Try setting it to one of the other boxes and check the preview that will be shown in ID against the PDF in Acrobat. Some PDF print drivers and 3rd-party PDF output does not include all the page boxes.
You have to show the import options to get to the crop options. The one you choose is sticky until the next time you change it, so it looks like you previously imported a PDF or .ai file for which the box was defined.
When you place the file, choose show options. This choice is sticky and if that option isn’t available in the PDF you’re placing you’ll get an error.