Any info on when canon 5d mark III will be able to worked tethered in Lightroom 4
Canon must release their SDK (Software Development Kit) that includes support for the 5D.3 before Adobe can work on tethering, so keep checking in the Software and Drivers section of Canon’s 5D.3 info to see when the SDK is shown, and then give Adobe enough months to get their part done, afterwards:
On other, older camera pages, the SDK is listed below the Select OS area. For example here is the 60D page that shows the latest SDK was April 2011:
http://www.usa.canon.com/cusa/consumer/products/cameras/slr_cameras/eo s_60d#DriversAndSoftware
We currently have SDK compatibility for the EOS 5D Mark III supporting EDSDK 2.11. Check out the link below for more information!http://www.usa.canon.com/cusa/consumer/standard_display/sdk_homepage
ssprengel wrote:
Canon must release their SDK (Software Development Kit) that includes support for the 5D.3 before Adobe can work on tethering, so keep checking in the Software and Drivers section of Canon’s 5D.3 info to see when the SDK is shown, and then give Adobe enough months to get their part done, afterwards:
Then how do you explain that Aperture 3 has had tethering support for the 5DmkIII (and the 1Dx) since May 2012?
and Capture One supports it too.
ssprengel wrote:
Canon must release their SDK (Software Development Kit) that includes support for the 5D.3 before Adobe can work on tethering, so keep checking in the Software and Drivers section of Canon’s 5D.3 info to see when the SDK is shown, and then give Adobe enough months to get their part done, afterwards:
Like I posted anove, I asked Canon.. and they sent me this response
We currently have SDK compatibility for the EOS 5D Mark III supporting EDSDK 2.11. Check out the link below for more information!http://www.usa.canon.com/cusa/consumer/standard_display/sdk_homepage
By Victoria Bampton - 8:23 AM on August 28, 2012 Reply
Canon 5dMk3 tethering is not available in this RC. I can’t comment on whether that will change for the 4.2 final release though.
You know Adobe needs to give money to the camera manufactures so they can have access to a special SDK's that allows ADOBE to develop software that the manufacturers are not willing to develop themselves. The ability to tether in Lightroom with my 5dMKIII is just one of the features that I am missing out on. I have a cobbled workaround, but it is lame. Capture one can tether a 5d mkIII but they have some weird stipulations, for example they cannot bring a Raw M or Raw S file into the application. The Canon SDK for the new gen of Cameras is really a tough nut to crack, so it seems. Speaking to Julieanne Kost in person she say the tethering option is not available and she does not know when it will be available. She didn't give me specifics, she did say if more customers complain about not having the feature that the Lightroom team would make it a priority. So Here goes, Dear Lightroom Team Please get your stuff together and make tethering in Lightroom 4 a top Priority!
Date: Tue, 18 Sep 2012 09:06:50 -0600
From: forums@adobe.com
Subject: Re: canon 5d mark III tethered to Lightroom 4 canon 5d mark III tethered to Lightroom 4
Re: canon 5d mark III tethered to Lightroom 4
created by ben anders in Photoshop Lightroom - View the full discussion
Any more news on this issue Adobe?? The SDK has been out for 4 months now...
Please note that the Adobe Forums do not accept email attachments. If you want to embed a screen image in your message please visit the thread in the forum to embed the image at http://forums.adobe.com/message/4707411#4707411
Replies to this message go to everyone subscribed to this thread, not directly to the person who posted the message. To post a reply, either reply to this email or visit the message page: Re: canon 5d mark III tethered to Lightroom 4
To unsubscribe from this thread, please visit the message page at Re: canon 5d mark III tethered to Lightroom 4. In the Actions box on the right, click the Stop Email Notifications link.
Start a new discussion in Photoshop Lightroom by email or at Adobe Forums
For more information about maintaining your forum email notifications please go to http://forums.adobe.com/message/2936746#2936746.
Rikk Flohr wrote:
And the SDK kit is broken (see Post 18).
So? ... it hasn't held back other developers to offer support ...
Anyone who is using Mac OS X 10.7.x or 10.8.x (just be sure to have the latest RAW image updates for OS X installed) ... You can use the included Image Capture app (found in the Applications folder) to tether any camera listed as being supported by Apple (about 60 cameras in all) then just point Lr to to "watch" the folder where IC saves the images ... no fuss, no muss, no having to wait while Adobe, Canon and Apple all point fingers at each other ... and make excuses for not offering support ...
Image Capture is a plain app with no frills ... but it can help get the job done until a better solution comes along ...
