17 Replies Latest reply: Jun 25, 2012 4:51 AM by Stan Jones RSS

    Encore CS6 Menu

    m2425 Community Member

      Why is it that my menus for blu-ray are being encoded with mpeg 2 and not h.264, and my settings are in h.264. I thought Adobe fixed this.

        • 1. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
          ram8kumar Community Member

          I tried with a very short project and this is not a problem with my project. What exactlry are you doing?

          Where did you see that the menus are being encoded in MPEG-2 and not in H.264?

           

          -Ramesh.

          • 2. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
            m2425 Community Member

            I see in BDedit, BDFix, tsMuxerGUI, TotalMedia Theatre 5, and on my PS3. When I first got CS6, Encore encoded menus in H.264 but it gave me errors trying to edit the BDMV in BDedit so I unstalled it then I started to use Encore CS5, but my main HHD crashed so I have to re-install W7, then when I heard that there was an update for CS6 so I decided that I was going to install Encore as well.

            • 3. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
              ram8kumar Community Member

              I am sorry but I didn't get what you said. You said that Encore CS6 gave you the menus encoded in H264 but BDEdit said that it was MPEG-2.

              Then you used CS5. (This had this bug of encoding the menus in MPEG-2 always irrespective ot the project settings.) If this is the problem that you are seeing with CS5, then this is a bug is CS5 that has been fixed in CS6.

              Any update to CS6 should not have effect on this behavior because I am trying with the update only. This should work in CS6.

               

              -Ramesh.

              • 4. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                m2425 Community Member

                No, CS6 is now giving menus encoded in mpeg 2.

                 

                When I first used Encore CS6 (about a week after it was released), it gave me H.264 menus, which I was happy because that was one of big problems with CS5, but for some reason the blu-rays that CS6 were producing were giving me problems in BDedit with editing mpls files & button commands.

                 

                That was the reason why I went back to Encore CS5 because I know how to get around that bug CS5 had for menus.

                 

                Now, since my PC crashed and I had to re-install Windows 7, I heard that there was an update for Encore CS6 I decided that I was going to install Encore as well. With the update the blu-rays that CS6 produce are not giving anymore problems with editing mpls files & button commands in BDedit but its producing mpeg 2 menus.

                • 5. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                  ram8kumar Community Member

                  Well, that sounds strange to me as I am also on the Encore Update (6.0.1.013).

                  Could you post the screen shot of your project settings and the folder where you see that the file is MPEG-2?

                   

                  -Thanks,

                  Ramesh.

                  • 6. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                    m2425 Community Member

                    Here are 7 pics of a simple blu-ray I made from Encore CS6 Ramesh with the programs that are telling the menu is in MPEG-2 and not in H.264:

                    1.jpg

                    2.jpg

                    This is with tsMuxerGUI:

                    3.jpg

                    This is with BDFix:

                    4.jpg

                    This is with BDedit:

                    5.jpg

                    This is with The KMPlayer:

                    6.jpg

                    This is with CLIPINF Editor:

                    7.jpg

                    • 7. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                      Stan Jones CommunityMVP

                      Also Encore 6.0.1.013

                       

                      Did a quick test.

                       

                      Simple BD project, blank Hd menu, added a placeholder background, added one button, used the library Crib m2v (which is mpeg2) and added as motion background, duplicated the menu and linked the button to the other menu.

                       

                      I used my default (1080p 29.97 30Mbps max) and then your settings (1080p 23.976 15Mbps).

                       

                      Using Mediainfo and BDEdit, all the streams are H264.

                      • 8. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                        m2425 Community Member

                        @Stan, as you see with my pictures, then menu is coming out in MPEG-2.

                        Question your 1080p 29.97 @ 30Mbps, does it come out in interlaced or progressive?

                        • 9. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                          Stan Jones CommunityMVP

                          Yes, interlaced (of course)!

                           

                          Well, the problem should be repeatable, and I always allow for operator error (you're looking at the wrong files, for example).

                           

                          Try my experiment and confirm you get the mpeg2. What is different (from my experiment) that you are doing? For example, I added background motion rather than some other way of forcing a render.

                          • 10. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                            m2425 Community Member

                            Ok I did what you said Stan and I found out that if the menu is not a motion menu (with a video or audio track) i.e. a static menu, Encore CS6 will encoded in MPEG-2 but if its a motion menu Encore CS6 will encode it in H.264. I guess Adobe didn't solve the whole bug for menu encoding.

                            • 11. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                              Stan Jones CommunityMVP

                              I'll confirm what you describe later today.

                               

                              Edit: for stills, I also get MPEG2 (in an m2ts file, which shows a general format of BDAV).

                               

                              A also filed a bug report.

                              • 12. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                                m2425 Community Member

                                I knew it, do you know how to make a still in H.264?

                                • 13. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                                  Stan Jones CommunityMVP

                                  do you know how to make a still in H.264?

                                  Not me! Waiting for Ramesh to tell us; or to confirm that its a bug. Or perhaps that it is a moot issue: mediainfo only gave a max datarate (of 40) for this "still." Is there a quality difference between the mpeg2 and the h.264?

                                  • 14. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                                    m2425 Community Member

                                    Yes but not by much but the compression is way better in H.264, one of my menus I made in Encore CS5, a while back, was 360 MB in MPEG-2 than it went to 170 MB in H.264 when I did the work around. Plus I know that some older blu-ray players can't play blu-rays with 2 different types of video codec.

                                     

                                    And for some reason I can't use BDFix to switch out the videos, I believe its because its a static menu.

                                    • 15. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                                      ram8kumar Community Member

                                      This seems to be a missed bug. The fixed thing applies for motion menus only. I think static menus are missed. Right now, I can not think of a workaround for this issue. Stan has already filed a bug report.

                                       

                                      -Ramesh.

                                      • 16. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                                        m2425 Community Member

                                        Well I hope they fix this through an update, well thanks for the help!

                                        • 17. Re: Encore CS6 Menu
                                          Stan Jones CommunityMVP

                                          Thanks for that confirmation, Ramesh.