Export a PDF and print using the booklet function in Acrobat.
I tried that, but the Booklet function in Acrobat reduces the size of the pages. I haven't figured out a way around that. Thanks for the suggestion, though!
1 person found this helpful
Turns out that the 'Print Blank Pages' box got unchecked, and it threw off my page order. When I checked that again everything went back to normal.
I knew it had to be something silly!
Thanks for your help, everyone!
I found this box checked in the 'print booklet' dialog, but you also need to check it on the 'print settings' dialog.