3 Replies Latest reply on Apr 27, 2014 12:19 PM by Willi Adelberger

    IDML to PDF

    Janine Aniko Level 1

      In exporting a file to IDML, does something change/ gets lost in traslation from the original indesign file? Like missing words, reformatted texts etc? I work with a client who has CS6 (I have 5.5) hence we agreed that every time he updates our files to save it in IDML so I can access them as well. But now he claims that after exporting to PDF (after the IDML), some stuff didn't reflect in the PDFs. Is that possible?

        • 1. Re: IDML to PDF
          Joel Cherney Adobe Community Professional & MVP

          Image previews get lost in all IDML use-cases.

           

          When you open up an IDML generated by CS6 in CS5.5, any feature that is CS6-only will be lost.

           

          The text engine changes from version to version, so you can't rely on the rag to be identical when you round-trip through IDML.

           

          Additionally, I've seen a variety of hard-to-track imperfections in interpretation of IDML, in CS6 specifically.

           

          You need to get a CS6 upgrade license, yesterday. Your workflow is dangerous.

          • 2. Re: IDML to PDF
            Laubender Adobe Community Professional & MVP

            @Janine

             

            What can occur (it occured to me): an applied paragraph style was changed to a different one.

             

            Basing a roundtrip workflow through IDML is really a bad idea…
            Joel is right calling it outright "dangerous".

             

            Ah, just another one, I have to admit, a very obscure one:

             

            Whole tables will be lost, if they exceed 200 columns (not so with CS4).

            It's unlikely you ever will work with those, but… ;-)

             

            Uwe

            • 3. Re: IDML to PDF
              Willi Adelberger Most Valuable Participant

              Dn't do that. IDML is not a workflow to going back and foreward between versions in a workflow.

              You will loose new features, but also bugs are changing the files, like loosing numbers and other unwanted losses.

              Your workflow is really dabngerous. You have to use the very same version and build as your client does.