Do you get the same hang if you copy the file to your local machine first, then open it?
Yep, the issue happens when working on large files locally also.
Issue usually won't happen straight away, happens reliably after working on large files for an hour or two. Annoying to try replicate I guess.
Any ideas or things you'd like me to try? I've turned background saving off temporarily but after 30 mins the whole computer froze, so that's back on.
If the whole computer froze - then you're looking at hardware problems, OS bugs, or low level driver bugs.
But without more details, it just sounds like it's taking a lot of time to process a huge file.
After PS froze, you could tab between programs for a bit, but then Finder froze and couldn't be relaunched. I believe that PS is affecting the windowserver process (which explains the behaviour of the app and the window getting stuck on top), which in this case resulted in a systemwide crash.
We're running Mac Pro systems from 2009 which are very stable, basic NVIDIA graphics, recently re-imaged with a blank 10.6.8 and installed CS6. We didn't get this problem in CS4 (skipped 5 and 5.5).
The problem is that the PDF was only a 2MB file. Why would PS be going crazy with disk writing activity when a PDF is imported? Is it writing everything out of the RAM?
If you rasterize at a large size, or if the contents of the PDF decompress to something large - Photoshop will have to page data to the scratch file. As you allocate memory (RAM), the OS will also grow it's swapfile - both of which cause disk activity beyond just reading the PDF file. Plus the PDF can reference fonts and color profiles that need to be loaded, and could reference linked files that have to be loaded, etc.
Chris, while I very much appreciate your time and support, I feel like you are telling me this is either expected behaviour or a computer problem. While that could be the case, there are elements here that make me think otherwise:
This is not one particular PDF I'm referring to, but any PDF, even the most simple and basic text based document. It seems that the PDF document itself doesn't make a difference, but the action of opening one.
Just to confirm, PS is hanging and also causing unexpected behaviour in the windowserver process by forcing panels ontop of other programs that are in the foreground. We're also experiencing ~75MB/s disk write for the duration (75MB x 60 sec x 2 mins = ~9GB) of the hang.
We're currently working on artwork that did not exhibit this phenomena under CS4. Could this be a bug?
Without seeing the files involved, it sounds expected.
There might be a real problem - but I'd have to examine the files to determine that.
Photoshop should not force anything on top of other applications, nor interfere with the window server.
We have some cases where we think other applications (browsers) are causing similar issues, but nothing that we can determine is caused by Photoshop itself.
I also experience this problem. Everyday!
CS6, MAC 10.6.8
I work at a print shop, and customers always send PDF files. Not beacuse their vector. Raster files are sent as PDF's as well.
Everytime I open up a PDF in Adobe Photoshop, the program freezes for about 5 Min or more. I cant exit out, only force quit the program. The only work-around I know of is to convert to tiff in acrobat or illustrator. Super annoying work-around. Adobe Photoshop should know what you trying to do.
Adobe should fix this. I dont think were the only ones who experence this problem......
Also Chris Cox, you should have a more helpful attitude. Sounds like you trying to play the blame game....
I'm trying to help here.
But without example files to examine and reproduce the problem, we can't do much.
And it's not blame when you tell someone the truth about where the problem exists (ie: whole system freezing has to be hardware, OS or drivers).
My guess is that this is not a core Photoshop problem (or we'd be hearing a lot more complaints and see the problem ourselves), but something in a font manager or other utility that only happens to people who have that utility installed.
Give me an email and I will send the next PDF that crashes Photoshop.
CS6, MAC 10.6.8
ccox (at) adobe (dot) com
Also, this was talking about hangs, not crashes.
Hangs/freezes and crashes are very different things.
Sent you an email. Never got a response.
Exact same problem here.
If you start afresh and open a PDF it will open with no problems.
The next time you try there is a 50:50 chance the Photoshop PDF dialogue box will freeze.
The longer Photoshop has been open, the worse it gets - until there is a 100% chance any PDF will freeze PS.
Exactly the same for me - as described by VMount, with all the 8 minute hangs and furious drive bashing described, all for a simple pdf import.
FYI - this happened to me with CS3/4 on a PPC and Intel Tower, also, I've now got a MacBook Pro using CS6 and the problem continues
I'm having the exact same problem. And it does seem like the longer photoshop is open, the more it happens. I think it might be font related — when I converted a file to outlines and made a pdf, I was able to open it in photoshop.
eastbayLA, this might be useful information. Is it the case as well for other members?
I've had exactly the same problem since installing CS6. Seems worse the longer Photoshop has been running. Even the simplest PDF causes the hang. If I re-start Photoshop the next PDF seems to open OK, but then the problem returns quickly.
If I wait five+ minutes the problem usually resolves itself, but it's quicker to force-quit Photoshop and start again.
Hi all, add me to the list of people that has had this issue for a long time, and like JointyJr I think it's even been since CS3...
As some of you suggest it might have something to do with font management; could Fontagent Pro be involved? I've been using this font manager and the plugins that come with it over the same period that this bug has been around, but I guess it would be too much of a coincidence that all of you are using Fontagent Pro as well?
I have suspected it of being involved in other strange behaviour like program errors and freezes, also within Photoshop, so even if just for the sake of ruling it out... anyone?
Definately not any font management software causeing this - I have none installed, I'm just using Font Book.
Using fseventer I saw only two noatble processes writing to my hard drive was "com.adobe.mediabrowser.plist" and there was something being written in private/var/folders/z1 "PSNormalizer" .
Spotlight was also up to somehting too.
Count me as another having the same problem (CS6 & Mac OS 10.6.8). I need to open pdfs in Photoshop all the time and it's driving me crazy!
