Hello everyone. I recently have been working on a Flash animation. Throughout the making of this animation Flash has been failing, getting "unknown errors," and just plain corrupting some of my files. Now I understand that a 200MB is a rather large animation. But anyway's I have been constantly duplicating my .fla's because of just how unreliable Flash seems to be acting when it comes to this. Finally I decided enough is enough and tried to export it. Heck, I was just going to split the animation into 2 parts if it makes Flash happy and saves my hard work from corruption. I finally found one of the backup files that is moderately new. However upon attempting to export as a QuickTime it reads
"The export failed because the operation ran out of memory."
I have tried everything to get this to work. It should work! And it shouldn't be this difficult. I'm hearing stuff about how Flash apparently fails when it comes to exporting 1920 x 1080. Is this true? In that forum I read somebody said Adobe was working on fixing it. That forum has been up since around last summer. Has anybody found a solution to this issue? I just want what I've worked very hard on to work. Please help.
(P.S. I'm on a Mac, and this is Flash Pro CS6)
You don't say how much memory you have to work with. Have you shut down everything else that you your computer has running while you are trying to export to video? One of the options in the Quicktime Export Settings window is "Store temp data:". Try the On Disk option.
It is possible to export a video from Flash at 1920 X 1080. My first guess is that your Flash movie is just too large at 200 MB. You haven't said how much memory or how much free space you have on your hard drive.
Is it possible for you to segment your Flash movie and export it to video in sections and then put it back together in a video editor?
On our hard drive we have around 45 GB left. I know it's not a whole lot but it should totally be enough for a video that's not even a minute and a half.
The animation itself is not actually 200 MB. I just checked and it is in fact 115.9 MB. That probably doesn't change anything but I though I'd let you know.
And exporting it as 2 parts and trying to put them back together in iMovie sounds fine. But how do you split apart a Flash file? I've never done that before...
1. Create a new Flash movie with the same stage size, color and frame rate as the movie that you have now.
2. Find a frame in your existing movie where you can make the cut.
3. In the timeline, select that frame in the top layer and then shift-click on the last frame at the lowest layer of the timeline. This will select all of the layers and frames for that part of the movie.
4. While those frames are selected, right click in that selection and choose "Copy Frame" from the menu that pops up.
5. Go to the new, empty movie.
6. Right click on the empty keyframe in frame 1.
7. Choose "Paste Frames" from the menu.
8. Save this new movie.
To be safe, do the same thing for the first half of the original movie. Now you will have the original movie and two "half" movies.
Try and export one of these halves as a video.
So here's what happened.
I created yet another Flash file to try and export it in pieces. EVERY single time it failed. I tried all sorts of things but it still "Fails" because apparently it ran out of memory. SO before writing this response I went to a bunch of different forums trying to hunt down the answer to this issue. One I found said that instead of letting it finish export "When last frame is reached." I should just specify the time of the last frame. Strangely, this worked. But even after the apparent successful export it just took a tiny piece of the Flash movie and spanned it over 42 second. (42 seconds is the actual time of the full clip.) So that didn't work... Then I read somewhere else that Flash is just plain bad when it comes to exporting its file to a QuickTime. And that in fact you need to convert the .swf version to a QuickTime. Though I have no idea how to export the .swf version... I really just hope I can find an answer... This is becoming pretty dang hard to export a such small file that is just around 8.5mb.
(F.Y.I. the 8.5mb is what you suggested to do. I've just been trying to export them in pieces... Yet it's still failing...)
So unless there's anymore ideas on how to make Flash decide it want to export cleanly I guess I need a .swf to .mov converter now? What do you advise?
Thanks for the continued response. I like knowing someone out there wishes to help me.
There may be any number of reasons why your movie won't export to video. The error that you get may or may not have anything to do with the problem, it may be an error message of last resort that doesn't actually describe the problem.
You want the video frame rate to be the same as the frame rate of your Flash movie. If the compressor that you choose to use allows automatic keyframing, then use the automatic option. Try setting the Data Rate to a lower value than the default if the compressor that you use chose allows that.
There may be something in your movie that is causing the problem. You might try making a very simple Flash movie and try and export that movie to video.
Is your Flash movie built at 1920 X 1080, or are you changing the size of the movie when you export it? If you are changing the movie's size, try and export the movie at its original size. If it will export at its original size, then you can take that exported video and resize it.
Yes, there are many people on forums that will tell you all about the evils of Flash. There are, indeed, many things that Flash can't do. Since there's no admission test to most forums, I'm guessing that most of the complaints are based on operator error.