Cameras supported are listed here: http://tinyurl.com/8b8hebw
Surely the obligation to provide support for your camera functions is with the camera manufacturer. Adobe is providing anciliary services, which enhances your productivity and the value of the product you paid the camera manufacturer for. More pressure should be placed on the manafucturer of the product you purchased. Refuse to buy the product untill you can get the service of your choice i.e. Support from the processing software of your choice. Your camera manufacturer has to ensure this happens.
Just an opinion.
I think the point several posters are trying to make is that two competing products to LR support tethered 5dmkiii function, so 1) the SDK must have been available to some folks in time to provide functionality and 2) the function seems to work on those two products, so the SDK can’t be as broken as suggested by Adobe.
I believe some providers are prepared to "crack" the code, Adobe wants permission/instruction to do so.
Your camera manufacturer provides software for you to process raw files from their cameras and expect/prefer you to use their products. They do not appear to be co-operative in enhancing competition from third party products.
hhansard wrote:
I think the point several posters are trying to make is that two competing products to LR support tethered 5dmkiii function, so 1) the SDK must have been available to some folks in time to provide functionality and 2) the function seems to work on those two products, so the SDK can’t be as broken as suggested by Adobe.
2. The SDK is reported broken by Canon with a fix promised for early October. Capture One is recommending as a work around to downgrade back to Lion from Mountain Lion to restore functionality.
DdeGannes wrote:
Refuse to buy the product untill you can get the service of your choice i.e. Support from the processing software of your choice. Your camera manufacturer has to ensure this happens.
Just an opinion.
While I do agree with your opinion in theory ... I seriously doubt that we could ever force the camera makers to bend to our wishes through a boycott to "ensure" that third party software developers can provide support for "ancillary services" ... otherwise the good folks at Adobe wouldn't have to reinvent the wheel each and every time a new RAW file is introduced ... third party developers can and do find solutions that are not interdependent upon others ... it only takes some initiative and commitment ... otherwise how do you explain the success of other developers who have achieved this feature? All of the excuses, explanations and hand wringing that goes on here flies in the face of actual results ... in my opinion ... they hold no credibility as to a legitimate reason for the lack of support ... the proof is in the pudding.
As I have said in another thread ... we aren't talking about something that is so difficult or intricate as sending a manned spacecraft to Mars ... we're only discussing the simple transmission of image files via a USB cable to a computer hard drive so the processing software can access the image file ... it can't be as difficult or impossible to offer because other developers have accomplished the task ... some did so months ago ...
DdeGannes wrote:
"I believe some providers are prepared to "crack" the code, Adobe wants permission/instruction to do so"
I'll buy that reasoning ... if you can share proof positive that Adobe waits until they have "permission and instruction" for each new CR2 or NEF file that comes out ... or do they go to work on their own as soon as they have the camera in-hand ...
==> "I believe some providers are prepared to "crack" the code, Adobe wants permission/instruction to do so"
i don't buy that argument at all. If you look at the history of ACR, you see many interviews with TK about his team's efforts at reverse engineering (i.e. cracking) the proprietary formats and control coding.
==> The SDK is reported broken by Canon with a fix promised for early October. Capture One is recommending as a work around to downgrade back to Lion from Mountain Lion to restore functionality.
You mean just like LR 4.1 is broken and we are waiting for 4.2? ![]()
Sure there are issues with the SDK (there are issues with every SDK I have ever programmed against -- and that has been more than a few), but it does not change the fact that some have the function operating by working around the issues. I would agree with your assessment that the issue is completely with Canon had everyone failed to make it work... But some have, so there must be aportioned blame.
As for the general argument that it is all Canon's responsibility to make the functionality available... Well that doesn't wash either. Users want teathering -- that makes teathering a competitive feature. It's Canon's responsibility to provide hooks into the hardware and integration support. Adobe is responsible for delivering end-user-capability and working with hardware mfgs to make it happen. At the end of the day, folks are going to buy Nikon, Canon etc and expect their integrated workflow to operate. Folks will purchase their workflow tool based on stability/features/etc. Saying a boycot of Canon to compel LR's tethering is a bit like the tail wagging the dog. I have $50K invested in Canon and $199 in LR...
According to this article, LR now supports 5d mk3 tethering. Seems like this is a very new development, according to the dates of the comments on this thread. Am I correct that this update just happened in the last week or two?
http://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom/kb/tethered-camera-support-lightroom- 4.html
North America
Europe, Middle East and Africa
Asia Pacific