12 Replies Latest reply: Feb 27, 2012 7:36 AM by the_wine_snob RSS

    Burn Project

    The great dog Chippie

      Ok here goes:

       

      I shot a 2 minute video in Pal 1080i.  I then edited the video using the Pal 1080i widescreen settings.

       

      Now I want to burn the movie to a DVD and send the video to  America. I am in Australia.

       

      Here is the Question:

       

      If I send the video to America, will it play on any PC?

       

      If I send the Movie to America, will it play on any DVD Player?

       

      If it will not play on DVD players, because the video is created in Pal and most players in America play only NTSC, can I output or share the Pal created video as an NTSC video, ( this is an option under Share for premier elements 10), then burn it as an NTSC video and send it to America feeling confident that it will play on a NTSC  DVD player, without quality issues compromising the video?

       

      Thanks

        • 1. Re: Burn Project
          Steve Grisetti MVP

          You can not play PAL DVDs on DVD players in the US, Chippie.

           

          The best way to share a video with your friends here is to create a computer file -- which is universal and doesn't have to be NTSC or PAL compliant.

           

          If you're using version 10 of the program, you'll find a number of great options for creating a quality MP4 under Share/Computer/AVCHD. You can even burn these to a disc if you'd like. They just can't be played on a DVD or BluRay player. They can only be played on a computer.

          • 2. Re: Burn Project
            The great dog Chippie Community Member

            Thanks Steve

             

            Helps a lot

            • 3. Re: Burn Project
              The great dog Chippie Community Member

              Hi Again:

               

              Want to clarify 2 things;  First, I have a Pal camera. The video was created in Pal.  Can I  using the export options in PE export in NTSC to create a DVD for play in America on DVD Players, even though it was created in Pal

               

              Will there be quality issues?

               

              Second,  What is the difference between creating a web DVD for the computer using Share/Computer/AVCHD and burning a DVD?  Both can play on the computer can they not?

              • 4. Re: Burn Project
                Steve Grisetti MVP

                There is no smooth way to convert PAL to NTSC. You can give it a try though. The results (because of the difference in frame rates) can be iffy.

                 

                A WebDVD creates a web site with menus and videos whose interface resembles a DVD.

                 

                Burning an AVCHD simply creates a single video file with no menus.

                • 5. Re: Burn Project
                  nealeh Community Member

                  OK - so your will be down-rezzing your HD clip to DVD Quality. So what you might try is to do everything in PAL then at the end Share the timeline to a DV file. Once you have the DV file you can try converting it to NTSC using DVdate. DVdate is often recommended in these forums for creating individual clips according to date, but it also lists the following feature.

                  check01_green.gif convert a DV file from Pal to NTSC or reciprocally: it is useful to make a DVD in NTSC format with a camcorder in DV Pal.

                   

                  Got to be worth a try.

                   

                  Cheers,

                  --

                  Neale

                  Insanity is hereditary, you get it from your children

                  • 6. Re: Burn Project
                    The great dog Chippie Community Member

                    Thanks Steve

                    • 7. Re: Burn Project
                      The great dog Chippie Community Member

                      My confusion is that some DVD players are classified as all region which means they should be able to play both Pal and NTSC. Is that right?

                       

                      If a person in America gets my DVD that was made in Pal Here in Australia and has a DVD player with all regions capability they should be able to play it on their TV ???? If they do not have a DVD player with all region capability, they will not be able to play it on their TV ???

                       

                      Thanks

                      • 8. Re: Burn Project
                        John T Smith MVP

                        All region and NTSC vs PAL are not the same thing

                         

                        Regions are a sales tool, so a disc meant to be sold in Australia may not be played in any other region

                         

                        NTSC vs PAL is two different standards, just like you may not put a Beta tape in a VHS player

                        • 9. Re: Burn Project
                          The great dog Chippie Community Member

                          Thank You

                           

                          That really clears it up.

                          • 10. Re: Burn Project
                            the_wine_snob Community Member

                            Also, Regions are ONLY for replicated discs, i.e. when one sends the Project out to a commercial replication house, to have a glass master created, and used to stamp the discs, rather than burn them. There purpose is exactly as John T. points out - limiting the play to a specific Region.

