Auto Save disfunctionality has cost me more time than I care to admit. I have heard nothing about this feature being fixed in 6.0 and found nothing after doing a search on this forum. Does anyone know if/when this will be fixed? My experience with Auto Save is that it is not reliable.
Auto Save disfunctionality has cost me more time than I care to admit.
Some bugs were fixed, but not every user request was implemneted. What specifc problem(s) are you current experiencing with auto save?
Keep in mind:
1. Autosave does not save to the current file, it creates a backup in the autosave folder.
2. By default, Premiere Pro automatically saves your project every 20 minutes and retains the last five versions of the project file on the hard disk. Both of these settings can be changed in the App Prefs>Auto Save
3. Autosave does not stop playback and does not happen in the background, so if you are doing continuous playback, it won't save a backup until you stop, at which point it will immediately do so (assuming you've passed the auto-save time limit).
My basic experience is that I set my number of saves to 100. I then go about the business of creative decision making...
I look up and realize that:
a) 2 days have passed and I am hungry
b) I have not saved the project myself
c) The only reason I stopped editing after 48 hours is that the power went off or the computer crashed or something hung up Premiere or I dropped coffee on the keyboard, or, or, or...
When I reboot the computer I find that it did indeed save 100 copies in the autosave directory, however using my paranoid settings of "save every 5 minutes" it reached saved version #100 early on the first day. After that it did nothing. It didn't start overwriting starting at #1, nor did it continuously update save #100 over and over. It simply did nothing except tell me it was auto saving ever 5 minutes with a nice onscreen message.
So it sounds like you encountered a bug where autosave stops writing new versions after the save limit is reached... Is that right?
Were those settings you mentioned literal? -- every 5 minutes, 100x max ... ?
What version was this occurring on?
Yes, autosave stops writing new versions after the save limit is reached.
And yes the settings are real. Only the times of editing were changed to protect the innocent.
My experience with this is with my 5.5 system. I haven't been able to stabilize my 6.0 system to the point of testing it.
There once was a bug...
Autosave stops working after creating number of saves specified in autosave preference setting.
1. Create a new Premiere Pro project.
2. Check your autosave preference. To speed up the testing I set it to create 5 copies at 1 minute intervals.
3. Open the directory where autosave projects are stored.
4. Grab a beer and wait for autosave projects to be created.
RESULT: The total number of autosave projects is your autosave setting -1 (i.e. if you set it to create 5 copies, you will have a total of 4). After it creates the last new file the next autosave will overwrite the first file that was created. After that, all new autosaves are created and then deleted immediately effectively giving you no new autosave versions of your project.
Does that sound like the same thing? It does to me. If so, the good news is that it has already been fixed. The bad news is that fix happened in Feb/March of 2008, during the 4.0 timeframe so you should not have been seeing it in 5.5. I'm runnign the test agin myself right now and if I see it I will re-log the bug. In the meantime, if anyone else can repro it in 6.0.2 please send me the details and I will log it for you.
When it is working for me it works correctly - saves are at the correct intervals, and it over-writes once the limit is reached.
Note that if you set the limit at 15, you get #1-15, then #1 is over-written, etc. if you look at the date created, a second generation #1 appears to have been created at the original time for #1, you have to look at the date modified to see the correct time(because the second generation is still #1) as Jim says earlier.
I think that is consistent with what JStrawn describes a couple of posts earlier, and also it is what is supposed to happen. My problem has always been, with every version of Premiere that I have used, that auto-save does not always start when I start Premiere, so I can find that you have no current back-ups.
As a test, I set autosave frequency to 1 minute and max versions to 5, and here's how it works in 6.0.2:
(Alan covered most of this correctly already so apologies if I'm repeating)
It saves these project instances into the auto save folder: 222-1.prproj, 222-2.prproj, 222-3.prproj, 222-4.prproj, 222-5.prproj
When the max is reached, it starts at 222-1.prproj agfain and workes its way down the list, over-writing each time.
You can verify this by looking at the 'modified' time for each one. There were some points where it looked like it hadn't written a project in a while bit it was because I was looking at the 'created' time which of course woule be older once the list starts being over-written. Also, I noticed that when I opened an auto-save project (e.g 222-1.prproj) a NEW auto-save folder was auto-created inside the parnet auto save folder containign the new auto save isntances, named as such: 222-1-1.prproj, 222-1-2.prproj.
That said, I'm not trying to talk anyone out of the fact that they may just be encoutnering a bug, but understanding the designed behavior will help us decipher what is or is not a bug. If things are still not working for you as expected, then either you have a system-specifc bug (which seems unlikely) or you have some other steps that you've introduced that I'm not following in my tests. Please let me know me know if the latter is the case.
Those have been my experiences too. As the AutoSave files are FIFO, if I need to access them, I first switch my folder view to Details, and sort on Date/Time, to find the latest, as ____ -3 might well be newer, than ____ -5.
I will defer judgement until I have a real edit session on my new 6.0 system. And I will assume the best.
It has been several weeks since I had the problem with 5.5 and I'm trying to remember exactly how the issue presented itself. I believe that it did give the appearance of re-writing, starting again at auto-save #1 after reaching #100, but it saved one of the very first "saved" versions instead of the current timeline. So, when I did a sort by date/time I was initially relieved to see that the last save was indeed 5 or 10 minutes prior to my crash. However, when I loaded the latest autosave it was a duplicate of one of the very first autosaves, not a save of the current timeline.
Sorry for confusion.