Great news! Thanks for reporting your success.
As an aside, you are about the 3rd Dell customer in the last 2 - 3 mos., who had issues with their Dell FW cards, on a couple of fora. Not sure if it's a Win7 driver issue (been mentioned in several other threads), or something else. Did your FW card come with drivers? Just curious.
Just the e card and a cable
Hey Rob. Good news! I gues I just lucked out when I picked up the Startech card on my first attempt. It worked without a hitch. Not only can I capture video (which was my primary goal), I've since learned that the camera is also recognized as a webcam so I can use it to record directly with programs like Adove Visual Communicator and get a much better quality image than I would get with a webcam (and have more creative controls at my fingertips).
The case with Dell is another case of a firewire port just integrated into another card to add additional functionality. They place it on the motherboard and it just does not work the way it should.
Enjoy your video camera now and capture away. It's so funny when I first tested it and it worked. I didn't believe it. I kept expecting it to screw up but it never has.
Thanks for reporting. I was just not sure about drivers, especially in light of some Win7 issues.
Here are snippets from a full page Dell Advertisement I found on the back of a Video editing magazine.
"If you can imagine it, you can create it". Set your imagination free - and bring your most amazing ideas to life -- with Dell Precision workstations."
"In the studio and now on the road, you have the power to keep up with your ideas and stay on top of your schedule."
" * Speed your way through the most complex tasks with powerful multi-core processors."
"* Collaborate, multitask, render and more -- with a system ISV-certified to run 90 applications including Autodesk Maya 2010, 3dMax and Adobe CS5" (My bold)
"* Keep your software and hardware working seamlessly with optional Dell ProSupport -- your single point of contact to over 75 software vendors -- for fast, efficient problem resolution."
And here's a link that the advertisement says to click on to "Learn More" http://www.dell.com/content/products/category.aspx/workstations?c=us&cs=04&l=en&s=bsd&~ck= mn&~tab=2&CID=28189&LID=1406433
On the above page it repeats the bullet points from the print ad:
Collaborate, multitask, render and more – with a system ISV-certified to run 90 applications including Autodesk® Maya® 2011, Autodesk® 3ds Max® and Adobe® CS5.
And on the above page here's the "Event Videographer Offer" -- specifically the Dell Precision T3500.
Here are some of the the specs:
Price after "Instant Savings" $789.00
Dual Core Intel® Xeon® W3503 2.40GHz, 4M L3, 4.8GT/s
1GB, 1333MHz, DDR3 SDRAM, NECC (1 DIMM) (no that's not a typo)
1 - 250GB SATA 3.0Gb/s with NCQ and 8MB DataBurst Cache™ (that's right ONE 250GB hard drive)
And look at this Mobile Event Videographer laptop Offer for $2,819.00 (after "Instant Savings"
Personally I think Adobe should prevent companies from using its brand named software in advertisements that offer such seriously underpowered computers for its CS5 systems. Is this bait and switch?
And BTW look at this page from Dell that explains what ISV stands for: http://www.dell.com/content/topics/global.aspx/solutions/en/isv_certifications?c=us&l=en&c s=04
"Dell seeks input from our software partners when we design our professional workstations because no one knows more about what you need to do your job well than the people who developed your applications. To help complement that partnership our platforms are tested by software companies until they earn the title 'certified'.
"The term 'certified', an industry standard label, is granted by workstation software companies to hardware partners meeting their specific standards. Application vendors run tests to insure the hardware platform and its individual components work without error. By eliminating the issue of incompatibility, both software and hardware vendors help reduce troubleshooting and resolution time and can get their customers back to business quickly. At Dell, workstation certification also means that Dell engineers work side by side with application vendors to optimize configurations and find the right balance between performance and peace of mind. The result is a workstation that comes standard with confidence."
Adobe are you reading this link? Adobe, did you test the $789.00 Dell Precision T3500 offered on this page to work with CS5 and more specifically Adobe Premiere CS5?
Yeah, I think that we're now on that "thin ice" of "minimum system requirements." I know that I have beaten and beaten on that dead horse, but he's such an easy target...
From my perspective, I tend to think that those "minimums" are just for installation, and maybe launch, if one is lucky. To actually use the software, much more horsepower is required, even for SD footage, but that's just how I see it.
Thanks for posting and for the links. I wonder if Adobe (our fortunate presence here) can comment. It is not likely, as it is the realm of marketing, but I'd be interested in reading some other perspectives too.
>Why can't Dell just admit this
In other places I have read about several lawsuits filed against Dell because they were using faulty motherboard components... and continued using faulty components long after they knew about the problem
Even the legal practice representing Dell in court was hit by the bad motherboard problem (I had to laugh at that one!)
The comment says "ISV-certified."
I don't know who ISV is, but I bet the first word is "Independent."
Please note that the article does not mention that Adobe directly made any kind of certification at all. This is classic advertising spin. Even here in this forum, we all read "certified" without noticing the "ISV" qualification. (edit: I just re-read that post, and I see that you did notice)
I cannot go any further. I think you all get the idea.
