1 2 Previous Next 72 Replies Latest reply: May 3, 2015 11:49 AM by natalief28076859 RSS

    Shadow/Highlight flickering

    Jack Banatoni Community Member

      When I use the shadow/highlight effect, my image flickers.  I'm using manual settings.  Someone suggested changing black clip to 0%, but that did not help.  Is there another way to use this effect without flicker?

       

      Thanks,

      JB

        • 1. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
          Todd_Kopriva Adobe Employee

          Make sure that Temporal Smoothing is enabled. See this page for details:

          "Shadow/Highlight effect"

          • 2. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
            the_wine_snob Community Member

            JB,

             

            Are you leaving the Auto box checked? I find that it will likely introduce flickering, or strobing. I never use that, and will manually adjust S & H accordingly.

             

            Good luck,

             

            Hunt

            • 3. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
              Jack Banatoni Community Member

              To clarify, I am not using auto amounts.  Temporal smoothing is unavailable for manual control.  Any other ideas on what I have to do to keep my footage from flickering?  This has happened on several different clips.  Thanks! JB

              • 4. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                shooternz Community Member

                Did you try using 'Levels' instead.

                • 5. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                  Jack Banatoni Community Member

                  I usually use a combination of Levels and Shadow/Highlight for quick color correction.  Shadow/Highlight flickers on most clips, but a few get by with great results.  I still haven't found the cause of the flickering.  Thanks for the suggestions.

                  • 6. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                    the_wine_snob Community Member

                    I also use Levels and H&S. I never use the H&S Auto setting, as it will usually lead to "flickering," unless the lighting and exposure are exactly the same for the total Duration of that Clip. I do it with manual settings ONLY.

                     

                    Good luck,

                     

                    Hunt

                    • 7. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                      jdv Community Member

                      The solution to this problem:

                       

                      http://jdvos.com/?p=247

                       

                      Actually quite simple...

                      • 8. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                        Curt Wrigley Community Member

                        jvos213 wrote:

                         

                        The solution to this problem:

                         

                        http://jdvos.com/?p=247

                         

                        Actually quite simple...

                        That is a silly solution.

                         

                        The answer was given early on .  Temporal smoothing  Did you enebale ti and increase the time value?

                        • 9. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                          jdv Community Member

                          Yes, actually I did even though I dislike the Auto setting intensely and it did not work.

                           

                          Uneccesary to call something 'silly' just because its not conventional and if it fixes a problem which (despite your opinion) has not been adressed propperly then who cares how its done?

                           

                          To make it clear:

                           

                          TEMPORAL SMOOTHING IS ONLY AVAILIBLE WHEN USING THE AUTO FUNCTION IN THE SHADOWS HIGHLIGHTS EFFECT. This fix applies to people using maunal adjustments of this effect as mentioned in the link you mocked.

                           

                          Shadows and Highlights is pretty much a big no-go on Auto (feel free to google this topic, quite easy to see I'm not making this up) and if you have a look around you see that people who did indeed have this problem in 'Auto' mode and tried the suggested 'Temporal Shift' found that it does not work for this particular problem.

                           

                          To those who ran into the same wall, feel free to try this silly solution, wont take you more than 5 minutes to apply (minus rendering time of course:)

                          • 10. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                            Luke Flegg Community Member

                            This solution isn't silly. It's completely ridiculous.

                            Another example why Premiere isn't made properly and fails to be a professional tool, in my opinion.

                             

                            In 6 years running Premiere and teaching people in schools to use it, even I cannot say it's anything more than a glitchy piece of software that would be incredible if it was half as stable as it made out to be.

                             

                            I suggest Adobe beta test it more, as it feels like it's beta tested for a week on brand new machines for which every single component, down to the DVD drive is tailored with nothing in mind other than Premiere compatibility. Get real! Why does every competing package run so much better on a wider variety of machines?

