4 Replies Latest reply: May 4, 2012 12:16 AM by Dorin Nicolaescu-Musteață RSS

    Trouble opening files from LR3 to CS4, desaturation occurring.

    tessarice30 Community Member

      I upgraded from LR2 to 3 a while ago, and recently, I've had an odd problem opening my lightly edited files into CS4.  I just do command E on my mac, and they open right into CS4.  When the image(s) open, they almost seem completely desaturated?  I shoot a nikon D700, raw, copy the NEF files into LR3 upon import, do light edits in LR (white balance, recovery, tone curve, some adjustment brush...) and then will open selected files into CS4 for futher tweaking.  Any idea why these images are doing this?  If I go back into lightroom and "reset all settings" and then open, the images open fine.  Help, i'm about to pull my hair out!!!

      Here is a screen shot showing the image in LR (left) and then how it opens in CS4.

       

      Thank you in advance for your help!  I'm currently running version 3.6 of lightroom and 11.0.2 of CS4

       

      Screen shot 2012-03-13 at 9.44.11 PM.png

        • 1. Re: Trouble opening files from LR3 to CS4, desaturation occurring.
          dhphoto2012 Community Member

          Looks to me like PS is opening the files in AdobeRGB colorspace, that'd do it

          • 2. Re: Trouble opening files from LR3 to CS4, desaturation occurring.
            Cornelia-I Community Member

            The question is if LR's adjustments are handed over to PS?

             

            Normally I would expect some dialog asking you if you want to render with LR adjustments or not. Maybe you have switched off those dialogs?

             

            Then it might be a question of matching ACR-versions between Lightroom and Photoshop:

            I am not familiar with CS4, but LR3 matches with CS5 (i.e. ACR 6.x), LR4 with CS6 (i.e. ACR 7.x. or 6.7 of CS5)

             

            So it could be that your CS4 does not know the ACR-version used by LR3, hence can only open without LR3's develop settings.

            CS4 matched with LR2.

             

            If you need to stick with CS4, you may need to switch the dialogs back on and let LR3 render a TIFF for hand-over to CS4.

            Should you dislike that, upgrade Photoshop... but then maybe to really current versions, so LR4-CS6 ?

             

            Cornelia

            • 3. Re: Trouble opening files from LR3 to CS4, desaturation occurring.
              tessarice30 Community Member

              Nope I am in sRGB.....

               

              It has been very confusing because I can get an image to open normally in CS4 by resetting ALL the settings.... i wrote down the settings, re-set, made sure it opened with the correct color rendition/not desaturated (for lack of a better term.....), and then went through and "re-created" the image step by step, starting with white balance and on down, and opening it in CS4 every step, to see what was making the color render that way in CS4.  I think I have narrowed it down to the Nikon V4 camera profiles... because if I set my camera profile to "d2x mode1 v2" it opens normally (with all of my other lightroom edits made...) but if i simply switch to "d2x mode 1 v4" it will desaturate upon opening in cs4.

               

              I've also had troubles like this from time to time in the past, and thought it had something to do with the adjustment brush.

               

              Has anyone encountered this problem before??  Is it a compatibility issue with CS4 being an older version of photoshop?

              • 4. Re: Trouble opening files from LR3 to CS4, desaturation occurring.
                Dorin Nicolaescu-Musteață Community Member

                I bet your Photoshop color rmanagement policy is set to Off, when it should be Preserve.

                 

                cm_policy.jpg