hello , I have one question in mind. I have read in an article,
Adobe Premiere Pro CS5 Workflow Guide -
Using Adobe® Premiere® Pro CS5 with tapeless Sony XDCAM content
This article says we do not need to transcode XDCAM EX1 or EX3 files , for editing as CS5, CS5.5 and CS6 natively supports the editing of these files.
But when we finish a project then what we do, in which format do we export to archive the edited master. because MPEG2 and H.264 are for disrtibution purpose, but
when we are talking of archiving then we need sobe robust format and codec. please explain me , I have searched a lot but get confused in different forums.
All suggestions are welome.....
It depends what and why you are wantng to archive.
I do not archive the master edit per se, as I don't see the need. In my view, archiving the edited master (for corporate work) harks back to days of tape when it was costly to re-digitize the rushes for a re-edit. At least, with an edited master, there was a starting point, even though we were going down a generation.
With hard drives so inexpensive, I archive the entire project - and that includes the native MP4 rushes from my EX1R together with all output formats that the clients have requested.
In this way the rushes remain unchanged and the project is ready at a moment's notice to re-output in any format that may be required.
If you must archive, an uncompressed format, such as uncompressed avi is good unless you want to use 3rd party codecs such as Cineform
hello Jon-M-Spear, what you are saying is correct , but this way I have to keep not only camera footage but also cache files, other graphic files etc. which I have used.
My project was an event shot with 5 camera set up , and of around 4 hour duration , so this way I will have keep 20 hrs of footage for a final of 4 hrs of event.
please explain any other way out,
And as you suggested uncompressed avi, but there is no option of uncompressed avi as I am working on MAC ,,,,
need advice seriously....
Mac has equivalent uncompressed codecs: Quicktime or Pro-res spring to mind.
You could always trim the project in Project Manager (leaving sufficient handles for a good tweak in the future) and archive the project, keeping only the material used in the edit.
i was also planning for project manager, but what you suggest as a second option, geting a .mov file with applying codec such as Avid DNxHD, pro res or as my footage
is XDCAM EX3, so applying XDCAM EX3 (35mbps). So 3 options , which is accepted cross platforms, more robust and edit friendly in future....
UT is a free and lossless codec that works on both Macs and Windows machines. It also works very well with Adobe software. It's a good choice for a Master export.
Hello Jim, thanks for your reply , I am not getting the download option for MAC. One thing more to ask, I have not heard much for this codec .
One thing more, as we are discussing for exporting XDCAM EX footage out of Premier CS5 , do we also need to apply any intermideate codec when we import such footage into premier.
Please throw some light on this also....
No you don't need a intermediate. Basically with mastering you basically have 4 main choices IMO if you want it to work well on both PC and MAC and not lose picture info. (mostly)
You could use UT, DNxHD,CineForm, or ProRes
Keep in mind though that DNxHD, ProRes and CineForm aren't lossless, they are however visually lossless. However they take up less space than UT does.
So it's all really a trade off.
As you people have said, about using DNxHD, Prores, Cineform etc. but aren't these are also intermediate codes. When we don't need them at time
of import XDCAM EX3 footage then why are these required for export. I have studied various artilcle also on different forums but have not understood them.
Cineform is actually free now. But you're correct about ProRes on PC. You can use Cineform for free by downloading the free version of Cineform GoPro studio which in turn allows you to access and use the Cineform codec for free from premiere pro's media encoder. The only restriction when using the now free cineform codec is that you can't do anything bigger than 1920x1080.
(Which for my current workflow doesn't bother me at all.)
To answer the OP's question though you need visually lossless and lossless codecs like the ones mentioned in certain cases.
For instance if I want to save a full quality copy of a edited project but I don't want to keep all my source files, then I make a high quality master using either Lagarith, DNxHD, UT, ProRes,Cineform etc.
Also if I want to edit a promo that I will use again in multiple TV shows and the people I work with will also need this specific promo for when they require this promo to edit with, then in this case I would also
export it in one of these formats I have mentioned above. Because I don't want the file to lose quality but I also need a way to be able to let other people and myself use this file.
Another reason you would use these file types is because if a specific animation is really graphic intesive and requires a lot of rendering to preview properly it is extremely handy to export you animation
then import it and it requires much less cpu/gpu power to process because it's only playing a video now instead of playing tons of layers and effects etc. That is why these types of codecs are necessary
because you need them around unless you want to lose quality in the situations I have mentioned above. I'm sure I have probably left out several scenarios but now you should get the idea.