                             

                            I used to be one of the people that kept making excuses for Premiere, thinking it was my fault, and now I just now I need to let go and see how much further competition has come.

                             

                            (this is all before addressing about 6 other issues ranging from Adobe losing information on my tech support cases, to failing to do callbacks...)

                             

                            Rant complete.

                            • 11. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                              rodney_ray Community Member

                              Jack,

                               

                              Did you ever find a workable solution?  Runing into the same problem.  First time I have tried S/H since I upgraded from CS4.

                               

                              thanks,

                              rod

                              • 12. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                hpmoon Community Member

                                This is absolutely disgusting.  I'm getting intense flickering with manual Shadow & Highlight settings on Export.  Adobe hasn't done anything to resolve this.  It is thus an amateurish piece of toy software.  This is happening without any other effects applied to a simple clip but Shadow & Highlight.

                                • 13. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                  Jeff Bellune ACP

                                  The information you need about using the Shadow/Highlight effect is here, as Todd mentioned previously:

                                   

                                  Adobe Premiere Pro CS5 & CS5.5 * Shadow/Highlight effect

                                   

                                  If you would like a different behavior, then please file a feature request here:

                                   

                                  Adobe - Feature Request/Bug Report Form

                                   

                                  -Jeff

                                  • 14. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                    hpmoon Community Member

                                    Jeff Bellune wrote:

                                     

                                    The information you need about using the Shadow/Highlight effect is here, as Todd mentioned previously:

                                     

                                    Adobe Premiere Pro CS5 & CS5.5 * Shadow/Highlight effect

                                     

                                    If you would like a different behavior, then please file a feature request here:

                                     

                                    Adobe - Feature Request/Bug Report Form

                                     

                                    -Jeff

                                     

                                    I have no idea why you keep linking people over to the help file for the Shadow/Highlight  effect.  There is absolutely no bit of information there that could lead  to any resolution of this issue.  It's an example of why people can get  so inflamed here; regulars like yourself -- though you are compensated, since your caption is a "Community Professional" -- purport to offer answers (a) without  thinking about whether it will actually address the problem; (b)  defending Adobe as a starting point; and (c) taking the easiest path of  citing already-established generalities.

                                     

                                    This is a bug,  plain and simple.  It dates back years, and hundreds of people have reported it across the Web.  [Advice:  spend a minute looking.]  I have submitted repeated bug  reports.  Many, many other users have too.  This is a simple case of  Adobe letting the issue slide.  Like a billion others.  One tiny  example:  ever wondered what those Auto Black Levels and Auto White  Levels buttons do in the Fast Color Corrector?  Absolutely nothing.   That's been the case for several years now.  Great job, Adobe.

                                    • 15. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                      Todd_Kopriva Adobe Employee

                                      > I have no idea why you keep linking people over to the help file for the Shadow/Highlight  effect.  There is absolutely no bit of information there that could lead  to any resolution of this issue.

                                       

                                       

                                      The page that Jeff pointed to contains information about the Temporal Smoothing control, which is suppsed to prevent flickering. You never said whether you had tried to use that control, even though it was suggested earlier in this thread.

                                       

                                      > though you are compensated, since your caption is a "Community Professional"

                                       

                                       

                                      That is only an acknowledgment by a group here at Adobe that Jeff has shown himself to be a knowledgeable and helpful person---which he is. It is no indication of compensation by Adobe.

                                      • 16. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                        hpmoon Community Member

                                        Todd_Kopriva wrote:

                                         

                                        > I have no idea why you keep linking people over to the help file for the Shadow/Highlight  effect.  There is absolutely no bit of information there that could lead  to any resolution of this issue.

                                         

                                         

                                        The page that Jeff pointed to contains information about the Temporal Smoothing control, which is suppsed to prevent flickering. You never said whether you had tried to use that control, even though it was suggested earlier in this thread.

