What operating system? My laptop slowed to a crawl after it updated from Windows 8 to 8.1. When I checked Preferenes > Performance, I found that GPU Acceleration was no longer ticked, but a visit to the nVidea driver site fixed it.
Thanks Trevor (sorry for the late response!)
Actually, I'm still using Windows 7, and it's not the computer that's slow - only that one tool. It's really weird!! I checked my video card and it seems to be set up fine...
Thanks for the advice, though!
Do you have the latest drivers for the video card? Just becasue it worked in CS5 is no guarantee it will work in CC as that program puts a much heaver load on the gpu.
Update from makers site, not MS.
I went ahead and updated my drivers again, but it did not help at all. (Radeon HD 5800) The tool is SO slow that it's pretty much useless. It was one of the reasons I wanted CC. That and Content Aware - which works fine. I'm thinking there's some setting somewhere that makes it slow?
Just to clarify things a bit: Is it slow while you are painting with the tool or after you release the mouse button? Is it significantly faster if you work with low-res files or is it the same?
When I hold the mouse button and drag it is as slow as just clicking and letting go. The longer I hold and drag, the longer it has to process once I let go. The smaller the file, the faster it works, but it didn't used to be like that.
PS Your screen name is awesome.
I am asking just to try and figure out if its related to GPU acceleration or not. I think that once you release the mouse button the ordinary CPU takes over to fix the selection. So your reply would suggest that it's not related to your GPU, at least I think that's a reasonable assumption. I suppose you could try and play around with the GPU acceleration settings under Edit/Preferences/Performance/
The tool is quite slow. Where I teach, we have PS CS6 running on pretty slow computers and the tool is a pain to use at higher resolutions, so I always make sure to use low-res images when showing how it works.
What are your computer specs? I assume you have disabled "Sample All Layers" and "Auto-Enhance" in the tool settings? Because these will slow it down even further. I suppose you could try and reset the PS preferences (this will also reset your personal preferences!). Hold down Ctrl + Option + Shift while starting up Photoshop. A dialog box will appear asking if you wish to delete the preferences/settings file.
Other than that I can't come up with anything else at the moment. If you are unlucky it might just be that the tool is more demanding in CC on your computer. But let us know if my suggestions made any difference.
Thanks! I am surprised that the username wasn't already taken!
I mentioned working on my laptop without GPU acceleration, and how much it slowed everything down, but Quick Select was still laggy after the driver updated and GPU acceleration restored. This is a reasonable laptop with i7, 16Gb and GTX680. Thankfully, I got my main system back yesterday, and Quick select is pretty much instant.
But there shouldn't be that much difference. The big box has six core running at 4.2Ghz (under load) 32GB and GTX570, so while it is certainly more powerful, the difference in performance in respect to Quick Select is not proportional. I've just tried reducing cache levels on the big box from the '6' it usually runs at right down to 2, but it still responds instantly even with large files. I have GPU set to Advanced, and tile size to 128 on both systems.
Another odd thing is that I only have 1GB vRAM with the GTX570, where the GTX680 has 4Gb of faster vRAM. But maybe Quick select is not a big user of GPU acceleration.
So no real help I am afraid. I have looked through the GPU FAQ, but nothing helpful there. OK, I have just found a more detailed article on GPU acceleration, and it mentions a lot of features, but not Quick Select, so it could be that GPU is irrelevant. The laptop is Windows 8.1 as opposed win 7 for the big box, if that makes a difference. Can you correlate anything between our systems? I hate to post this without any suggestions, but I'm stumped.
There are tricks to aid Quick select.
- Make a copy of the layer, and apply Curves and/or Levels directly to the layer, and try to increase contrast between the subject and background. Use this layer to make the selection, then switch back to the normal layer to use the selection.
- I don’t know if this will work as I have just thought of it. Copy the layer, and Free Transform it to a smaller size. It will be image dependant, but Quick Select is much faster with images below about 1500 pixels wide. Use Quick select on the smaller image layer, and copy the selection to a new layer. FT it back up to size, and it should fit. This would only be useful if you are going to use Refine Edge right after, and will have obvious limitations.
Make sure you report back if you find a solution.
1 person found this helpful
Hey! I had the SAME problem... solved in 30 minutes because I had put CC on my laptop and the Quick Selection tool is fast, but on my Mega-fast desktop (16gb, 4.2Ghz, blah, blah) Photoshop CC was DRAGGING BUTT.
The difference is I loaded the desktop from scratch. The Laptop had CS5 prviously, and PS copied the settings from Edit/Preferences/Performance that existed in CS5... it was all about the History & Cache section. Hit "Big and Flat" for the 1024K cache tile size, and it set the cache states to 6. I backed that up to 4... eh whatever
You are welcomed
(I was about to uninstall the PS CC! It's all good now... BTW - I even yanked out the Nvidia GTS450 thinking it was a driver issue, but there was no difference with the onboard Intel HD Haswell i5 4th gen graphics... so, don't do that!)
[edited] I just did some experimenting, 8 levels with a small cache size works too... so, just get out of the 2 levels at 128k if that is what you are set at. I am at Big and Flat which is 6 levels/1024K.
