11 Replies Latest reply: Feb 25, 2009 3:11 AM by GESYMSB RSS

    New Monitor, new headache !

    GESYMSB Community Member
      As many of you know Circuit City is closing, so I grab a LG 22 inch
      LCD Monitor with a good discount.

      However..........

      It is a big differences between a CRT and a LCD, this monitor comes
      with a program named "ForteManager" that to me is no better than
      my Video Card "Catalyst" software.

      The question both of this programs create they own profile
      but I guess they are just for them because they dont
      show on my Photoshop CS3 List of Profiles.

      Then how to tell Photosho about the current setup or just
      use photoshop without any profile ?

      ( We talking about profiles like sRGB Color Space Profile.icm )

      Thanks.....
        • 1. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
          BobLevine CommunityMVP
          Two things come to mind...I would never buy anything at a going out of
          business sale because you have no recourse with the sell.

          Now...your monitor is indeed very different than a CRT but the first
          thing you need to keep in mind is the requirement that you use its
          native resolution. For most 22" monitors that's 1680x1050.

          If you have a newer video card that should be no problem, but for an
          older one it may well present an issue.

          Get that straightened out first and then worry about the color calibration.

          Bob
          • 2. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
            GESYMSB Community Member
            >Two things come to mind...I would never buy anything at a going
            >out of business sale because you have no recourse with the sell.

            No problem with me, the Dell ( Sony Trinitro ) 21 inches
            that now become my wife's monitor cost me only $10 bucks.
            From a local newspaper company.

            >For most 22" monitors that's 1680x1050.
            What this have to do with profiles ?

            >If you have a newer video card that should be no problem
            >but for an older one it may well present an issue.

            My Ati is connected using the DVI-I connector.

            >Get that straightened out first and then worry about
            Get what straightened out ?

            Thanks
            • 3. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
              dave milbut Community Member
              off topic as the OP already bought, but for others,

              circut city has been notroious about marking up then claiming "sale" prices in which the "sale" price is actually higher than the original. it pays to shop around.

              http://consumerist.com/search/circuit+city+sale/byrelevance/?timerange=month
              • 4. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                GESYMSB Community Member
                Thanks Dave, I know what you meant, the trying to sale the
                Digital Converter Box that you normally can buy for $40 bucks
                or around that, for $40 something AFTER DISCOUNT !

                But forget about that, the question is that I dont see anywere
                any indications on the Video Card software, nor the LCD
                Software, that after setting up a monitor, it will write
                a profile that can be use by other programs
                ..... that's the reason I post the question.

                Maybe I am making a mistake ( will see ) but I decided to go
                for the Spider2Express, I willing to take chances for less than
                $100 bucks........

                Thanks for posting........

                ( Sorry for taking so long to comeback here but we had
                plenty customers this last week )

                Chao
                • 5. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                  D Fosse-QDEaQ1 Community Member
                  The Spyder will do fine. You won't see it in Photoshop; it will just hide under the generic "Monitor RGB" there (...but don't set it as your working space! Some people do that. Just leave it alone).

                  If you look in Vista however, "Spyder2express" will automatically be set as default for your monitor (Control panel > color management).

                  Oh, one more thing: ATI catalyst has a habit of kicking out monitor calibration. You may have to disable that from startup.
                  • 6. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                    GESYMSB Community Member
                    Thanks Freeagent, I was searching around on the net, when
                    I noticed your post, now I had found some posts that even
                    get you more confuse !

                    Take a look at this: ( Some post I was reading )

                    Hi All, I recently purchased the Spyder express 2 to calibrate my lcd correctly. Regarding the profile which was created how now do I use this in Photoshop?
                    At the moment In the "color setting" menu I have the photoshop working space RGB set to "Monitor RGB - Spyder2express"
                    When I open an image I get a profile mismatch and photoshop asks me if I want to convert the profile of the photo from Embedded - sRGB IEC61966-2.1 to Working: Monitor RGB - Spyder2express.
                    Now heres where im confused.............

                    Now the other person responds with.......

                    You want to switch your color space to either sRGB or
                    Adobe RGB. Don't use the Monitor RGB.

                    Is that's correct, somone could just use a know calibrated
                    picture for testing and set the monitor to "close to perfect"
                    ( Will not be perfect some not all eyes see the same )

                    On other places I read that now Photoshop on some cases
                    include ( bundle ) the Spyder2Express......

                    See what I mean, I getting all kinds of Positive &
                    Negative inputs ob this matter !

                    1000000 of thanks.
                    • 7. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                      D Fosse-QDEaQ1 Community Member
                      >You want to switch your color space to either sRGB or
                      Adobe RGB. Don't use the Monitor RGB.

                      This is correct, and essentially the same as what I said. Use sRGB or AdobeRGB as your working space. Monitor RGB is just for special purposes (like posting screenshots on the web for color troubleshooting).

                      The Spyder will take care of itself. Fire it up, and it will install the monitor profile in the correct place. From then on, that profile will be more or less invisible to you, but doing what it should (although you can see it kick in on computer startup).

                      >Is that's correct, somone could just use a know calibrated
                      picture for testing and set the monitor to "close to perfect"

                      This is what calibrators are for. You'll never be able to get it 100% right by eye.

                      There's no inclusion or bundling of any calibrators with Photoshop. Up to CS2 there was something called Adobe Gamma, but it wasn't very accurate (because you had to do it by eye) and it's been discontinued.
                      • 8. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                        D. McCahill Community Member
                        > circut city has been notroious about marking up then claiming "sale" prices in which the "sale" price is actually higher than the original.

                        Gee, you wonder how a company can stay in business pulling stuff like that.

                        Oh, wait a sec ...
                        • 9. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                          dave milbut Community Member
                          from what i've read, it's not them, it's the liquidator - the company hired to liquidate the inventory. they pay CC a fixed fee then sell everything for whatever they can. they don't care if they sucker you into something. they're in it for the biggest bang for the buck. the more money they make over the fixed fee they paid to CC, the better for them.

                          that's standard operating procedure for those types of companies.
                          • 10. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                            Bill Lamp Community Member
                            I bought from them:

                            2 each 4-packs Lithium AA batteries for $3 each off real price.

                            1 750 gig Firewire external drive for back-ups at $25 off real price.

                            Real price is what the same thing sells for at other stores.

                            I looked at a few other things and turned up my nose at the prices.
                            • 11. Re: New Monitor, new headache !
                              GESYMSB Community Member
                              I have check around and I did save about $40-$60 on this LG
                              Monitor ( W2252QT-TF ) I already when to LG and downloaded its
                              Service Manual in case one day I need it.

                              However I was showing my wife, that seens they increase the
                              prices as they get close to last day.
                              They see people coming and they trying to take advantage of that.

                              I also received today my "Spyder" the dam thing did very good !