Bluff titler, definitely.
Although using keyframing you can also create some amazing titling effects right in the program! Look at the example of the title I created in the demos along the left side of this page.
What exactly are you trying to do? There are usually inexpensive ways to do it with some simple keyframing and motion paths.
I want to make text and "objects" fly in and out and around the screen, bounce around, explode, catch fire, glow, etc. I keyframed a title using the "size" parameter to get "fly in your face" look and it just didn't look right - I also need some objects to work with, or need to be able to design them myself (fish, guns, bows, arrows, etc) - is there an animation program that will work with PRE to help me create some of these things? I will look at your examples on muvipix to see what the PRE possibilities are. Eric
After Effects. The learning curve is killer -- but with it you can do almost anything you can imagine!
LiveType is very powerful and easy to use. It's Mac only though.
You may also want to post this question at the Community Forum at Premiere Elements support site http://Muvipix.com. There are some very knowledgeable editors there that will likely have some great suggestions.
I agree with Steve on this.
I use BluffTitler (plus several of the ProDAD plug-ins), but do most work in Premiere. When I need more than it can provide, I go to BluffTitler next (or one of the ProDAD apps), and then AfterEffects for involved Titles.
One thing that I do like is to use Photoshop to create Layered PSD Title files, and then Import those into Premiere Pro (only in Pro), as Sequences, where I can animate each Layer individually. PrE does not allow for Layered PSD files to be Imported with the Layers separate - only Flattened.