Panorama in Adobe CC, Lightroom vs. Photoshop

[Ole Plannthin]

I use Lightroom CC (2015) combined with Photoshop CC (2017). I am not expert

In Lightroom I can combine images into a panorama. In the newest version I can use "Boundary Warp".

In Photoshop, I can equivalent combine the same images into a panorama. I have not a "Boundary Wrap" in Photoshop.

What is the difference between using lightroom and Photoshop?

Producing the two systems the same result?

What should I choose?

Regards

Ole

[KanikaS]

Moving to Photoshop General Discussion​

[John Waller · Accepted solution]

Ole Plannthin wrote:

I have not a "Boundary Wrap" in Photoshop.

Yes you do. There's a Boundary Warp slider in the Camera Raw plugin.

How to create panorama using Camera Raw 9.4 and later

Ole Plannthin wrote:

What is the difference between using lightroom and Photoshop?

Producing the two systems the same result?

What should I choose?

Use whichever you are most comfortable with and suits your workflow better. You may end up using both at different times.

[Ole Plannthin]

Hei John,

Thanks for your reply, informations and corrections

About Boundery Warp in Photoshop you wrote: "There's a Boundery Warp slider in the Camera Raw plugin".

I have tried to follow the instructions in your link, and can thus understand what you mean. Nice

Previously, I chose to open the photos from Lightroom with "Edit in Adobe Photoshop witn CC 2017 ...". With the images in photoshop, I used: File > Auitomate > Photomerge. Here there was not a "Boundery Warp".

Regards

Ole

[John Waller]

Previously, I chose to open the photos from Lightroom with "Edit in Adobe Photoshop witn CC 2017 ...". With the images in photoshop, I used: File > Auitomate > Photomerge. Here there was not a "Boundery Warp".

Let Adobe know that you'd like to see the Boundary Warp slider added to the Photomerge dialogue.

Submit your feature request via this form:

Feature Request/Bug Report Form

[Ole Plannthin]

Done

[Conrad C]

Ole Plannthin wrote:

What is the difference between using lightroom and Photoshop?

Producing the two systems the same result?

What should I choose?

They don't produce the same format. Lightroom and Camera Raw produce a result in DNG (raw) format, which has some advantages if you want to keep adjusting the panorama. Photoshop produces a non-raw Photoshop document only.

If you want the result to be a DNG (raw) file or you want to use the Boundary Warp feature, merge the images in Lightroom or Camera Raw.

If you want to use some of the panorama merge features that Photoshop has that Lightroom and Camera Raw don't have, such as a wider choice of projection types or the Content-Aware Fill Empty Areas option, then merge them in Photoshop.