12 Replies Latest reply on Jun 15, 2012 6:13 AM by Jason Nichols

    Removing project from source control

      We have a project that is source controlled in RoboSource 3.1. There are currently three writers on the project and we each have a version of the project on our hard drives from which we are working. We are having a hard time keeping our projects synced between our hard drives and RoboSource. My question is this: If I go into RoboHelp and select remove project from source control, does it only remove the temporary project on my hard drive, will it remove the main project in RoboSource, and/or will it remove everyone else's project from source control.


        • 1. Re: Removing project from source control
          RoboWizard Level 4
          Hi Bill

          I'm a bit confused as to why you are even using source control if each author has a different version of the same project on their local drive. The purpose of source control with RoboHelp is to ensure that all authors are working with the same project. Suzie's project should look identical to John's and so on.

          Assuming Source Control is properly set up and configured, I would think if you deleted a project from the Source Control repository it would very likely affect the other users.

          Cheers... Rick
          • 2. Re: Removing project from source control
            wesacalypso Level 1

            What happens is that sometimes someone will go in and change the name of a topic that has already been created and when that happens, RoboSource doesn't seem to play nice. The other authors who might want to edit that topic cannot because RoboSource cannot find the old topic name. Also, there have been times when a folder has been deleted in RoboSource but shows up in RoboHelp anyway because the folder that was deleted is still on our hard drive. I know one solution is delete the .cpd file and rebuild RoboHelp, but at this stage of the development, with everything set up the way it should, I am unwilling to do that. Since we are newbies to RoboSource and did not have any time to look at it or play with it before we were told to use it, we might not be doing the things the right way. That being said, we feel development would go faster if we took it out of RoboSource.

            Sorry for the long winded explanation and hope I haven't been too confusing.


            • 3. Re: Removing project from source control
              MergeThis Level 4
              We've also recently moved to using RSC (as part of converting X5 to RH8), so expert advice this is not.

              However, it seems that renaming should be done in RSC, and not in RH. In addition, the RSC Edit > Delete / Hide option might be the answer for folders.

              Good luck,
              • 4. Re: Removing project from source control
                I can understand your frustration with errors in RSC/RH integration. Strange things do seem to happen.
                In answer to your original question, I do not believe that removing the project from source control on a single author's machine takes the project "Out" of source control for other authors.

                The database of files on the RSC server will remain the same and the rpoject will be maintained locally. This can be a good way to clean up a project and then add it back to a new RSC database later.

                Good Luck!
                • 5. Re: Removing project from source control
                  Captiv8r Adobe Community Professional & MVP
                  Hi all

                  I wrote this article a couple of years (and versions) ago. Not sure if it will still apply but it may. Perhaps take a look at the link below:

                  Click here to read

                  Cheers... Rick
                  • 6. Re: Removing project from source control
                    Gravenstein Level 2

                    We rebuild our CPD files quite often, for precisely the kinds of synchronization issues you describe. The only problem we run into when we do so is that it can take a long time to rebuild for the really huge projects. For most people, this shouldn't be a problem.



                    • 7. Re: Removing project from source control
                      Gravenstein Level 2

                      Rick, your article still applies to RH6/RSC3 projects. FYI, I also remove the pss file and the mssccprj.scc (if present).


                      I haven't checked the procedure for RH7/RH8 projects, but I'll bet it's the same.



                      • 8. Re: Removing project from source control
                        Gravenstein Level 2

                        Leon, you might want to be careful with renaming items in source control. If you make a change in source control, RH may not know about it. We generally make changes in RH, letting RH communicate the relevant changes to RSC. I don't usually make changes directly in RSC unless there's a problem.


                        I might mention that such problems tend to occur when there is a RH crash during certain kinds of operations. For example, say that the help author renaming a folder when his or her pc crashes. This kind of interruption can leave RH with one set of information and RSC with another. Then you can get stuck with having to manually rename and delete things to get them sync'd up again.


                        I'll agree with you on deleting/hiding folders in RSC. Sometimes there gets to be quite a bit of visual clutter, but you probably don't want to totalll obliterate the old items.


                        My 2¢.



                        • 9. Re: Removing project from source control
                          Eli_for_Hire Level 1

                          Hello again,

                          So, I tried it out on one of my test systems.

                          Removing the project from source control will change that user's view of the project.

                          However, the user can re-connect to the project again (by opening it from source control) which will copy all the files back down as if it was new again.


                          However, if the issue you are having is that your authors are seeing different versions of the files, you should check on the status of the files for each user.

                          I reccomend you have each user save and check in all files.

                          This should put all changes back up. Then, when you open the project, have each user download the latest from the server. If there are any inconsistencies, you will get warnings about them.


                          Hope this helps.

                          • 10. Re: Removing project from source control
                            Eli_for_Hire Level 1

                            Oh, One more comment.

                            You can disconnect a project from source control instead. This makes the local set of files on your PC a local only project, but leaves the stuff on the RSC for other authors to connect to.

                            • 11. Re: Removing project from source control
                              rwrich21 Level 1

                              Hello Eli


                              How do you disconnect a project from RSC?


                              My system Attributes:

                                  RoboHelp HTML V8.02

                                  RoboSource Control 3.1

                                  RoboHelp Server V8.0

                                  WebHelp Pro 5.50 (7.00.145)

                              • 12. Re: Removing project from source control
                                Jason Nichols Level 1

                                I followed Rick's instructions using RoboHelp 8. It works. But I did not have to delete the pblsvrs.sss file, which in RoboHelp 8 lists the names of the servers to publish (HTML files) to.