There are third party applications that will convert a Flash .swf file to video. I don't know of a free one for Mac. I have no idea how well any of them work. I have never used one.
To be honest, i checked about 6-7 third party programms to do the job, just 1 really helped and did the job perfect without loosing frames. To bad its just for PC, i will still post the link to it here, so it may help others: http://www.flash-video-mx.com/flash_to_video_web/
Let's face it, video export was very big anounced in Flash CC, and guess what, again just another broken new feature. I have seen so many new things in flash over the years that really are not worth a notice. Most things are not operator errors, most things are bad programming and the lack of taking customers response serious.
My recommendation is to bypass the QT movie export completely and use one of these effective workarounds. If you were to get an export to succeed, you'd find that the framerate is completely whacked and you can't use it effectively in any non-linear editing environment. QuickTime is not a stable export movie format ever since Adobe bought Flash. I'm an animation filmmaker, and this is a workaround that I and my professional friends use:
1) export an image sequence using the PNG format, no compression, best quality. Give yourself a short frame name with an underscore after it, like "myfile_.png"
2) take the sequence of PNGs and do either one of these options:
a - use QuickTime Pro to import image sequence. Open your audio file with QT, it createsit's own file, then copy it, and then use QT manager to add it in to your video file. EXPORT a new QT using PNG compression (or other). Close/do not save this initial compiled edit. Your exported fil is the final and useable one, and is frame stable. Done.
b - import your PNG sequence into any non-linear editor, having set it's internal preferences to import stills so they last only 1 frame each. Most, like FCP or Premiere, you can also import as a media sequence or "footage" but that pre-applies a supposed FPS rate when imported. Again, you can now compile a video/audio edit and then export.
1) use SWIVEL, a free app that converts SWF files into movies, including QuickTime.
2) publish an SWF without any compression/jpg high quality /audio included
3) import into Swivel.
4) set video qualities. Codec should be QuickTime ANIMATION
5) set audio qualities
6) Export, done.
Hope this helps!
I appreciate all the responses.
Loreleip22, I'm new to some of these concepts. And while I like to think of myself as having a large knowledge of different aspects of a computer, I still may need some help. As I write this I'm exporting a piece of the animation as a PNG. However, I don't know if I have QuickTime Pro... It's just the QuickTime that came with the Mac. I sorta doubt it's Pro. But if it is, or if you still can in the basic version, how do I import the sequence?
I don't have any audio in the animation. I was hoping to add the audio in iMovie after exporting. That's why I really was hoping for a QuickTime file as iMovie seems to be most happy with them.
And also I don't really understand what a non-linear editor is...
And this Swivel. You mentioned it was a free app. Like on the Mac App Store? Or do I download it online.
I don't have Premire or any other adobe products really. I was just hoping to get Flash Pro and have my hundreads of dollars let me simply export a movie... I'm not trying to fuel the Adobe hatred fire here. These are insanely complex programs. And like any program, they fail in some departments. We're just seeing the error report and freaking out because we don't understand why they're acting up. But I still just wish it would work...
hi ProS -
if you don't have QT Pro, then you can't do this import/export method that I describe. I recommend using the Swivel method, and you can find it by doing a search, and download it online.
A non-linear editor is basically any digital video editing software, like iMovie, Final Cut Pro, or Premiere. It's called this because you can move back and forth on the timeline as you edit. This name came about as a response to the old tape-editing days, when you could only edit in one direction - forward, as you put one shot directly after another.
As far as you having PNGs explode all over your desktop - wellll.... you should have saved them to a folder. PNGs are the highest quality you can wrk with, so if you're able to be happy with JPG quality, then you could use that instead. But like I said, just use Swivel.
Loreleip22... I FREAKING LOVE YOU!
I took the step to research and download Swivel. Swivel allowed me to export my SWF file as QuickTime in a very short amount of time. There was no quality loss. There was absolutly NO issues! I'll post the animation as soon as it's up on Youtube. It still very much bugs me that I had to go to a 3rd party software to make Adobe work... But heck! It was free! Again thanks so much Loreleip22! And also I appreciate the suggestions given by everyone else.
Hello again. I know this isn't a self publicity page but, as promised, this is that animation that I needed all the help on. After about 25 days of support and development it's finally done! If you find the time, tell me what you think! I'd be overjoyed to get responses! :D
hey PS - that was really well done! Thanks for sharing, and I'm so glad to know that you've been able to bring it all the way to the finish line. Good luck with getting it out there into the world of animation-consuming people!