4 Replies Latest reply on May 2, 2017 6:28 PM by matthewarthur

    Audio Still Sub-Par


      Hi there,


      I have done some research and have gotten the sound to sound a lot better than the initial settings, but it is still not right! It sounds like it's going through a bitcrusher effect.


      Even though it happens on export as well, when I preview the sound files in Animate, the quality is noticeably worse than when I open the original audio file.


      Any help would be appreciated!



        • 1. Re: Audio Still Sub-Par
          Colin Holgate MVP & Adobe Community Professional

          With ActionScript 3 FLAs scrubbing works a lot better if the sounds you imported are WAV than MP3. Also, if you imported MP3 they won't sound better when exported as Raw. If you're not importing WAV, start doing that (BTW, if you're working on HTML5 Canvas you will want MP3, not WAV).


          If you are already using WAV and are hearing a difference, check your original sounds to see if their levels are correct. Also, use your sound editor to do the conversion to 16 bit 44.1 kHz Stereo, it's likely to do a better job than Animate does. If you're happy with the 16 bit WAVs that you give to Animate, the exported Raw sound should be identical.

          • 2. Re: Audio Still Sub-Par
            matthewarthur Level 1

            Colin, thanks heaps! The issue was I was importing 24-bit .wavs at 48000hz. I used Adobe Media Encoder to encode them to 16 bit wavs with a sample rate of 44.1khz.


            The sound quality is much better now - the audio preview in Animate is perfect. However, there is a slight bit of crackle in the exported .swf. If I can fix this issue, I'll be good to go!

            • 3. Re: Audio Still Sub-Par
              Colin Holgate MVP & Adobe Community Professional

              Your swf settings were correct, are you still using Raw? Are your sounds set to Stream in the timeline?


              As a point of interest, I think that Animate misreads 24 bit as 8 bit, which is why it would be so bad.

              • 4. Re: Audio Still Sub-Par
                matthewarthur Level 1

                Hi Colin, yes, that's all set.


                I found that if I export with MP3 compression at best settings, it actually doesn't have the crackle and sounds great!


                Obviously, this is not as good for the audio mastering process (.wavs are always better), however, it will do the job for my purposes. Thanks for the help!