Im having the same problem....
Did you ever get a dialogue box asking what you wanted the page to look like from available templates? Once you select something, the new page is created.
My problem is that when i click on the option create a new page nothig comes up... I've tried this with all the sites i have connection to
Can you try the following steps?
- Remove your website connection.
- Quit Contribute.
- Launch Contribute.
- Re-connect to your website.
Now click New Page button, and check whether you see the options to create Blank Page, Starter web pages.....
If you still experience issues, try clearing Contribute's preferences.
Hope this helps.