I agree with you, but alas, that is NOT the case!
Select the CROP tool. Click and hold to turn on "Show Overlay."
In the Photoshop APP's dedicated CROP tool, there are options.
In LightRoom's dedicated Crop tool, there are options.
In Camera RAW (of ANY vintage) there remains ONLY the Rule of Thirds (which appears by default when Show Overlay is selected, and not by name or by choice.)
I don't have CC nor LR. Just be sure you are comparing apples to apples.
There is a vast difference whether you are cropping in Adobe Camera Raw, technically a plugin, or in an application like Photoshop or Lightroom. And yes I would expect differences between applications as they don't do much cross exchange of ideas. But the cropping in CC version of ACR should be the same.
I don't have CC nor LR. Just be sure you are comparing apples to apples
That is a nice statement for a Windows guy…
I never use crop in ACR because I like this feature more in PS itself. Also the inability to save crop presets in ACR makes it very limited. The ACR engine for PS and LR are the same, the body differs.
Thanks to hard yelling people we now have about the same crop tool in PS as in LR. Although I still don't like it in PS, after having used it years and years I now have to move the image instead of the crop.
Sadly the ability to rotate crop and having adjust it automatically to the borders is a very nice option. If it wasn't for this I would stay with the old classic mode.
But the OP is right, many features in different Adobe Products have somewhat the same result but sometimes very different approaches, options and tools.
Until the Adobe HQ is going to settle in Utopia we might be better off trying to learn living with it