                             

                            I do not believe that PrE has a setting for Regions, as it is not really designed to create a DLT, or similar, for replication, and only for burning. Adobe Encore does have the setting for Regions, BUT again only for replication, and if set, this can cause the Burn to error out, as Regions are not allowed on burned discs.

                             

                            The PAL/NTSC are for the TV standards in various countries, and refer to the pixel x pixel Frame Size, plus the FPS difference between those two TV standards. The FPS is reflective of the Hz, Cycles per second, of the electrical system, with 60Hz for the US, and 50Hz for most European countries.

                             

                            Now, most newer PAL DVD decks, can also play a well-burned NTSC disc, but very few NTSC decks can also play PAL discs. Older PAL decks usually cannnot play NTSC disc though.

                             

                            Good luck,

                             

                            Hunt

                            • 11. Re: Burn Project
                              nealeh Community Member

                              Amazon summarise it quite well at http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/help/customer/display.html?ie=UTF8&nodeId=502554

                               

                              Now you and I, being from PAL land usually have an easy task - almost any new DVD Player and TV is going to also be NTSC compatible. And, if the DVD Player should be locked, then there is an extraordinarily high likelihood that you can enter a code with the remote to make it region-free.

                               

                              Now North America is the opposite. I believe that very little equipment sold in NA is capable of playing / displaying PAL DVDs.

                               

                              Anyway - this is what Amazon say about it.

                              DVD Regions

                              DVD Regions | Region 1 DVDs sold by our Marketplace sellers | Regional Coding Enhancement (RCE) | Global DVD region countries | Blu-ray Discs Region Encoding | High-Density (HD) Discs Region Encoding

                              DVD Regions

                               

                               

                              The DVD region code identifies a DVD's compatibility with the players typically sold in a particular region.

                              The following graphic shows the approximate location of each region. Click here for an approximate list of countries that fall into each region:

                              DVD regions map

                              Region 0 (or "region free") is compatible with DVD players from any region, depending on relevant hardware. Region 0 titles can be either NTSC (generally if they originate from the US) or PAL format (originating from within the EU).

                              The majority of all current titles play only in one specific region unless otherwise noted. DVDs sold by Amazon.co.uk are encoded for Region 2 or Region 0. Region 2 DVDs may not work on DVD players in other countries.

                              Region 1 DVDs sold by our Marketplace sellers

                               

                               

                              Region 1 discs are intended for use with standard DVD players in North America (Canada and the USA). In most instances they can also be played on compatible "multi-region" DVD players (also known as "chipped" or "region-free" players).

                              They also require an NTSC-compatible television. NTSC is the standard picture format in North America, and differs from the PAL format adopted in Britain and Europe. Region 1 DVDs are usually presented in NTSC format, so you should ensure that your TV is capable of reading the NTSC signal before purchasing Region 1 DVDs.

                              Regional Coding Enhancement (RCE)

                               

                               

                              Regional Coding Enhancement (RCE) has been added by some film studios (specifically Warner and Columbia) to selected Region 1 DVDs, with the intention of preventing these discs from playing on some multi-region DVD players. We are therefore unable to guarantee that all Region 1 discs will be compatible with all multi-region players.

                               

                               

                              Finally, although the reverse to you, my Sony stills camera is an import and records NTSC. I was VERY pleased with the way PRE converted this to PAL for me. However NTSC -> PAL is throwing away frames. The other way PRE has to add frames which may be more noticeable. I suggest you try with a small clip first to see how well it will do it.

                               

                              Cheers,

                              --

                              Neale

                              Insanity is hereditary, you get it from your children

                              • 12. Re: Burn Project
                                the_wine_snob Community Member

                                Yes, European PAL-land seems to now have the "best of both worlds," but in NTSC-land, we are rather stuck with having to do conversions, and those do not always look good, or work well. Poor us (or maybe that should read, "poor US.).

                                 

                                Hunt