                                         

                                        > though you are compensated, since your caption is a "Community Professional"

                                         

                                         

                                        That is only an acknowledgment by a group here at Adobe that Jeff has shown himself to be a knowledgeable and helpful person---which he is. It is no indication of compensation by Adobe.

                                         

                                        Seriously, this is why I question the value of these forums altogether.  People don't simply read the threads, as is standard in true power user forums all across the Interwebs.  If you merely scroll up this short thread, you'll see how obviously Temporal Smoothing is no solution, and 100% irrelevant to the issue being complained about here, which is flickering and banding during both rendering and even paused playback on the timeline in full manual mode.  Temporal smoothing is totally unavailable in manual mode, and Jeff knew that.

                                         

                                        Since you are an actual Adobe employee, Todd, I have some advice:  presume that your customers are pointing out an error that Adobe can fix, instead of beginning with the hope that it's not Adobe's fault.  That's good customer service, or in other terms, the only way you'll survive as a business.

                                        • 17. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                          the_wine_snob Community Member

                                          Can you post all of the S & H settings, chosen, that are giving you that flicker?

                                           

                                          As I have never observed it, I want to duplicate it, if I possibly can.

                                           

                                          Thank you,

                                           

                                          Hunt

                                          • 19. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                            the_wine_snob Community Member

                                            Thank you for that info.

                                             

                                            I just applied those settings to a DV-AVI Clip (SD), and Rendered that Clip. I could detect no flicker or banding, even with the Program Monitor nearly full screen on my laptop and the Magnification at 150%.

                                             

                                            What are the specs. of the Clip, where you observe those issues?

                                             

                                            I'll be glad to try with any Source Footage, that I can get my hands on.

                                             

                                            Appreciated, and good luck,

                                             

                                            Hunt

                                            • 20. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                              hpmoon Community Member

                                              the_wine_snob wrote:

                                               

                                              Thank you for that info.

                                               

                                              I just applied those settings to a DV-AVI Clip (SD), and Rendered that Clip. I could detect no flicker or banding, even with the Program Monitor nearly full screen on my laptop and the Magnification at 150%.

                                               

                                              What are the specs. of the Clip, where you observe those issues?

                                               

                                              I'll be glad to try with any Source Footage, that I can get my hands on.

                                               

                                              Appreciated, and good luck,

                                               

                                              Hunt

                                               

                                              Thanks for checking it out.  Here's another thing to see, a screen grab that shows the Program Monitor view when the time marker is in the clip with the Shadow/Highlight effect enabled using those settings I mentioned earlier.  The source clip is a simple MPEG-2 1280x720p 29.97fps file at a moderate bitrate.

                                               

                                              Ribbons Color Reference.jpg

                                               

                                              The thin band at the top is showing the proper application of the effect; it moves around frame-by-frame (there are no keyframes, cropping, etc., of course) and that is the "flickering" that people are talking about/reporting.

                                              • 21. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                the_wine_snob Community Member

                                                Wow, that IS obvious. I nearly went blind, looking for tiny flickers and banding (at least it did prompt me to clean the laptop's monitor!).

                                                 

                                                I saw nothing even close.

                                                 

                                                Am I correct that the problem exists in Exported footage too, and not just in the Program Monitor? If only in the Program Monitor, I would quickly check the video card's installed driver. If in Export, I am at a loss to explain what you show. I will definitely have to defer to Todd, Kevin, or someone else there.

                                                 

                                                Thanks for the screen-cap and good luck,

                                                 

                                                Hunt

                                                • 22. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                  hpmoon Community Member

                                                  the_wine_snob wrote:

                                                   

                                                  Wow, that IS obvious. I nearly went blind, looking for tiny flickers and banding (at least it did prompt me to clean the laptop's monitor!).

                                                   

                                                  I saw nothing even close.

                                                   

                                                  Am I correct that the problem exists in Exported footage too, and not just in the Program Monitor? If only in the Program Monitor, I would quickly check the video card's installed driver. If in Export, I am at a loss to explain what you show. I will definitely have to defer to Todd, Kevin, or someone else there.

