4 Replies Latest reply on Mar 1, 2010 9:09 AM by Artistes

    Flash color shifting nightmare

    mixmasterdsr04 Level 1
      I'm bringing in production art into Flash, and it's shifting - getting lighter. I've read all about the issue, how it's photoshop's color profiles, etc. Problem is, converting the images to working RGB isn't helping. I've tried converting them (originally they were in Adobe 1998 RGB) , creating a new document with the correct profile, but nothing works. I'm saving them out as PNG files. They look great in a browser even. Just washed out in Flash. Anything else I can try? At the end of my rope here.
      Thanks
        • 1. Re: Flash color shifting nightmare
          derobinson Level 1
          Don't really have an answer with relation to Flash for you, but considering the wide range of combinations in monitors/video cards/operating systems/personal settings in the world, you will be hard pressed to reproduce the exact color that you see on your own screen no matter what you do. That's just kind of par for the course. Instead, find something that looks best on the most screens you can test on. It won't be perfect, but its the best you'll get.

          Good luck!
          • 2. Re: Flash color shifting nightmare
            Pete_Hughes Level 1
            Generally that is not a problem when coming in with 24 bit sRGB but there have been a couple of recent reports involving Macintoshes. You might search old posts and contact those involved if possible to see if they found a resolution. I don't see it in tech support anywhere.
            • 3. Re: Flash color shifting nightmare
              innov8ivdesign
              Was nearly at the end of my rope as well. This was a tough one for me, and all the discussion-board answers were annoying (things like "You can't know what color setting your users will have"). Well guess what—I know what setting I have!
              But here is what works . . . instead of using Photoshop's "Save for Web" feature, just do the old "Save As" and select PNG as the format. I did it both ways, using Photoshop's eyedropper both files showed identical color. However, when they are imported into the Flash library, then placed into a Flash layer, then Flash-eyedropped, the colors are different. Very strange, but true.
              • 4. Re: Flash color shifting nightmare
                Artistes

                Very simple solution.  Convert the PSD image to 32 bits/channel (under image/mode) and then save.  When you import to flash it's good as new.

                 

                To work on the image again (do anything with filters or selections, you have to convert back to 16 or below, but then just save as 32 when you're ready to import to Flash.

                 

                Not sure why they can't remedy this.  I think it's a leftover Macromedia/Adobe glitch.

                 

                Erika