3 Replies Latest reply on Aug 29, 2013 8:19 AM by Bob Currier

    Color changes in preview

    Oleg Bolsh

      Hello, I'm so tired trying to figure out the reason of a problem in Premiere Pro (my version is 6.0.4). I'm very frustrated just because I've spent too much time trying to solve the problem which is so ridiculous! What I'm doing is just trying to color corect my footage with the help of Color Finesse plugin. The problem is that I can see different results in full screen Color Finesse preview and PP windows preview. Sure you could kick me off this forum saying that it's not Premiere Pro but 3-d party plugin problem but I want to tell you that it's not!

       

      The point is that I can see the right result of the color correction in Premiere Pro when I'm scrolling the preview unless I mouse up to stop the timeline cursor being dragged. Once I just mouse up the image in preview changes! I even set up the similar options of resolution for playback and pause in preview but I still can see the same issue. I also tried to change the sequence options of preview rendering (max bit depth, max rendering quality) but all in vain. I surely get this result when exporting - it seems that PP use in this situation the same rendering engine as what is shown in preview when the cursor stops.

       

      But what really confuses me that in dragging timeline cursor mode I can see the proper colors that I made with Color Finesse! Isn't it an issue?! Haven't anybody noticed anything similar? The image in my case seems to be more red and whites are cut. I thought that there is might be some problems with color spaces but I just don't know what to do in Premiere! I tried to color correct my footage in After Effects with the same Color Finesse settings and then export it  - everything is ok with colors! But not in premiere! By the way in both cases of exporting (premiere, after effects) I can see that the result image is in YUV color space with chroma subsampling 4:2:0, 8 bits, progressive though I choose RGB in After Effects when exporting (I can see it in Media Player Classic's properties of the footage).

       

      MRproblem1.jpgMRproblem2.jpg

       

      Please, can anyone help me with this issue or is it really an Adobe Premiere bug?

       

      I thought that there are some problems with color spaces and tried to watch YC waveform. But I guess that my original footage was even worse in it though I can not see any issues or color cutting with my original footage in premiere pro window. Color finesse window show another results. What's happening?...

       

      MRproblem3.jpgMRproblem4.jpg

      MRproblem5.jpgMRproblem6.jpg

        • 1. Re: Color changes in preview
          Bob Currier Level 3

          The reason for this is that Premiere Pro hands us (Color Finesse) an 8-bit version of your image when dragging and when inside the full Color Finesse UI. Because it's an 8-bit RGB image, overbrights get cut off, and there was an extra YUV->RGB conversion performed.

           

          When rendering, and when you stop dragging, PPro gives us a floating-point YUV image, which Color Finesse is happy to process without any problems clipping overbrights. But because the image format is different, there may be visible differences, depending on the footage.

           

          I don't really have a good solution for you. There have been some changes in the PPro CC plug-in API that may help us; we're currently investigating how we can take advantage of that.

           

          If it helps, the result you see in PPro when not dragging is what will render to your final output.

           

          Bob Currier

          Synthetic Aperture

          • 2. Re: Color changes in preview
            Oleg Bolsh Level 1

            Thank you, Bob, for answering. And I would also would like to thank you for creating such a convenient instrument for After Effects (cause you see - I seem to can not use it under premiere pro).

            I guessed that in dragging mode PPro tried to optimise rendering in different ways clipping it from all the sides etc. But the problem is that all is vice versa: I do like the result in dragging mode and it's the same as in full Color Cinesse instrument and I can see clipping in stop cursor preview mode. Unfortunately there is no any difference on Ppro YCwaveform in this two modes (dragging, stop cursor) so I have to load images from footages (from Composite Video view).

            MRproblem7.jpgMRproblem8.jpg

            That's why It does not help that the result I see in PPro when not dragging is what will render to my final output (maybe I'm wrong, maybe highlights are not cut but just more reddish...but I can feel more difference in video - the first one looks much better).

            Do I correctly understand that dragging mode differs from stopping not just in that 8-bit image is handed instead of 32-bit but also that the first one is RGB but the second one is YUV (there are no YUV modes in Color Finesse full interface in some reason)? So is it possible that clipping happens with 32-bit YUV image? We could test your plugin by feeding it my original video footage (you should test it in PPro) - if you wish - and you could see - why there is difference (I understand that it may take some time so I seem to not wait to the results and find another way of color correcting though I very much like Color Finesse).

             

            So - I'm sorry. In this case the problem seems to be exactly in Color Finesse? But anyway I don't understand why not implement Color Management in PPro such as it's done in After Effects or maybe even better by having several options. I think that sometimes you'd better have several options instead having no ability to do something.

             

            P.S. Bob, I also have a suggestion for your plugin - it's kind of UI improvement. It's a good idea to have the ability to reset each option (each slider) by just double clicking on it's name just as it's done in Lightroom.

            • 3. Re: Color changes in preview
              Bob Currier Level 3

              Premiere Pro handles AE-style plug-ins differently than AE itself does. I understand why in most cases, but it can still cause issues like you're seeing. Whether handling things differently is a bug or not is not worth arguing about; the important thing is to minimize any side effects.

               

              The difference you're seeing is because--for performance reasons--Premiere Pro sends the smaller 8-bit RGB images to plug-ins when doing something interactive. This helps keep things realtime. But once you stop interacting, it passes the more accurate YUV float image to the plug-in. Additionally, when Color Finesse requests frames from PPro when in the full UI, it is always given 8-bit RGB (this part I consider a bug).

               

              So I understand why there is a difference, but not why you're seeing the difference you are.

               

              Whether PPro sends the plug-in YUV integer, YUV float, or RGB float to the plug-in depends on the codec in use; Color Finesse can handle all those formats. Because of this it would be good to be able to test with your footage. The possible issues could be 8-bit to float conversion, YUV to RGB conversion, or some combination of the two. Being able to test your specific case would help.

               

              You can send a short bit of footage to us at support "at" synthetic-ap "dot" com. Also send along your Color Finesse correction settings. We probably can't get to it until next week but I would like to definitively understand what's going on.

               

              Regarding resetting a single slider: if you command/control click on the text it will reset the parameter. Resetting by double-clicking is a good enhancement request though.

               

              Bob Currier

              Synthetic Aperture