I found that the composition with this problem is only the ones that has 3D ray-traced render !! so that is probably why. I guess an update will come to fix this and all the render crash in AE using ray trace
Without knowing any more information about your system and how you're working, it's going to be rather hard for people to help you.
What exact version number of After Effects are you using? 12.2.1? 11.0.4? What do you mean by noise and "less quality"? Screenshots would be helpful here. Do you mean in the final render or just in the Premiere preview?
What errors and crashes are you talking about with the ray-traced renderer?
What are your computer's specs?
The composition has reflections and lights using ray tracing. quality is in 8 antialiasing box mode.
I'm on osx 10.8.5 on a MacPro 2x2.4Ghz Quad core intel xeon 24Gb ram
Nvidia Geforce GTX 680 2Gb Mac edition / / Cuda Driver 5.5.47 // GPU Driver 8.17.76
After effects version CC last update available 188.8.131.52
even if you export from premiere with best quality options you got bad results. So rendering from AE is not the same that using a composition with dynamic links rendered from Premiere.
About the crash thing using ray traced I think is a well known issue. and there are another post discussing about that. Last update didn't fixed.