11 Replies Latest reply: Sep 10, 2012 3:32 AM by Jacob Bugge RSS

    Unneeded layout change?

    Claudio González MVP

      When I click to answer to a message, I am taken to this faniliar window:

       

      1.JPG

       

      However, if I click on the Use advanced editor button, the scenario unnecessarily changes to this:

       

      2.JPG

       

      Note that, in contrast with the first layout, I am no longer able to see all previous messages, but only the one I am responding to, which is uncomfortable, as also is the fact that that message is now at the bottom of the reply window.

       

      If there are more people who think that this layout change is not only unnecessary but also uncomfortable, could something be done about this?

        • 1. Re: Unneeded layout change?
          Jacob Bugge MVP

          I am afraid the separate window for the advanced editor has been with us ever since the fair forums fell into the abyss, Claudio.

          • 2. Re: Unneeded layout change?
            Claudio González MVP

            In which you may of course be completely right, but doesn't answer my questions. Am I alone in finding this annoying? If I am not, is it worth raising the issue?

             

            By the way, in other non-Adobe forums I frequent that have advanced editing capabilities, all that changes in the response window when one choses them is the menu.

            • 3. Re: Unneeded layout change?
              the_wine_snob Community Member

              Claudio,

               

              I also find it an annoyance. I do like the ability to scroll through ALL Replies, currently now in the "regular" editor. I do use the "Advanced Editor" often, and feel strongly that it too, needs that capability.

               

              I do hope that the Adobe Forum Team sees this, and though it might be beyond their purview, it should be broached to the Forum Design Team (two different teams, doing two different things in the Adobe Forums). The Adobe Forum Teams is trying to make the overall experience here better, and understand the "contributors," plus the need to make life easier on them. Will everything be incorporated into the forums, in my lifetime? Well, maybe not, but they ARE aware, monitoring and working hard - that I know.

               

              Hunt

               

              PS - Here we are in complete agreement, amigo!

              • 4. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                pwillener ACP/MVPs

                Claudio,

                 

                I also think this behaviour is new, and I cannot fathom what the reason for this could be.  Why hide previous posts when replying???

                 

                Sometimes issues are very complex, and it can be extremely helpful to re-check what has already been written in a long multi-user topic.

                 

                I wonder what these people who think up such changes are thinking...?

                • 5. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                  the_wine_snob Community Member

                  Pat,

                   

                  I wonder what these people who think up such changes are thinking...?

                  I can just imagine a conference room, filled with people listening to their iPods, and iPads, and texting on their iPhones. Suddenly, one screams out, "I have an idea... " then things go downhill from there.

                   

                  Hunt

                  • 6. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                    TerriStone Adobe Employee

                    Claudio, I'll look into this. But it will take me a while to get back to you, as I was out last week and there are a LOT of forum comments to catch up on.

                    • 7. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                      the_wine_snob Community Member

                      Terri,

                       

                      Welcome back!

                       

                      Hunt

                      • 8. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                        TerriStone Adobe Employee

                        Thanks, Bill!

                        • 9. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                          Claudio González MVP

                          Welcome back, but your good intentions are even more welcome...

                          • 10. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                            Phillip Jones Community Member

                            Claudio González wrote:

                             

                            When I click to answer to a message, I am taken to this faniliar window:

                             

                            1.JPG

                             

                            However, if I click on the Use advanced editor button, the scenario unnecessarily changes to this:

                             

                            2.JPG

                             

                            Note that, in contrast with the first layout, I am no longer able to see all previous messages, but only the one I am responding to, which is uncomfortable, as also is the fact that that message is now at the bottom of the reply window.

                             

                            If there are more people who think that this layout change is not only unnecessary but also uncomfortable, could something be done about this?

                             

                            I just changed to it because it was first time I noticed it. I actually like it. Its is putting back features that were ripped out of the forum  a year or more ago.

                            • 11. Re: Unneeded layout change?
                              Jacob Bugge MVP

                              Claudio,

                               

                              This post #28 by John from 17th September 2011 seems to support my conviction that it is an old issue:

                               

                              http://forums.adobe.com/message/3922839#3922839

                               

                              Another issue, when the thread spans more than one page, is the inability to reply to the OP while staying on the actual page and thereby being able to quote other posts. I believe many of us have always done that here in this forum, for posts that continue the general development of the thread.