(mas edit: you will also notice that it doesn't say "Premiere." CS5 has a lot of components, as we all know. I also did not see direct mention of video editing. Maybe someone will verify that for me.)
ISV stands for Independent Software Vendor, and the certification software vendors provide assures consumers that the programs a workstation has been certified for will run effectively on those machines. Components, especially graphics cards, can similarly be certified by ISVs, though not all grant certification to components.
after reading this, ISV might mean
Isn't Securely Vetted.
The link to that ad was on the back cover of a full page ad by Dell for the Videomaker Magazine. So its target audience was videographers.
I realize there is not a whole lot that you can do but Adobe really needs to protect its trademarked products - especially because of the no longer "casual" but very serious hardware requirements of Adobe Premiere. Adobe must consider its customers first -- before the advertising hype of its hardware partenrs, such as Dell.
All the trouble that you are having is caused by the Windows 7 firewire driver. I have 3 computers here with firewire and none of them were working with firewire devices in Win 7. The problem is that Microsoft developed a new base driver for firewire in Win 7. This driver does not work for just about everyone. However, there is a fix. Just replace the default driver with the "legacy ieee driver. Go to device manager, IEEE 1394 Bus Host Controllers, and expland that. Right click on whatever shows under that when expanded (this computer says "Texas Insturments 1394 OHCI Compliant Host Controller". My other computers say something else).Click on properties, click on driver tab. Click on update driver. Click on "browse my computer for driver software. Click on "let me pick from a list of device driver on my computer. Click on the driver that has the word "legacy" in parens. Click next. The legacy driver will be installed. You don't even have to reboot.
Apparently, the new driver supplied with Win 7 works with NOTHING or almost so. All 3 of my computer have different firewire controllers and none would work with the original driver. All now work with the legacy driver. Microsoft is real proud of the new driver. There is a pretty large article on the Microsoft tech site about the new driver and all the things that they added. They forgot to make it work for just about everyone.
By the way, I first discovered this problem in my HP laptop. I called HP support and they were of absolutley no help. They were not aware of the driver issue. I image that Dell is clueless about the driver problem as well. Too bad Microsoft is not aware of this problem. I found the solution by typing into Google search "windows 7 firewire problems" and looking at the search results. We are not the only ones that have the problem. What a shame.
After you change the driver, all of your firewire controllers should work Ok.
Jim; these are wonderfully detailed instructions.
They were very easy to follow.
I did all this, and it did not help the Dell firewire port.
It still does not work properly, although it did start working occasionally.
It did not hurt my new firewire port, so I left the legacy driver installed.
Thanks for the good work.
Well, it did capture video,
but I can not export to tape.
Dell offered to send out 2 more hard drives!!!
I asked for my money back.
After 12 months with a bum computer, they agreed.
8/20/2010 I sent it back.
Nearly a year to the day I bought it.
I hope to get a check in a couple of weeks.
Anyone brave enough to recommend a good fast Windows 7, 64 bit computer for me to try.
Anyone brave enough to recommend a good fast Windows 7, 64 bit computer for me to try.
I'm not, but there are many who are.
Start with Harm's overview:
Then go to the top of the hardware forum that it is in, and read several.
A reseller may be your best option.
I am just not brave enough to do this.
I wasted a whole year of my life (in precious spare time) on that $%&(*
Too scared to launch out in to the deep.
I'm like a guy that loves driving cars, but doesn't know how to change the
I just want to drive a computer ... work the software.
These references were interesting, but I'm too old and stupid to build one.
Then use a custom builder; I suspect prices are not that much over. I think Harm does this, and the guys from ADK often post here.
I did not know about this service.
I've seen issues with the Texas Istruments 13394 chipset before. I solved it by adding an internal or external OHCI complient card. Only a few new laptops have PCIe card slots. Has anyone tried the HP Laptops with a Firewire adapter? I would like to find a USB 3. to 1394 addapter if I update my laptop but after searching everywher in the US, not found one. There is a company in Tiawan making one but no supliers in the US carry it. I've seen USB 2.0 addapter but could not tell you if they would solve your problem.
I fixed an issue that affects CS5.5.2 users that capture video through Firewire IEEE1394. When attempting to capture the default drivers allowed machine control of a DV deck and camera. However, the video passing though the cable was delivered in slow motion and stuttering. This is an issue with Windows 7 IEEE 1394 drivers.
The solution is: Change to the 1394 Legacy driver
Go to; control panel/device manager/IEEE 1394 Bus host controllers
Right click; 1394 OHCI Comliant Host Controller
Right click; Properties
Selec;t the driver tab
Select; Update Driver
Select; Browse my computer for the driver software
DO NOT select Browse C:\Windows\System32\drivers
Select; Let me pick from a list of device driver on my computer
Select; 1394 OHCI Compliant Host Controller (Legacy)
Driver will install
This driver works, the default driver did not.
This is not a problem with the Adobe software.
It is a Windows 7 issue.