2 Replies Latest reply on Apr 3, 2017 5:16 PM by HD_Gibbs

    Photo rejected for technical issues

    HD_Gibbs Level 1

      This photo was rejected for technical issues, along with the rest of this sequence of a skier jumping off a cornice onto untracked snow. On the whole, I appreciate the feedback when my photos are rejected, because it helps me to improve. But in this particular case, I find "technical issues" to be somewhat vague and unhelpful.

      I shot this using the exact settings recommended by a pro for ski photography - 1/1600 at f5.6 on a 5D Mark III - not too much room for improvement there, but maybe there was an issue processing the image? Any feedback would be appreciated! Is there a change I can make to have this photo accepted?

      Thanks in advance.

      Japan Feb 2017 (1 of 1)-2.jpg

        • 1. Re: Photo rejected for technical issues
          Szalam Adobe Community Professional & MVP

          What ISO were you using? Because your image is fairly noisy. I mean, I can see the noise even in the inline version. Clicking on it to view it full size really shows the noise. See?


          This section of the sky (from the bottom-right) should be a fairly smooth gradient, but it's all noisy.


          Also, look at the branches specifically. There is a lot of chromatic aberration or something.


          Green and pink around the edges like crazy.


          The snow has lots of contrast, so well done there, but the skier seems under-exposed and yet still noisy.

          Look at him or her at full size, very noisy.


          • 2. Re: Photo rejected for technical issues
            HD_Gibbs Level 1

            Hey Szalam, thanks again - that's really helpful feedback, you're exactly right.


            The image was shot at ISO 200 lol, so that's not the issue; the problem is the way I've processed it in Lightroom. Way too much post! I've just reset the develop settings and the image is sharp. I've learned a lot since I processed this photo, so I'll have another go and resubmit.