3 Replies Latest reply on Jul 28, 2017 11:20 AM by Szalam

    Newbie: lack of aesthetic or commercial appeal - help

    sdloeffler Level 1

      Greetings, I'm new to Adobe Stock and quickly becoming frustrated.  I submitted 23 photos and had 1 accepted.  Most were rejected for having a lack of aesthetic or commercial appeal.  Now, I'm no Ansel Adams I'll admit, but my photos aren't that bad.  to make it worse, they tell me my photos have no appeal but there are others on adobe stock that look pretty close to mine.  I some cases I think mine look better, but yet I can't get mine on the site while others can.  Is this just luck of the draw based on who is reviewing and what kind od mood they're in that day?

       

      Here is an example...  the shot below is currently on Adobe Stock:

       

      as.jpeg

       

      here is the photo I uploaded...

       

      DSC_5834-Edit.jpeg

       

      Mine is not appealing...

       

      thoughts?

       

      before someone says there may be too many like this out there.  there were numerous pics, but I saw only this one that was like mine.

       

      Any help is appreciated.

        • 1. Re: Newbie: lack of aesthetic or commercial appeal - help
          Szalam Adobe Community Professional & MVP

          I like the wreath in yours better, but overall your photo is not as pleasantly composed as the one that is there. Yours is a bit too tight to the subject. There's no room around it for anything.

          Speaking of composition and angles, you can see the white/blue building behind the main building (on the right) better in the Stock image as well. In yours it's a distraction because it's just kind of peeking out a bit so there's nothing to resolve what it is in a viewer's mind.

          Also, the water is higher in the Stock image and it looks nicer because of it.

           

          Now, if there were no shots of this already in the Adobe Stock collection, maybe this one would have been accepted. I don't know. But when there are more useful and more pleasing images of the same thing from nearly the same angle with nearly the same lighting...why add an inferior image? I don't work for Adobe so I don't know for sure about their reasoning, but I do know that if it were me and I already had the other one in my collection, I would reject yours too.

          • 2. Re: Newbie: lack of aesthetic or commercial appeal - help
            sdloeffler Level 1

            Appreciate the feedback

            • 3. Re: Newbie: lack of aesthetic or commercial appeal - help
              Szalam Adobe Community Professional & MVP

              Your'e welcome. It's too bad the other photos got there first! You've got a nice photo of what looks to be a beautiful place!