5 Replies Latest reply on Oct 21, 2017 7:22 AM by Bill Gehrke

    AMD Radeon Pro 580 Performance with Adobe?

    libsimpso Level 1

      I'm researching to upgrade an edit system. Going PC is not an option, and I am focused on finding a solid mac platform for HD and 4K editing.

       

      While Apple is getting ready to release an iMac Pro and new Mac Pro later this year, no specs are available. The best stop gap measure I can come up with is to explore purchasing the currently available 27-inch iMac. Sadly, the GPU (Radeon Pro 580) offering is not listed here: Adobe Premiere Pro System Requirements

       

      Does anyone have personal experience with this GPU and Premiere?

       

      Or Adobe can you chime in? Has this GPU undergone any performance testing?

       

      Thanks!


      Lindsay

       

      [Moved from the non-technical LOUNGE Forum to the Hardware forum... Mod]

      [Here is the list of all Adobe forums... https://forums.adobe.com/welcome]

        • 1. Re: AMD Radeon Pro 580 Performance with Adobe?
          aforetaste Level 1

          I'm very curious about this as well. Anyone have any experience?

          • 2. Re: AMD Radeon Pro 580 Performance with Adobe?
            libsimpso Level 1

            Adobe, do you have plans to test this new hardware on the iMac platform? Is there a timeline for such testing?

            • 3. Re: AMD Radeon Pro 580 Performance with Adobe?
              RoninEdits Most Valuable Participant

              adobe staff typically doesn't respond here with detailed info, so i wouldn't expect any help from them. the amd 500 series is based off the same tech as 400 series, which has been working ok for the most part. this youtube video compares the new imac vs older model, and shows the radeon 580 working fine. perhaps more interesting is how far behind premiere is in performance vs the other software. adobe takes a while to copy features from other NLE's and software, so eventually they might implement the same features and catch up some performance ground.

               

              • 4. Re: AMD Radeon Pro 580 Performance with Adobe?
                shaneknightnyc

                I've been working in PP CC 2017 with the new iMac running the Radeon Pro 580 and 40gb RAM and have experienced several disappointing issues. The biggest has come when using LUTs with the Lumetri Color panel while editing HD footage I transcoded to ProRes 422. During both playback and export I get random flashes of pixelation with GPU acceleration enabled. Sadly, when I contacted Adobe about the issue, I was told my only option was to edit using the "software only" option and "try" to use GPU acceleration during export and am literally doing this as I'm typing this up - so I'll try to remember to report back on the issue. Kinda sucks and I'm really disappointed in Adobe for not including the Radeon Pro 580 in their list of "approved" graphics cards as they've had plenty of time to test this and send out an update to everyone. As it stands, I upgraded to the new iMac expecting it to speed up my work flow and w/o being able to use GPU acceleration during export - the weekly TV show I produce still takes over 6 hours to export #sad

                • 5. Re: AMD Radeon Pro 580 Performance with Adobe?
                  Bill Gehrke Adobe Community Professional & MVP

                  I am guessing OpenCL will never be as good at GPU Acceleration as CUDA.  Even the latest AMD/ATi Vega's are no where near as good as the current nVidia GTX 10 series of products.

                   

                  Here are the PPBM test results of the two current GPU's with the new top of the line AMD Threadripper 1950X based system

                  "34","79","27","156", Premiere Version:, 11.1.2.22, Vega Frontier 16GB GPU ($999)

                  "34","52","13","158", Premiere Version:, 11.1.2.22, Asus GeForce GTX 1080 Ti 11GB  ($750)

                   

                  The first number is the disk test result and the 4th number is the CPU intensive test.  The two middle numbers are GPU accelerated tests.  Unfortunately this is a PC-only test.