-
1. Re: Old Time Rock and Roll with AE and Element 3D
(Please stop deleting this post. It relates to using Element in AE. As a MVP for Adobe I think its valid to share and answer any questions that relate to using this plugin. If you disagree lets talk with Todd K. about this so it can be resolved in a reasonable manner. Thank you.}
But then again, there was no question... I'm sure such posts fall under one of the "no self-promotion/ no product promotion" rules and you're linking to a video that uses copyrighted music, too. Or am I wrong?
Mylenium
-
2. Re: Old Time Rock and Roll with AE and Element 3D
Its posted on You Tube and linked to several other Adobe and Creative Cow sites. They dont have an issue with that. Questions can be elicited by sharing projects. If you are moderating lets continue with discussion with Adobe privately.
-
3. Re: Old Time Rock and Roll with AE and Element 3D
Just saying... There sure is some legal stuff involved here and the forum guidelines say something about not posting copyrighted stuff, which in my opinion includes links to such content...
Mylenium
-
4. Re: Old Time Rock and Roll with AE and Element 3D
Lets consult Adobe on this since its on several of its forums. I will respond to whatever they feel is appropriate since it is their website ;-)
Todd , please contact me at [ email removed by admin ]. I would prefer to continue this dialog in a more appropriate place.
-
5. Re: Old Time Rock and Roll with AE and Element 3D
Since the post also appears in the Video Lounge (here: http://forums.adobe.com/thread/1111206), I think that it was a reasonable moderation decision to delete the duplicate.
-
6. Re: Old Time Rock and Roll with AE and Element 3D
This topic has gotten several moderation requests.
Yes, the copyrighted music isn't a great idea -- but the basic video is reasonable and relevant to the forum.
Yes, it is self promotion of a sort, but showing off not as much as selling. That is also relevant.
I'll vote to let it stay.
-
7. Re: Old Time Rock and Roll with AE and Element 3D
As a participant in many Adobe forums I find that different folks tend to frequent them.
My thought was the After Effects forum was particularly appropriate since lots of folks are just beginning to put Element to serious use. The Video Lounge is another totally different group of friends that I just enjoy sharing, getting feedback and starting dialogs with. And in the Premiere forum it touches upon use of dynamic link and just how solid it is today.
I see it as just targeting different groups of users. If there are no over riding legal concerns, I would hope to be able to communicate with all the various folks I have been in contact with for the last several years in this manner.