4 Replies Latest reply on May 10, 2017 8:28 PM by D.A.R

    Exporting to tiff using zip compression

    Jim_Palik Level 1

      I have been exporting to tiff 16 bit whenever I upload to have large prints made. Full frame 20 mb dngs will be in the 100 mb area for the tiff. Do I lose any scalability when I use the tiff zip compression in lightroom? The file size is almost half.

       

      I never enlarge the original file size even though sometimes after cropping many times it is significantly smaller. Is there any reason to increase the image size when exporting to tiff.

       

      Jim

        • 1. Re: Exporting to tiff using zip compression
          cppasm Level 3

          zip compression is lossless, so you will not loose anything.

          All you will loose is application compatibility - not all applications supports zip compressed tiffs.

          It's up to you to decide whether you are using such applications and does it worth it.

          • 2. Re: Exporting to tiff using zip compression
            Jim_Palik Level 1

            Do you see any value to enlarging the file when exporting to tiff.

            • 3. Re: Exporting to tiff using zip compression
              cppasm Level 3

              What do you mean by "enlarging"?

              Increasing resolution? No - I don't see the point to do this if you don't need to.

              Increasing file size? It depends. If you are using apps that don't support compressed tiffs and want to process your images in them then this is the only way to go. Otherwise don't see the point either.

              • 4. Re: Exporting to tiff using zip compression
                D.A.R Adobe Community Professional

                You won't lose any scalability when you use compression. the application that will work with the tiff will unpack the compressed file, scale it up, then packet again. The resulting zip file will of course be larger than the original zip. Any loss of quality will be due to interpolation of scaling.

                 

                Whether you enlarge via Lightroom on export or Photoshop, interpolation will occur. The result of acceptability is subjective and often affected by the content of the image.

                 

                The size you can print is restricted by the amount of pixels you have divided by the print resolution. Many large format printers will work just fine with an image that is 200ppi. Yielding a larger image than if it were 300ppi.

                 

                In addition I would question whether you need to be exporting 16bit files for the print. Technically, yes, it has better quality than an 8bit file but in many real world examples I have yet to find anyone who can tell the difference.

                Discuss with the printer service their requirements and perhaps ask for tests at different resolutions (300/240/200/180) and different bit depth (8/16)