                                                   

                                                  Thanks for the screen-cap and good luck,

                                                   

                                                  Hunt

                                                   

                                                  I'm afraid the same thing happens on rendering/export.  Definitely a bug.  Jeff Bellune keeps insisting it isn't.

                                                   

                                                  Thanks for taking a look.

                                                  • 23. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                    Jack Banatoni Community Member

                                                    Wow, I started this thread almost a year ago!  Anyway, yes, I can confirm that it carries through export.  To be clear, the flickering occurs even when all the automatic settings are off.  It flickers on manual control.  It's really luck of the draw if flickering occurs on a clip or not.  Sometimes it works as expected, other times the flickering shows up.  Would love to see a solution...

                                                    • 24. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                      sunlit777 Community Member

                                                      I can confirm the flicker issue, and it is rather pronounced (=unacceptable) in certain videos, e.g. with high contrast shooting beach seaside in full sunshine.

                                                      I am amazed at how some guys in this thread that are supposed to be community helper veterans ignore the issue, brush off the reports, and link us back to some basic help pages.

                                                      • 25. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                        peter quixote

                                                        I gave up entirely on shadow/ highlight, and this proposed alternative 'Levels'  is a different function entirley as far as I can work.

                                                        Levels  does not 'even out' highlights or shadows.

                                                        It narrows the dynamic range doesn't it. Almost the opposite.

                                                        If Adobe Premiere could get this right it would bre a big plus, is there any update to resolving this problem.

                                                        • 26. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                          Jack Banatoni Community Member

                                                          Unfortunately, Levels is broken in CS5.  Using the pop-out box, the sliders only adjust the master levels.  The RGB levels have no response.  You can still adjust these levels in the effects panel, but it's not as convenient.

                                                           

                                                          Too bad old versions of Premiere never seem to get updates, even essential ones, after a new version is released.  I just bought CS5 this year, but I'm stuck with broken levels until the next upgrade.

                                                          • 27. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                            peter quixote Community Member

                                                            Thanks for the update Jack, I didn't know that the RBG levels failed.

                                                            I think I misunderstood the value of levels early on, and just never got round to trying RBG levels.

                                                            • 28. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                              quiche_me_quick Community Member

                                                              I have exactly the same issue but ONLY with DSLR footage, it's almost as if the rolling shutter affects the flicker...very strange. There are quite a few posts about this but no solution, so i presume it must be a bug.

                                                              The quickest way i found to work around with the problem was delete the H/S effect on all the clips and use the Brightness/Contrast tool instead, which seems to work well with exposure issues.

                                                              • 29. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                GHo_PCO

                                                                Hello, I came as well into that issue, we are using a high quality highspeed camera with high quality images. Whenever I try to apply shadow & highlight with "Automatic" OFF it always creates dramatic flickering in the preview as well as in the exported material. It doesn't matter which setting.

                                                                 

                                                                Is there any further solution than cutting the clip into very small parts?

                                                                • 30. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                  Jack Banatoni Community Member

                                                                  Since I started this thread two years ago, I still haven't found a solution.  I gave up on the shadow/highlight effect and started using a luma curve effect to achieve similar results (with less ease, to be sure).  I'd recommend that route.

                                                                  • 31. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                    Steve221 Community Member

                                                                    I noticed the same thing.  When comparing the exact same video with my DSLR (1920/1080 30fps) and my camcorder (1080i/480i 30fps) the DSLR flickered while the other did not.

                                                                    • 32. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                      PaulM-Aus Community Member

                                                                      I'll chime in to and confirm Shadow/Highlight causes a visible and unacceptable flickering on at least half of the shots I apply it to. That is common across AE CS5/6 and PR CS5/6, in both Auto+Temporal Smoothing and full manual modes. I've found flickering across a range of sources (Red, AVCHD, HDSLR, Uncompressed digibeta, MiniDV) at range of resolutions. All clips that flicker were shot on full manual with no adjustment in exposure settings. I can't work out what causes the flickering - I haven't been able to find any pattern amongst the clips that do. It's a real shame because when it works the filter does some truly wonderful things to perceived dynamic range.

