9 Replies Latest reply: Jul 20, 2012 9:17 AM by Chris Cox RSS

    Placing files

    community help Community Member

      This question was posted in response to the following article: http://help.adobe.com/en_US/photoshop/cs/using/WSfd1234e1c4b69f30ea53e41001031ab64-78f2a.h tml

        • 1. Re:  Placing files
          Bojan Živković ACP

          There is one very important thing to keep in mind before placing images in Photoshop: every document must have all layers in the same color mode with the same color profile and every layer or element of composition in document must have same resolution, in other words document can not contain elements or layers with different color profile and resolution. When placing pixel based documents it is very important to check first resolution of file to be placed because Photoshop will automatically change resolution to match resolution of document in the way as we do in Image Size dialog with Resample Image turned on what can cause placed document to be upsampled or downsampled. Downsampling is in most cases ok but upsampling is thing to avoid. You can read more with more details, screen-shots and explanation in my post What you should know before placing images in Photoshop and Illustrator - http://adobephotoshopsecrets.blogspot.com/2011/06/what-you-should-know-before-placing.html ss

           

          Message was edited by: Bojan Živković

           

          Message was edited by: Bojan Živković

          • 2. Re:  Placing files
            Chris Cox Adobe Employee

            The modes, bit depths, etc. do not have to match - because Photoshop can convert the placed document into the parent document's colorspace.

            And placing documents with a different resolution is a very common and powerful technique.  You should pay attention to resampling, to make sure it doesn't catch you by surprise - but there's no reason to say that users must avoid it.

            • 3. Re:  Placing files
              Community Member

              Looks like the post by Chris Cox moved Bojan Živković to withdraw his article:

               

              http://adobephotoshopsecrets.blogspot.com/2011/06/what-you-should-know -before-placing.htmlss

               

              Picture 20.png

              • 4. Re:  Placing files
                Chris Cox Adobe Employee

                No, I think he just goofed on the URL.

                • 5. Re:  Placing files
                  Community Member

                  Chris Cox wrote:

                   

                  …he just goofed on the URL.

                   

                  Oh!  Most embarrassing for a thinly-veiled spammer trying to direct traffic to his site where he offers h1s services as a free lancer. 

                  • 6. Re:  Placing files
                    Bojan Živković ACP

                    I get conclusion about color profile because dragging file with Adobe RGB (1998) profile to document with sRGB profile will prompt for profile conversion. Even when do not convert option is choosen colors will be converted to match destination profile. Converting that layer to smart object and editing it will again prompt to convert or to use embedded profile but even use embedded when choosen colors will appear in sRGB gamut. I tried to convert layer to Smart Object before dragging it into another document with different profile and in that case use embedded profile works and colors appears as in profile with wider gamut.

                     

                    Message was edited by: Bojan Živković

                    • 7. Re:  Placing files
                      Bojan Živković ACP

                      I saw hole in help, trying to point to that hole and missing information. Many people are trying to place jpg with low quality and they are satisfied with size but not and with quality. They do not understand where is problem and if they search Photoshop Help they wont find answer because that information is missing. I am trying to contribute to community posting on Adobe Community and providing links to missing explanations. Who are you and what are you dloing for community to leave comment about spam?

                      • 8. Re:  Placing files
                        Community Member

                        Bojan Živković wrote:

                         

                        …Who are you and what are you dloing for community to leave comment about spam?

                         

                        I am just a long-time Photoshop forum user, which is where I am posting.  Your post was moved from Community Help to these user-to-user Photoshop General Discussion forums.

                         

                        Any public post that links to a web site where commercial or professional services are being offered is self promotion that can generally be classified as spam.

                        • 9. Re:  Placing files
                          Chris Cox Adobe Employee

                          The modes, depths, and profiles do not have to match - because Photoshop will convert them to match.

                          Yes, to put pixels into a document those pixels must match the document configuration -- but Photoshop takes care of the conversions, and can warn you about those converstions if you so choose.  The user generally does not have to worry about the conversions because Photoshop will take care of them as needed.