4 Replies Latest reply: Jul 30, 2012 10:28 PM by getho RSS

    help! avchd 720 50p sync issue

    getho Community Member

      Sorry for the similar post, but I've now realised what the major problem is exactly; hoping somone else has had it:

       

      I've got avchd mts files, recorded at 50p.

      Premiere is seeing them as 25fps, plays the video back at half speed (its smooth - so they ARE obvioulsy 50p files).

      Plays the audio back at normal speed so nothing syncs.

       

      VLC plays them back correctly

      codec: h264 - MPEG-4 AVC (part10) (h264)

      Frame rate:50

       

      Interesting erightsoft super shows frame rate of 25 as well.

       

      Same error with mercury playback on or off. Updated QT.

       

      Video Codecs

      TypeNameFormatBinaryVersion
      ICMMicrosoft RLEMRLEmsrle32.dll6.1.7601.17514
      ICMMicrosoft Video 1MSVCmsvidc32.dll6.1.7601.17514
      ICMMicrosoft YUVUYVYmsyuv.dll6.1.7601.17514
      ICMIntel IYUV codecIYUViyuv_32.dll6.1.7601.17514
      ICMHelix I420 YUV CodecI420i420vfw.dll1.2.0.0
      ICMToshiba YUV CodecY411tsbyuv.dll6.1.7601.17514
      ICMCinepak Codec by Radiuscvidiccvid.dll1.10.0.13
      ICMASUS ASV2 CODECASV2asusasv2.dll2.0.0.5
      ICMHelix YV12 YUV CodecYV12yv12vfw.dll1.2.0.0
      DMOMpeg4s Decoder DMOmp4s, MP4S, m4s2, M4S2, MP4V, mp4v, XVID, xvid, DIVX, DX50mp4sdecd.dll6.1.7600.16385
      DMOWMV Screen decoder DMOMSS1, MSS2wmvsdecd.dll6.1.7601.17514
      DMOWMVideo Decoder DMOWMV1, WMV2, WMV3, WMVA, WVC1, WMVP, WVP2wmvdecod.dll6.1.7601.17514
      DMOMpeg43 Decoder DMOmp43, MP43mp43decd.dll6.1.7600.16385
      DMOMpeg4 Decoder DMOMPG4, mpg4, mp42, MP42mpg4decd.dll6.1.7600.16385

       

      is anyone willing to download a source file and see if they get the same thing?  If I can show that its an issue with the source file then at least I can stop trying to "fix" my hardware/software.

       

      Ppro CS5 win7 x64.

       

      Will upgrade to cs6 today if that will fix it!

      heres a small sync test vid straight from camera

      http://pixelpics.com.au/stuff/00001a.MTS

        • 1. Re: help! avchd 720 50p sync issue
          Jeff Bellune ACP

          What camera shot the footage?  My Sony NX5U AVCHD files use CABAC encoding and don't inject text into the file.  According to MediaInfo, your camera didn't use CABAC and there is text injected into the file.  MediaInfo also reports the frame rate as 25 fps.

           

          No matter what I try, the file you uploaded won't play back properly in CS5.5.  Not in the Source Monitor, not in a matching 25 fps sequence, not as a re-interpreted 50 fps subclip and not as the original 25 fps clip in a 50 fps sequence.  I get dropped frames and random frames from other parts of the clip.  My NX5U clips have *never* behaved that way.

           

          Jeff

          • 2. Re: help! avchd 720 50p sync issue
            getho Community Member

            Hi Jeff thanks so much for taking the time to try it out.

            the camera is GH2, bought second hand recently, I just checked the firmware and it was running original firmware when I shot the clips.  I'm going to hack it to see if that helps, but in the meantime i've still got lots of stuff I shot with it that I want to edit.  I downloaded someone elses mts from a hacked GH2 and it VLC reported the frame rate as 100 - which makes me think that for some reason it doubles the reported frame rate.This footage was reported correctly in ppro and played fine.

             

            The thing is although media info reports 25fps on my clips, its definiately 50p.  If I put some of it on my timeline and export movie it does export correctly (without jitters) and in slow mo.

             

            Still head scratching :/

            • 3. Re: help! avchd 720 50p sync issue
              Jeff Bellune ACP

              I'd double-check those exports. 

               

              The original clip duration is locked, The original clip speed is 50 fps.  Pr imports the clip at 25 fps, but with the original duration.  That means only half the frames ever get into Pr.  I can manipulate the video in Pr and the AME so that it syncs perfectly with the clip audio, but only the first half of the clip.  The frames from the second half of the clip never make it into the export/re-timing chain because they never got into Pr or the AME in the first place.

               

              Do you get similar results?

               

              NB: I think Pr knows the extra frames are there, but because the clip's duration is a constraint, it doesn't know what to do with them.  I think that's why I get random frames appearing from later in the clip when I play the clip back in the Source Monitor or in the timeline.  Yet another way to have lots of fun with temporally-compressed footage!

               

              Jeff

              • 4. Re: help! avchd 720 50p sync issue
                getho Community Member

                Hi Jeff, yes that sums it up: I can export OK because I'm only exporting from the first half of the clip.

                 

                I just tested it with the new firmware and it looks OK  - VLC reported the framerate as 100, and appeared to import into premiere at 50fps with no stuttering weirdness.

                Which is great for future stuff but now I just need to work out how to fix the footage I've already taken.

                 

                You said that there was text in the file, I was wondering if its possible to hack that info?  As I said VLC plays it fine (and would rather not reencode frame by frame with something like super, as theres lots of footage).  Thanks for your help