| No question, just a comment for the PS developers. | After reading about some of the new features in CS6, I decided to upgrade without skipping a version. However, then I learned that the intefac had been significatly redesigned. Learning a new interface constitutes a time consuming waste of time to me. I would rather spend my time processing my images than in learning a new interface. Consequently, I will not be upgrading to CS6.. I hope this gets passed on to the Adobe developers. |
So your message for the Adobe developers is create no changes on future versions? If you want to stay locked in time that is your choice, but don't think most users would agree. There is a long list sent in by users of feature requests to cater to specific desires, of which very few will get implemented.
Photoshop 7 was an excellent program, and even after 10 years many are still using it.
Are you aware that if you do not upgrade to CS6 before 12/31/12 future versions will cost full price? Yea, I agree that change sucks.
Absolutely not. I appreciate new useful tools and features, this is why I generally have the most recent version. However, as I thought I made clear, but apparently did not, what i object to is having to spend time learning a new scheme to access the tools and features that I already use. It seems to me that older tools can be improved and new ones added without having to relearn how to access everything.
If you miss the deadline you will have to pay full price, unless Adobe caves on the upgrade policy which means you have to upgrade to each version, no skipping.
The interface is a little different to allow you to alter the color of the background gray, crop tool changed, and some background re-programming with blur and liquify filter. Has put a bigger burden on GPU which is causing the GPU makers to scramble to build new drivers. Can't think of much else that has changed.
Doug, what are you talking about?
Photoshop's user interface has ABSOLUTELY NOT been "significantly redesigned".
Having said what you said, I'm left to wonder whether you're commenting on a completely different application, or having a very specific problem. This is Photoshop CS6 we're talking about, right? Had you customized your prior version heavily? What version was it that you upgraded from?
There have been some things added that make it look different by default - e.g.:
In fact, across many, many major version releases of Photoshop the usability is substantially the same. You can start Photoshop 6.0 today and apply many of the same techniques as with Photoshop CS6. This is one thing the Adobe people have gotten right.
How long have you been using Photoshop CS6, and what parts do you find different?
I've used every version of Photoshop myself daily for almost 20 years, and moving from Photoshop CS5 to CS6 has been utterly trivial! It probably represents one of the most easy to deal with upgrades I've been through with any application.
I recommend you actually try using it for a while before commenting on the changes.
And by all means list the specific things you find distasteful and we can discuss how to smooth your transition. ![]()
-Noel
Noel,
Thank you very much for your detailed comments. I have not used CS6; I have only read a couple of reviews of it and it appears that perhaps they were not saying what I thought they were. Your comments have been most useful and I greatly appreciatte everyones efforts at getting me straight on this. I think you have changed my mind; especially that comment about having to pay full price if I wait too long! ;-)
Great! I suggest before making a purchase decision you download the 1 month free trial and give it a run yourself!
And as I mentioned, feel free to post your specific thoughts here - those of us who have been through the transition will be more than willing to help you get through it.
-Noel
My misunderstanding there was I thought it was Adobe's policy to offer the discounted upgrade price to the users of the last three releases and thus, if I waited until CS7, my CS5 would only be two versions old. So I gather this present offer to CS 3 4 & 5 version is a one-off & apparently only applicable to Cloud.
You can read the official policy here: http://www.adobe.com/products/creativesuite/faq/upgrade-policy.html?PI D=2159997
The default look of PsCS6 is different (easily changed back to a lighter UI), but functionally pretty much the same as previous versions.
The only change I have had a hard time getting used to is the new Crop Tool. I really liked it at first... I thought it had some smart changes in its UI. But after a few months of using it daily, I find it not very intuitive (for me). I always have to think about what I want it to do. I hope Adobe works on it more for next version of PS.
The only change I have had a hard time getting used to
Some things seem to have been changed without regard for efficient use – changing a path’s Path Operation is now a two-click-task but was a one-click-task before.
Annoying but not tragic and maybe that can be remedied in the future.
Edit:
Thanks S2,
I knew most of what she showed, but as always with Ms. Kost I learned a few things I did not.
The Crop Tool changes I have found hardest to get used are having to think about which "Front Image" choice I want (It used to be just one button, now I have four choices)
And I don't like how there is no indication if you have a Crop Preset to resample. I posted another image here (I can track it down Monday) where I have the Crop Preset doing three very different things, yet the info displayed in its command bar is identical.
Also, unlike other presets, you can not rename a crop preset. What is shown below is the default naming by Adobe for a Crop Preset.
here it is:
I agree that it's unacceptable to have stuff exceed the space given by default, with no way to widen the field. What's the problem with using more horizontal space?
Would that be the vicinity of Linville Falls, NC, Charles? Seems awfully familiar looking to me.
-Noel
charles badland wrote:
And I don't like how there is no indication if you have a Crop Preset to resample. I posted another image here (I can track it down Monday) where I have the Crop Preset doing three very different things, yet the info displayed in its command bar is identical.
Also, unlike other presets, you can not rename a crop preset. What is shown below is the default naming by Adobe for a Crop Preset.
There are two types of crop presets which you can name as you like, therefore you can include the resulting dimensions and pixel density in the name.
There's the Tool Preset kind that stores all of a tool's otions, which you name when creating and which can be renamed in the Presets Manager.
There's the crop dimensions and density preset which you can name as you prefer, or accept the Ps suggested name, when saving it. If you want to rename one of these presets, select it, save again with new name, delete old preset.
Hi Noel,
Nope, wrong coast.
We went to Yosemite two months ago. That is a section of of pic overlooking Vernal Falls.
But I did visit Linville Falls, NC... maybe 15 years ago? Beautiful area.
Here is the whole pic (a quickly throw together stitch/composite) That is the backside of Half Dome at the top. My wife and kid are quite a bit above the falls. For scale, look at the little black specs of people to the right of the falls. This is where, not too long ago, three young adults tragically died (trying to save one another) crossing over the guardrail for photo-ops in the river at the top of the falls.
North America
Europe, Middle East and Africa
Asia Pacific