancement / FMR*********
-Brief title for your desired feature:
Uninterrupted playback when moving the CTI
-How would you like the feature to work?
During playback, I'd like to be able to click somewhere else on the timeline (usually scanning ahead) and have it jump to that point and continue playing. Instead, I click ahead and playback stops. Then I have to hit spacebar to begin playing again. This sounds like a little thing, but I do it hundreds of times a day when editing.
-Why is this feature important to you?
This feature is something that I've found useful in FCP for a decade, so it's a big loss.
Just filed my own Feature Request.
*******Enhancement / FMR*********
-Brief title for your desired feature:
Normal behavior when manually adjusting the playhead position.
-How would you like the feature to work?
During playback, if I move the playhead to a new position, I'd like it to remain there until I manually initiate playback once again. Having playback continue after I put the playhead where I want it would be incredibly frustrating.
-Why is this feature important to you?
Because programs that do things 'automatically' without user initiation are very frustrating to use. I want the software to do what I tell it to do, not what it wants to do.
I've just reread this thread in its entirety, and i see its now a classic example of Adobes forums. So i will be referencing this thread in a news article about to be published.
In brief, it illustrates nicely the (incorrect) way many large corporations work; people ask for a feature or change, and they are told they are wrong to even ask. Later the feature arrives mysteriously and those that dont like it ask for a reversal. Now these people are ignored or told they are wrong.
And the obvious solution of having a toggle or setting isnt implemented for another year..
(an obvious example is Windows 8 desktop - next year we''l be able to swap GUI with a click, instead of the fiddeling required at the moment)
Till then, keep claiming "the keyboards the only professional way to work" from Bluffers Guide to being a Professional.
I've just reread this thread in its entirety, and i see its now a classic example of Adobes forums. So i will be referencing this thread in a news article about to be published.
We look forward to your scathing exposé.
Once published, please post a link here so all
Adobe users will benefit from your wisdom and insight.
1. You did not originate this thread.
2. Aside from your semi-heated exchange with another user,
there were no contentious comments in this thread.
3. The only Adobe presence is a posted feature request link.
4. Your last post to this thread was Jun 1, 2012.
I just read through this also. I agree with the request in Post #30 - however I would be willing to accept a modifier.
After some work I was doing last night, I now see the advantages of clicking "Play In to Out" and have it start at the in point, and if I want to jump ahead to just before the out point, I could Ctrl-click or Alt-click (or whatever) on where I want it to resume without having to hit the spacebar again. Better yet, let me set something in Preferences to avoid the modifier.
I don't actually need it in the Sequence timeline as much as I need it on the Source Monitor timeline while I am making subclips - making sure they start and end exactly where I want them. But it might as well get added both places. I have been editing a long time but seldom made subclips. My latest project has forced me into it.
I also want the software to do what I tell it to do, and this time, I want to tell it to continue to play from wherever on the timeline I click, following the previous command's instructions. Which might have just been "Play", but in my case would be "Play In to Out".
If I click on anything other than the timeline, I would expect the video to stop playing, of course. But if I had a second setting in Preferences, perhaps it could just play until I told it to stop or it came to the end (unless looped).
Sun of a gun. Those darned FCP people came up with something I also need. The temperature in Hell just fell to below 32 degrees Fahrenheit, Submitting a close copy of post #30 as well as a new one for my exact needs, as follows:
My second request is as follows:
(Edit: Please note that these are actual submissions. )
To all who agree with cmataxis (and me since I literally copied this request into my own) , I heard from an old friend at Adobe that this feature is also desired by people at Adobe who will help make sure it gets onto the "Big Board" of feature requests. Not sure exactly what that means but it sounds quite encouraging.
You may have read other posts of mine that indicate that I want people to be careful about what they ask for. If we make sure to ask for things like this, that would be great time savers, and avoid some of the other features that are not as useful, (or that simply would not be as widely appreciated) we can help guide Adobe towards the creation of the product that we really want Premiere Pro to be. They do listen. So if we choose wisely, the Adobe engineers have the skills needed to create magic*.
Arthur C. Clarke
North America
Europe, Middle East and Africa
Asia Pacific