                                                                       

                                                                      Also, the bug/feature request form links to an error page whenever I submit an entry.

                                                                      • 33. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                        jessechandler

                                                                        I figured it out.

                                                                         

                                                                        Make sure there is no video BELOW the clip being effected, and the flicker magically disapears.  You can also just "de-enable" all the clips below, or insert a slug.  BOOM!

                                                                        • 34. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                          PaulM-Aus Community Member

                                                                          I'm afraid to report I still get flickering no matter what, if anything, is sitting below the clip in question - I've had a few instances this morning on the timeline I'm working on. But I'm glad it's working for you Jesse!

                                                                          • 35. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                            mde.tv Community Member

                                                                            I'm here reporting the same bug. For me, what worked was making sure I only had one video element active at a time, so no layers stacked on top of each other. A little annoying but it can be fixed by pre-rendering elements. Not sure if this will work for anyone else.

                                                                             

                                                                            I'd also like to note that reading this thread made me physically sick. All the old video pros coming in and chipping in their two cents without reading what people wrote before... "easy fix, just enable temporal smoothing." C'mon, pay attention.

                                                                            • 36. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                              hpmoon Community Member

                                                                              mde.tv wrote:

                                                                               

                                                                              I'd also like to note that reading this thread made me physically sick. All the old video pros coming in and chipping in their two cents without reading what people wrote before... "easy fix, just enable temporal smoothing." C'mon, pay attention.

                                                                               

                                                                              Exactly.  It's a big problem here; they'll ban you for mentioning the names of the old veterans with thousands of posts, but it's totally true.

                                                                              • 37. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                                shuenwang Community Member

                                                                                has anyone been able to find an alternative to highlights/shadow?

                                                                                • 38. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                                  mde.tv Community Member

                                                                                  There is none. Make sure there are no video tracks above/below the track you are adding the effect to, turn off auto amounts, and turn black clip/white clip down to 0%... one or all of those things may be required to remove the flicker effect.

                                                                                  • 39. Re: Shadow/Highlight flickering
                                                                                    CraigGordonDMD Community Member

                                                                                    For those of you that simply notice the "sky" in your clips flickering when using Shadow/Highlight Adjustment, make sure to set at least the Black Clip and/or White Clip from .01 to 0. This will stop that annoying flicker throughout the entire clip.

                                                                                     

                                                                                    If you do a crossfade, with two shadow/hightlight adjusted clips, you get another type of flicker. Rendering without GPU acceleration will solve the problem. Go into Project/Project Settings/General and click software only. Save the file, close out, reopen. It works.

                                                                                     

                                                                                    The problem occurs when two clips that both have Shadow/Highlight adjusment with different values are crossfaded. You get this light dark bands of flickering in the crossfade. It looks horrible.

                                                                                     

                                                                                    Setting the clipping amounts to 0, as opposed to the default of .01 will help with the clip flickering, but NOT the crossfade flikering. It will not help

                                                                                    Using Opacity keyframes as opposed to the Crossfade Video Transition Effect will not help.

                                                                                     

                                                                                    Rendering without GPU acceleration will solve the problem. Another way to solve the problem is to make INTER clips. Render the two clips seperately with all shadow/highlight effects, then replace the clips on your timeline with the rendered clips and THEN crossfade them.

                                                                                     

                                                                                    IT IS POSSIBLE THAT ALL SHADOW/HIGHLIGHT ADJUSTMENT FLICKERING IS CAUSED BY YOUR GPU CARD AND THIS MAY BE WHY ADOBE DOESNT SEE THE PROBLEM. Im not sure!

                                                                                    1 2 Previous Next