Sulaco: Thanks for your help! I run a 16gb RAM desktop that my husband is jealous of and says I could use it for gaming, so I wouldn't expect it to be slow. I tried resetting the specs and made sure the tool settings were as you described and it didn't help much. I started working with the low res images until that last poster came up with the solution.
Trevor.Dennis: I appreciate all the time you took to try and figure out the problem! And coming up with the work around. It is much appreciated!! I tried the cache levels you recommended and it was just as slow. I used your workaround until the solution got posted:
Shootmyphoto.com: THANK YOU SO MUCH!! I would not have expected lowering the cache states to make it work faster! Once I changed the cache states down to 4 and tile size to 1024K it went back to normal!!
And, I would like to add, you solved an additional problem I was too busy to post about - when I opened a file that was shot at ISO 400+, the photo looked extremely grainy/noisy in photoshop CC, but completely normal in any other program or online. Now after I changed those settings, the photos look normal again!! THANK YOU!
Cool to hear that you solved the problem! Also nice to learn something new, thanks shootmyphoto! I have never fully understood how cache levels and tile size works! Mine is set to 4 and 1024K also ...
Thanks Tim!!! You sugestion worked like a charm!
Trevor's answer worked for me AFTER I remembered to restart PS after making the prefernces changes.
One of the biggies with Preferences > Performance — supposing GPU accelleration is enabled — is making sure Cache levels are set to something other than 1. In fact there is a warning against this at the bottom of the History and Cache area.
[EDIT] Incidentally, my primary Scratch disk overflowed recently with four separate temp files. One of them did have an old date on it, so would have been orphaned off by Photoshop shutting down unexpectedly. I'm not even sure why I am using it, but is just old habbit of bumping old drives when upgrading, so the D: drive is a single 300Gb Velociraptor (2nd gen ?). The E: drive has a pair of 1Tb 6th Gen V'Raptors, which tested at >350Mb/s so I should probably use that as Primary Scratch. Just not sure what I'd use the 300Gb drive for. When I get round to bumping my boot drive with a pair of 250Gb Samsung EVOs, I will need another mainboard SATA header, so probably just trash the 300Gb drive.
up till yesterday everything worked fine on my copy of Ps CC. Then I encountered "all of the sudden" the same issue as described in the original post. Glad, the solution offered to the original poster works, but it didn't work for me and as I read, I am not the only one. And apart from that, I suffered crashes as well ...
I looked at the performance settings in my copy of Ps CS6 (in which the quick selection tool works fine) and they were exactly the same as in Ps CC. But I oversaw the amount of RAM appointed to Ps ... Then I recollected, that I had changed this setting in Ps CC the day before. Because I have 24 Gig of RAM, I put up the slider there to the max Ps recommends. (i.e. appr. 15 Gig). I put the slider back a little (appr. 13 Gig) and everything worked fine again ...
So, no driver updates, no cache level or graph card resettings necessary here. Just try this simple solution ....
You're my hero!!! This solved the problem on windows 7 with 12gb of ram and Adobe Phtoshop CC 2014.
Im sorry to bring this topic up again. But none of the above suggestions work for me. Quick selection too is getting slower the more area I select. Any ideas?
I'm using PS CC 2014. After updating I noticed that quick selection was unuseably slow. I went to Edit / Preferences / Performance and noticed that cache levels was set to 1. Increased it to 4 and the problem was solved. Notice that is necessary to exit and restart PS for the modifications to be effective.
Just one more advice if you are having this issue.
1) i set as ppl told here the chacle levels to 8 and cache tile to 1024
2) i set the scratch disk to only my fast SSD HD
3) MOST IMPORTANT ---> Changes only did effect after i closed and restarted the Photoshop CC.
I hope this help someone !
Tims suggestion worked like a charm for me. The tool works instantly now. I changed to big and flat (which initially changed the tile to 128k) then I changed that to 1024k, set my cache level and history state to 6, restarted photoshop, and it worked.
Now if I can just get lightroom cc 2015 to stop crashing I'll be set. Looking into this on other forums. Thanks guys!
I have changed the settings using some of the above suggestions but nothing has worked for me. I recently updated from Photoshop 2014 CC to 2015 CC. I am on a Mac with 4gb ram and 2.66 Dual Core Processor, but never had quick selection behaving so slow until I updated. My current settings are cache level and history 6, tile 1024k, and I have restarted photoshop.
Thank you this worked for me, I have been tearing my hair out with it.
Your suggestions have been gratefully appreciated THANKYOU
I'm having this problem and it even extends to certain selections made through other methods. I've done all of the advice in this thread and nothing has fixed it.
You are my hero shootmyphoto.com Worked like a charm!!!
Thank you, Tim, this worked perfectly for me!
I'm on a Mac, and simply changing the cache size from 1 to 4, (as previously suggested), was the solution. I re-booted PS and the tool Quick Selection tool began working normally (fast) again.
i have clicked to big & fat , photoshop set cache at 6 and 1024K
after i set the cache to 4
i can't notice any differents between 4 and 6
which is the right value?
what do you use 4 or 6?