The formats you've tried may have been the culprit.
Where, specifically, is your input coming from? Is it a still, a screan cap, a video?
And what, specifically, is your final delivery format? Tape, DVD, web, computer playback, all of the above?
I have tried with a still image, and with a screen capture. The still was a png I believe, and the screen caps have been like 4 or 5 formats. mov with h.264, jpeg 2000, avi uncompressed... i think also I tried ms video 1 and yuv. My final delivery formay will be web. I would like it to be a quicktime video in HD, I was thinking h.264, file size is not an issue, doesn't need to stream really. Problem is that I've tried all the previously mentioned formats for output and then some others too. I've even tried image sequences and they too are faded. If it helps at all, in the preview window in premiere the video has its whites, and also in the preview window in adobe media encoder cs4. The only point where it looks wrong is in the output video.
Things are still a bit too scattered. What I'm looking for at this point is not so much what you have tried, but what you're trying to do. For example "I need to create a software tutorial for the web", or "I want to edit some of my video game play and upload it to the web". Let's start with just that basic data, and go from there.
Ok, well honestly I would like to use this program for more than this project, so lets just say "I would like to edit a video and have the colors remain correct when I export video". Thats all I want. In this particular project, I'm editing clips composed of a few 3d animations and screen captures to create a tutorial video for a website. Later I'm hoping to use to to edit video from my DV cam. Simple editing, clips and transitions.
I just tried 2 more fomats, "animation" and "graphics" Both exaclty the same color fade.
I'm really convinced its a setting within Premiere or Media Encoder. Does anyone know if there are settings or filters within those programs that would cause this?
What program are you using for the 3D animations? For the screen caps?
One more question, and then I'm sure someone will start giving some answers: where and how are you judging the results of your Export, DVD RW on TV, on the computer monitor with a software DVD player, or in a player for the non-DVD files (which one(s)?
I have use camtasia and camstudio AND screentoaster for my input screen cap videos, although I think the format is the crucial piece of information, they are all (with the exception of screen toaster) using the codecs installed on my pc. The 3d renderings I'm not sure because I didnt create them, but the format of the 3d renderings is quicktime mov h.264.
I'm judging the output from my video players on my pc. i have windows media, quicktime player, and vlc. they all display the same. I don't need to put it on a tv because I'm not judging by my eyes, I'm comparing input and output video side by side. You can see the difference in the above snapshot I posted. In fact, I'll give you the html color difference between the original white and the output "white".
Original white is #ffffff and output white is #ededed.
I really strongly believe the problem has something to do with Premiere. I can use virtualDub to edit video and output in the same formats and NOT get that greying effect. Same codecs are being used.
For the Camtasia files, the TechSmith CODEC's are likely used. Do not know about the open source Camstudio, or ScreenToaster though.
Some folk have had issues with the TechSmith CODEC's in PrPro. Not sure exactly what they were.
My *guess* would be that PrPro is not working correctly with the CODEC's used. Players are nearly always much more lenient, that are NLE's. That VirtualDub does a nice job, might indicate that it DOES like the TechSmith (and other) CODEC's, better than PrPro.
I think that you've given folk enough to get started on. Hope that the answers start to flow in.
BTW - one more question: do you see this difference, when playing back your Timeline, or is it just after Export? You may have already answered that one earlier on, and if so - sorry.
IIRC there is a problem with Quicktime with the 'greying' effect. Try another export format, not Quicktime and see if you can replicate it.
Thanks for your help.
No I only see the change in the output files. Everything looks good in the premiere preview window AND the little thumbnail in media encoder while its encoding.
Also, I haven't been importing camtasia's TechSmith CODEC, I export it to something more commong first. ie, all those formats I listed before....
although I think the format is the crucial piece of information
I'm going to have to agree with you on this one. Others have had issues using that software, primarilly because it does not record to any camera standard formats, which is what Premiere seems to like best.
The solution likely lies in your media and methods. (You may have to change one, or both.) I just don't work with that kind of media, however, so I will have to defer to others who may have had success in getting it working.
is there some sort of screen profile that filters in between encoder input and output stages? I have a compaq laptop.
HEY! Good news! I tried AVI, with NO comression at all, not uncompressed YUV, but "none" on the compression list, and the colors stayed correct!
It just looks awful and its 70mb for 2 seconds of video.
An alternative might be Microsoft DV, which will save quite some space with hardly any discernable deterioration in quality.
Good that you found at least one way to resolve this. Quicktime again...
Glad that you got it sorted and have some decent output. Thanks for reporting, and hope that the rest goes smoothly.
Last week I had to prepare final Avid50 masters of 2 documentaries airing on my local PBS station. ALL of the Quicktime files rendered out of Adobe Media Encoder (thru Premiere Pro CS4) were not acceptable (horrible contrast alterations, resulting in DULL washed-out dynamic ranges: all the blacks were now dark grey, pure whites were gone). Absolutely horrible. I spent two full days experimentating with this crap, to no avail. If you render out any Quicktime format in Premiere CS4, the contrast ratios are altered...
Here was my solution. I rendered out my masters to AVI uncompressed in Premiere, then brought them into After Effects (CS4), and rendered that out to Quicktime Avid50 (and as a test, to Animation codec also). Absolutely perfect files-- no changing of anything. Perfect renders.
Lesson here. Quicktime is broken in Premiere CS4 and Media Encoder. Useless crap. But at least for now there is a workaround. This better be fixed in the upcoming update.
Jon R. Hand
Note: I shoot in HDV, and resize down in CS4 (with high quality turned ON). Renders take forever, but the output quality is so superior to CS3, that I would love to go back and redo ALL of my work in CS3. So here Adobe got it right and hit the high mark. If you're downscaling in CS3, you're wasting your time. CS4 downscaling is incredible, like night and day... It's embarrasing now to view my CS3 masters.
Quicktime is...Useless crap.