Basically I open a pdf and the Import PDF dialog box pops up, but then hangs for 3-4 minutes. I'd estimate it happens about 50% of the time. I haven't been able to figure out any pattern as to why it happens or doesn't happen.
I also have CS5 installed and have never had the same issue there (with the same pdfs).
Hey Chris or anyone else from Adobe - is there any chance we can get this looked at slightly more in-depth?
This issue is re-occurring across our four Mac Pro workstations of various ages and operating systems.
Why is Photoshop writing out the contents of the RAM when I open a pdf?
We're working with machines that have 8-16GB worth of RAM and having to write that out to the scratch disk every time you open a PDF is very unproductive use of our time.
It's nice and easy to blame everything else like fonts or drivers or operating system or graphics cards or RAM or Acts of God, but how about for a second we assume that Photoshop is the cause, look at how we'd test for it and ultimately get it resolved.
This is the sort of issue that the average consumer would probably just ignore or deal with, which could explain why you guys don't believe this to be a bug. Seems to be picking up a lot more attention on here.
Same issue here. Was there ever a solution?
Same issue. No progress?
After I force quit Photoshop when this happens, it usually takes 3 times reopening the program to get it to work. The first few times it just bounces in the dock for a few minutes and then closes again.
I too have been experiencing this for a couple of years now with various releases of Photoshop on various machines. I now have a brand spanking new iMac with 16gb Ram and the very latest Photoshop CC 2014.0.0 release and STILL this happens! Adobe should address this now.
This is still an issue in CC2014.
PDF Generated on this machine (MacPro 2010) by InDesign 2014 CC – Drag PDF to Photoshop launches import pdf modal box then hangs, spinning beach ball, whole system laggy if you try and move to other programmes, sometimes eventually it'll suddenly right itself and allow you to finally click 'ok' - other times it'll sit there and slowly consume system resources till you get bored and restart.
Just recreated the 'condition' :
as you can see, Photoshops hangs while a massive tempoaray file is being written to
Hard drive write speeds have reached 108MB and Photoshop has hung for up to 8 minutes, after that that large file vanishes and all is normal again
The PDFS can be any size, with or without fonts embedded, with or without graphics or any kind. Has been happening for numerous versions of Photoshop.
Let me know if you need any more info.
Happens to me all the time too. I also noticed that it happens when PDF contains raster images. Even small ones. If it's vectors-only then Photoshop opens it fast. Hope it helps. This issue is really annoying.
Just add me to the list, happens all the time
This is still occurring at least two years after being first reported on this forum. Everyone I know who works with pdf's in Photoshop has exactly the same issue. This is a MAJOR bug that seems to be being swept under the carpet for some reason that Adobe are unwilling to relinquish. I work within the Digital Marketing sector and personally know a huge amount of both colleagues and competitors who have hugely varying setups yet we all still encounter this debilitating issue.
An answer or at least some kind of communication would be most welcome Adobe.
Still happening in CC 2015. Would've thought Adobe would have fixed this by now. This is not good enough Adobe!
Same here. For years. Crazy that it's still an issue in CC 2015. Minutes-long hangs every time I open any PDF with raster data, while the hard drive churns away. Import dialog moveable but sticks in front of all other applications. Photoshop can be cmd-tab'd back to, but it's menubar doesn't come back until it finally finishes unknotting its panties.
Update: I have also found trying to rasterise any type of vector file is also creating this hang
Saving a Photoshop PDF
I too have been having this problem for some time
Only fix is a reboot, then PS CS6 will occasionally open ANY PDF.
Once PS hangs I can sometimes force a quit
After that PS may or may not launch until I reboot
Update 2: Saving a Photoshop PDF - stops saving at 10% - causes that massive write out to the hard-drive.
This time no beachball, am able to continue using Photoshop.
Raising my hand for having a similar issue - maybe the same, maybe not the same.
Opening Photoshop for the first time after starting up - or opening photoshop after computer running all day - same issue.
I launch Photoshop (CC2015 running on Windows 10), no hangs, no delay, all good. I open ANY FILE (PSD, jpg, no matter, ANY FILE), and the file opens as expected. As soon as I click anything Photoshop will hang about 30 seconds. I can select other windows outside of Photoshop, my computer is NOT hung. It's as if Photoshop is checking for an update, or communicating with Adobe - and hangs until it times out. After about 30 seconds Photoshop becomes responsive again. I don't see any unexplained network traffic, and no additional processes seem to launch. It FEELS like Photoshop is attempting to connect with a source, and only responds after the source times out.
That's my hypothesis.
In the meantime, it's absolutely consistent, and only happened after the latest CC update (r168 x64)
Has Adobe completely ignored this problem? I run into this every day. The Import PDF dialog just freezes up with the spinning beachball coming up for minutes at a time on even simple pdfs. I've found that it's often just faster to force-quite Photoshop and re-launch than it is to wait for Photoshop to become responsive again.
I'm not sure that Jamesd posted this as a bug in the relevant place and I'm not sure whether Adobe patrols the site for issues like this.
This is definitely caused by the way pdfs get rendered - the cause of the hang always happen by the look of it - that massive HD write session that occurs. It either happens in the background without notice (albeit a slow down due to the large amount of data being written) or a beachball which seizes PS for up to 8 minutes or more.
yes, add me to the list too, this has happened for years. currently running cc 2015. was there any solution from adobe?
I run into this issue every single day without fail. I know as soon as I drag a PDF to place in Photoshop, it's going to freeze for a good 5 minutes before I can move on. I can still jump to other programs and work on other things while I wait at least. Once it gets its act back together, I can usually place the same file again without the delay.