A few issues with the newly updated Adobe Reader app for the iPad (April 10, 2012):
1- I can mark-up a PDF with the annotation tools (pen, highlighting, underlining, etc) and then hit SAVE. When I then re-open the PDF, I do not see my comments/mark-ups,
2- From within the Adobe Reader app -- when I try the "open-in" (to another application), I receive a pop-up message: "A system error was encountered."
In step 1, are you using Adobe Reader? It doesn't sound like it, since Adobe Reader doesn't have an explicit SAVE button.
In step 2, could you confirm which "other app" you're selecting from the Ope In.. menu?
In step 1, I am using the Adobe Reader app. If you use the 'Freehand Drawing' feature to mark-up a PDF -- there is a 'Save' button in the top-right of the iPad screen.
In step 2, I was trying to 'Open in' an application called SharePlus (which allows me to access SharePoint sites).
I'm having the same problem, the annotations I made are missing when I send the edited file by email or open it in other apps. All the annotations show within adobe reader app. If I can't send the file with my annotations is useless.
I think the problem you describe is different. For SGFilipe1022, the issue is that while in Reader, the annotations are not visible after closing and opening the document within Adobe Reader. However, in your case I suspect that what you are seeing is that not all PDF Readers support the viewing of comments and markups. In particular, the previewer in Apple's Mail program for iOS does not render comments. Similarly, most PDF Readers on iOS use the device's built-in rendering to show PDFs. This also does not support viewing of annotations.
Can you please tell me where you are viewing the PDF after editing it in Reader? This will help me confirm (or disprove) my suspicion.
Of course your suspicion is correct, the annotated and form-filled PDF files can only be properly read on Mac or PC. They do not show up in the viewer on an iPad or an iPhone.
Here is the solution to this problem. As they have done in the Goodreader app, you need to add a "flatten annotations" function in Adobe Reader when exporting annotated PDFs.
It works like a charm, and is a much better solution than "hoping and praying" the recipient of my annotated PDF file views it on a desktop computer, rather than seeing a blank form on their mobile device.
Any progress on this issue? I am having the same problem. Having carefully annotated my Uni notes, I found that the latest (not all thank heavens) annotations disappear when I return to view the document (still in Reader for iPad) after leaving it to view a different PDF from the documents menu. I seem to be unable to add any more notes, although those already there remain consistently. Is there a limit to how much you can add?
Europe, Middle East and Africa