12 Replies Latest reply: Nov 6, 2014 7:28 PM by Herbert2001 RSS

    What should I buy?

    hannahc

      I am an artist and would like to buy an art program but I'm a little stumped on which one to buy.. Photoshop, CS6, Illustrator?

      Can someone please help me choose which one would be better for drawing on?

      I downloaded the free trail for Photoshop and I like it so far, but I know a few other very good artists who use Photoshop CS6  and unfortunately I probably wont be able to get that so I was wondering which other programs to pick from. Thanks!

        • 1. Re: What should I buy?
          deepakgahlot Community Member

          Hi

           

          if most of the work you do is drawing, I would recommend illustrator and the combination of the illustrator and Photoshop will be better

          • 2. Re: What should I buy?
            rkelly0137 Community Member

            What kind of artist are you?  What kind of art do you like to do?

             

            Photoshop and Illustrator are two completely different programs.  If you're not sure which one fits your needs then I don't think you understand what they do.  I recommend a bit of research.

             

            I'm a huge fan of Photoshop and have used it for many years, but I'm not a traditional artist.  Although Photoshop certainly can do purely rendered art, usually people use some sort of photograph and/or vector art (like what you do in Illustrator), and modify that art, composite it with others, do layout, shading, etc.  If you want to start from a blank canvas and paint or draw then there are better programs out there, many of which are free.  Try a search for 'painting program".  You could use one of the free programs and put the money towards a Wacom tablet - a necessity for any kind of drawing art.  I even find it 'necessary' for Photoshop.

            • 3. Re: What should I buy?
              Peru Bob Community Member

              Download the trial versions of Photopshop, Photoshop Elements, and Illustrator and you will be able to decide for yourself.

              • 4. Re: What should I buy?
                hannahc Community Member

                Sorry about that, I should have said I am a digital artist; I draw things like canines/pets/humans/etc. I have Paint Tool Sai right now but I would really like a better program like Photoshop.

                I did research them all last night and tonight but I need just a basic explanation of what each does, or at least what might be better for me. Like I have the trail version of Photoshop right now and I like it so far but before I start a plan and spending money I would like to make sure its the one I want.

                I haven't heard much of Illustrator..

                I guess my real question is which program would be better for a digital artist to draw from (blank canvas)

                • 5. Re: What should I buy?
                  hannahc Community Member

                  And yeah, I already have a Wacom Bamboo Create and have bought the program Paint Tool Sai

                  • 6. Re: What should I buy?
                    gener7 Community Member

                    Corel Painter might be what you want. Many artists use it with Photoshop.

                     

                    Gene

                    • 7. Re: What should I buy?
                      rkelly0137 Community Member

                      Sounds like you have a good start.   The tablet is a must.  I started with a Bamboo too, served me well for many years.

                       

                      I can't recommend any programs as I don't do digital (traditional) art, but I hear Corel Painter and ArtRage come up a lot.  I looked into it a few months back, just because I didn't understand what was different from what Photoshop (with tablet) can do, and what a painting specific program can do.  The painting programs add a lot of features to replicate actual mediums such as paper texture or paint blending.  If you're using "oil paints" in a painting program and paint with a color over top another color you can blend them in as you would in real life.  Photoshop can paint with opacities, but it'll only blend as much as overlaying two colors in digital RGB space.  It sounds pretty neat, but if you're like me and don't have any formal training in traditional mediums it doesn't really mean much.

                       

                      Photoshop isn't going to give as many painting-specific options as a painting program, but it can do a whole lot of other things that the painting program can't.  Will you use these features?  Who knows, but if you wanted to get into other forms of digital art then you'd probably be adding a Photoshop type program in the future anyway.  Also, if you get serious into digital art work (read: do this professionally) your path is probably going to cross Photoshop at some point in time, so you'll probably want to be at least competent in the basics.

                       

                      Just things to think about.  I can't tell you which is the best option for you.  If you're just looking for something to paint with there are going to be much cheaper options than Photoshop.  If you want to do more than paint, then you'll probably be looking at Photoshop sooner or later. 

                      • 8. Re: What should I buy?
                        Herbert2001 Community Member

                        Also test Krita, which is a digital paint application, and free/open source! Supports full 16/32bit per channel as well. ClipStudio I use for inking and other tasks, because ClipStudio supports full vector strokes as well (which can be scaled to any resolution without losing quality - great for inking).

                        https://krita.org/

                        CLIP STUDIO PAINT | CLIP STUDIO.NET

                         

                        I've replaced Photoshop with Krita and ClipStudio for all of my digital painting and drawing (and a little bit of Photoline). All these apps have a much better feel than PS. Photoshop does not support any stroke smoothing (there is a plugin called Lazy Nezumi, though) - something I find essential in a drawing application. Krita, ClipStudio, Photoline, Gimp - they all support stroke smoothing out of the box. Photoshop does not.

                         

                        Worse, Photoshop's drawing has a couple of serious interpolation issues - this becomes extremely problematic when drawing sharp lines on a zoomed out high-res canvas: Photoshop will then add rough kinks and janks to your lines.

                         

                        This makes Photoshop completely unusable for me (in terms of drawing) - you can check what it looks like on this thread (at the bottom where I posted an example).

                        Brush strokes become jagged after a few seconds

                         

                        I work with the latest Intuos Pro 5 Large Wacom tablet, btw.

                        • 9. Re: What should I buy?
                          nickna12 Community Member

                          Painter 2015 and/or Photoshop.  But both require a good deal of study to get into.  As has been said, many artists use both programs.

                          • 10. Re: What should I buy?
                            hannahc Community Member

                            The only reason I really want Photoshop is for the brushes and different features it has that Paint Tool Sai doesn't. I don't know if I will use Photoshop for the full drawing; just to add effects that I can't add with Sai. I don't think I'll ever use it for pictures or video, since I have Sony Vegas Pro 12 and Adobe Premire Elements 11 (which I haven't figured out how to use yet) so..

                            That's why I wish it wasn't a plan and I could just buy it besides continuing to pay for it when I'm only going to use it every now and then.

                             

                            But anyway thank you everyone for your suggestions! and listening to me ramble

                            • 11. Re: What should I buy?
                              rkelly0137 Community Member

                              You could also get Photoshop Elements, which should have a large amount of the features you want for a fraction of the cost.  It also has a much easier learning curve.  I can't say I've ever really used it, as it's missing many features that I consider critical, but for drawing and some basic editing I'd imagine it'd be ok.  I believe that you can have a single layer in 16 bit, you just can't do multiple layers.  I'd imagine you want 16 bit for drawing to minimize banding.

                              • 12. Re: What should I buy?
                                Herbert2001 Community Member

                                Krita also loads up Photoshop brush *.abr files. As does Photoline, btw.