6 Replies Latest reply: Mar 23, 2009 11:38 AM by Ramón G Castañeda RSS

    Camera Raw update has changed things....

      I have Canon 40D and I have the DNG converter 4.2, which is recommended for this camera. I also have the Camera Raw plugin version 3.7, which is recommended for CS2. When I would convert an image from to DNG and open it in CS2 as a Camera Raw image, the window would come up and each line under the 'Adjust' tab (starting with exposure) had an individual auto setting that the image was adjusted to. I found this to be very useful because I could just uncheck the bos to see where the original setting was and make much faster adjustments.

      Then, a few days ago I get a message that there is an update available and so I run the update and now the settings are different. There is now just the default or auto and when you select auto it changes everything, it is no longer line by line.

      Additionally, this update to the Camera Raw is now changed the color of all my photos. When I open the photos in my Canon software they are full of color, but once I convert them to DNG and open them as Camera Raw in CS2 they lose a lot of color. This was not happening prior to this update.

      Is this an issue with the DNG converter or an issue with CS2? I have everything Adobe recommends so I don't know why the color would be desaturated so much. The photos look like crap now. This was not an issue before.

      I'm wondering if I can go back and take the Camera Raw file I downloaded and replace the updated one. Does anyone recommend this approach? If so, how would I go about this to do it correctly?

      Thanks!

      Tyler
        • 1. Re: Camera Raw update has changed things....
          Ramón G Castañeda Community Member
          >have the DNG converter 4.2, which is recommended for this camera.

          Wrong! You should always run the latest version of the DNG Converter, that means 5.3.

          All versions support any and all versions supported in earlier versions.
          • 2. Re: Camera Raw update has changed things....
            Community Member
            Thank you! I just went with the one that was recommended for 'my' camera. Hopefully this fixes the issue. Thanks!
            • 3. Re: Camera Raw update has changed things....
              JimHess-8IPblY Community Member
              No, you still don't understand. DNG converter 4.2 might have been the first version that supported your camera. But that doesn't mean that it is the "recommended" version that you should use. The DNG converter is an evolving program, and you should always try to have the latest version. There are constant little changes made to the converter that might be beneficial to you.

              I don't understand why you got a message that there was an update. ACR 3.7 was the last version released that was compatible with Photoshop CS2. And there haven't been any updates since, nor will there ever be.
              • 4. Re: Camera Raw update has changed things....
                Community Member
                Actually, I do understand about the DNG converter now. It's an evolving program, I get that.

                As for the update, I don't know either. I thought it was weird because I know anything after 3.7 is not for CS2. I had a window pop up and tell me there were updates from adobe and it was all legit. It was connected to Adobe. I had run a 'repair' of CS2 and so maybe that replaced some current files with the ones in the original software, but I don't know. When I go into my Adobe folders the camera raw file is the one it should be.

                I have downloaded the 5.3 and I will convert some RAW images and compare them to see if that corrected the issue. For me, I shoot Real Estate photography so correct color is a big deal to these people. The most noticable place I see color loss is in wood, wood cabinets in a kitchen for example. In stead of rich dark wood it lacks color. This doesn't do well when you are tying to capture a $80k kitchen full of custom wood cabinets. I have also taken the exact same shot in jpeg and it comes out perfectly. So, I know it's somewhere between the DNG converter and opening the image in Camera Raw that the color get's lost. I realize that most of the people on here have forgotten more than I know about how this software works. I try to get the shot I want on site and therefore I have not relied on software much over the years. But, I'm trying to learn how to use this stuff and I appreciate your help while I learn it.

                Thanks again!

                Tyler

                I really appreciate your responses!
                • 5. Re: Camera Raw update has changed things....
                  Panoholic Community Member
                  > this update to the Camera Raw is now changed the color of all my photos

                  You probably have DNG files converted prior this upgrade. How do they show up in the upgraded ACR?
                  • 6. Re: Camera Raw update has changed things....
                    Ramón G Castañeda Community Member
                    The Adobe Update Manager (AUM) is like that, it may show you that there is an update available when you already have that same update installed, or it may fail to alert you that there is an update you don't have, or it will fail during the update. I haven't relied on it or used it for years.