3 Replies Latest reply on Aug 21, 2017 1:48 PM by Joel_Geraci

    Performance(calculation speed) hit in long pdf form

    arvindkumar7 Level 1

      Hello Guys,

      Please get a few mins to read all.

       

      I am creating a pdf version of loan and mortgage calculator originally created in excel. This calculator spans more than 1600 rows across 12 columns and out of which 1560 rows are used only for payment/amortization schedule. This part is actually causing problems. Excel sheet is having multi-level nested(to excel's limit) if else largely and some other simple calculations e.g PMT, MOD.

       

      I have converted all excel formulas in livecycle javascript and are working fine but the pdf form calculation speed is far from that of excel. Even if we use the short term for loan e.g 3 or 4 years it take time while excel sheet is designed to calculated till 1560 total number of payments and takes no time to calculate all data.

       

      I used repeatable subform feature and depending on the total number of payments rows are generated during runtime. I used this to keep document length optimum and escape from calculating unnecessary rows that are not required when loan term is small. But this failed even for small loan terms e.g 3 or 4 years.

       

      I later did acrobat form in which all the 1560 rows with 12 columns created, dynamically set format of 18850 fields, converted javascript from livecycle to acrobat format and applied script under each of 18850 fields. But this also works slow because it calculates all 1560 rows*12 cols each time even if no data is there or not req to calculate. I am planning to put all the script under one field and using document level function and do repeat only required number of times through loop.

       

      But I think I should test adobe writing speed if we forget all calculation for one sec. I find writing a null( "" ) into 18850 fields adobe took apx 1 min with no calculation done. While excel does this in 0.5 sec or less.

       

      This means that even if an efficient code is written it would still work slow for longer loan terms.

       

      Please advise what can be done or to what application or file format I should switch to.

      Thanks for reading all.

      Arvind

        • 1. Re: Performance(calculation speed) hit in long pdf form
          Joel_Geraci Adobe Community Professional

          Keep using Excel or move to Use Google Sheets. These are applications that were specifically designed to handle that number of calculations quickly.

           

          With 18,850 fields, you're asking way too much of Acrobat and PDF. You might get better performance if you don't have any calculated fields at all and use a dialog to collect the inputs, run the calculations, set the delay property to true, populate the fields with their values, then set it to false again but honestly, I still don't think you'll find the performance anywhere near that of Excel.

           

          As background, the delay property set to true will stop Acrobat from generating field appearances every time a field changes value. Setting it to false will allow all fields to update after they have their new values set.

           

          J-

          • 2. Re: Performance(calculation speed) hit in long pdf form
            arvindkumar7 Level 1

            Hi Joel,

             

            Thanks for replying. I agree with you and already my next step was to try Google sheets but read somewhere that it may take some time to refresh data from server to local browser depending on Internet connection speed.

             

            Also I read in a adobe forum post that adobe reader or acrobat cannot use all cores of processor and adobe's cpu usage remains low all the time.

            • 3. Re: Performance(calculation speed) hit in long pdf form
              Joel_Geraci Adobe Community Professional

              I understand your frustration but here's the thing... other than a piece of dedicated client side spreadsheet software, you're just not going to find anything that is optimized to perform like... a piece of dedicated client side spreadsheet software.

               

              It's time to reset your expectations.