9 Replies Latest reply on Apr 5, 2017 4:58 PM by deans67202452

    After Effects error TDL

    drfleming

      I've never seen this one before...I created a block in Illustrator and typed some letters to cut out of the block by creating outlines and then making a compound path to cut out the letters.

       

      I brought the file into AE to be used in a ray-traced 3D comp to get some extrusion and environment mapping on it.  When creating the outlines from the vector layer, I get:

       

      "After Effects error: TDL: outline contains traingles that are too small to be rendered. Check for very thin triangles in original artwork. (88::3)"

       

      Any ideas?

       

      Dave

        • 1. Re: After Effects error TDL
          Mylenium Most Valuable Participant

          You need to clean up your text. This error points to "illogical" non-convex curves or otehr issues like multiple anchor points in the same location, self-intersecting shapes, non-contiguous contours, to thin areas and so on. Whatever it is, only meticulously prepping your shapes will fix it.

           

          Mylenium

          • 2. Re: After Effects error TDL
            drfleming Level 1

            Unfortunately, that isn't the problem.  But, I do have more information about how this error is occuring.  The error occurs not when making the shapes from the vector layer - that works OK.  But, as soon as I try to make the new outline layer 3D by clicking the 3D box on the layer, I get the error.

             

            To test this further, I created a box in Illustrator.  I typed the letter "I" in the box, created outlines for the letter and made a compound path for the cutout shape.  So, in other words, the simplest shape I could possibly make that still gives me the look I want.  I imported the file to AE, made shapes from the vector layer...OK.  Turned the layer into 3D - boom - got the error.

             

            Is this a bug?

             

            Dave

            • 3. Re: After Effects error TDL
              vfxcick

              I am having this same problem also.  I can tell it's from the font I'm using, I believe it was created for our network in-house.  I can type in text just fine as long as the layer is in 2D, but once I convert it to a 3D layer (or open a project with 3D layers in this font) I fet an error.

               

              Seems like the solution would be either

              1) DOn't use 3D layers for text

              2) Clean up that font.

               

              Unfortunately, 1) is not possible because this is an established animation for network tune-in end cards and can't be changed at the moment.  I would love to 2) clean up the font, but I'm not sure how one does that (I'm an animator).

               

              Any advice?

               

              Specs:

              Mac OSX 10.7.3

              2x2.66 6-core Intel

              16GB RAM

              ATI Radeon HD 5770 1024 MB

              AE CS6 11.0.0.378

               

              Thanks!

              erica

               

              edited to include screen cap of the fonts in question!

              Screen Shot 2013-01-03 at 3.45.34 PM.png

              • 4. Re: After Effects error TDL
                drfleming Level 1

                Hi Erica,

                 

                To respond to your two solutions...

                 

                1) I'm in a situation where I must use 3D to match other 3D text and graphics on screen.  There's just no reason why these two programs shouldn't work together better.

                 

                2) The font in question is Helvetica Neue.  I can't think of a more generic "vanilla" sans serif font than that one.  Like I said in my test graphic (white box with the letter "I" making a cutout), there's literally 8 points in the entire shape.  So, something else is clearly wrong and there's no need to "clean up the font."

                 

                Somebody on the COW forum suggested I try expanding the appearance from the object menu in Illustrator before export.  I will try that tomorrow when I'm in front of it again.

                 

                Dave

                • 5. Re: After Effects error TDL
                  Mylenium Most Valuable Participant

                  I can't say anything beyond what I already stated. We had this error a couple of times on the forum over the last year and if cleaning up the contours or using a different font doesn't resolve it, I don't know what else to advise. I won't rule out that it is some bug of sorts, but I suspect the files would work just fine on anotehr system, so investigating this from afar by opening the project files would not be that helpful...

                   

                  Mylenium

                  • 6. Re: After Effects error TDL
                    Mylenium Most Valuable Participant

                    That is exactly the kind of font you should not use. If you inspect it in AI based on the converted contours you will no doubt see all sorts of issues like unconnected paths, holes inside holes/ intersecting other holes and so on. Without a lot of extra preparation this will never work, I'm afraid...

                     

                    Mylenium

                    • 7. Re: After Effects error TDL
                      drfleming Level 1

                      What I did in the final analysis to get things to work (I'm on a deadline, just like everybody else), was to switch fonts a few times until I fould something that would work.  I ended up using Brandon Grotesque instead of Helvetica Neue, which I think we would both agree are pretty similar sans serif fonts.  But, for some reason, it likes the one and not the other.

                       

                      I did have a colleague in another state duplicate my workflow and he got the same result (error at first, then OK when switching fonts), so, in my opinion, that spells B-U-G.  Plus, I have multiple other AI objects within the same comp, all with shapes made from vectors - highly complex shapes at that - and AE has no problem with them.

                       

                      df

                      • 8. Re: After Effects error TDL
                        Todd_Kopriva Level 8

                        Any time that you think that you have encountered a bug, please report it here:

                        http://adobe.ly/ReportBug

                         

                        (That's the same bug-report form that you get by choosing Help > Send Feedback in the After Effects application.)

                        • 9. Re: After Effects error TDL
                          deans67202452 Level 2

                          This is an old post but if someone is still having a problem with this error, the best way around it is to change the font (not ideal) or convert your text to a shape before making it a 3d layer. Hopefully this helps