9 Replies Latest reply on Mar 12, 2010 2:59 PM by Koscieliska

    Best computer to edit PrE8

    Koscieliska Level 1

      I am considering to buy a new computer, which will be mostly (but not only) dedicated to editing HD videos in PrE8 (and probably in the future in Premiere Pro). Could someone kindly suggest a couple of PCs available on the market which could do this job well? I am prepared to spend up to say $US5,000.

       

      Andrew

        • 1. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
          Steve Grisetti Adobe Community Professional

          You shouldn't need to spend nearly that much!

           

          Here are Chuck's suggestions, from the Muvipix forum. He offers a couple of levels of options.

           

          I personally recommend you stay with HP or Dell, both of which offer well-tested machines assembled from top of the line parts.

           

          Both companies have a line of discounted, refurbished products on their sites, which offer excellent values.

           

          About the biggest challenge will be deciding whether to go with Windows 7 32-bit (which performs nearly flawlessly with Premiere Elements 8) or Windows 7 64-bit (which seems to have its share of driver-related problems with the software). But, for a long-term investment -- particularly if you plan to eventually move to Pro software -- it's 64-bit hands-down.

           

          In fact, why not pick up a top of the line machine for under $1200 and use the rest of your budget to buy the CS4 Production Suite?

          1 person found this helpful
          • 2. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
            Koscieliska Level 1

            Thanks Steve. By the way I just got your book on PrE8.

            Very useful and practical!

            • 3. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
              the_wine_snob Level 9

              Andrew,

               

              When you mention "HD" material, is this AVCHD footage? The reason that I ask is that AVCHD takes more CPU horsepower, than will other HD formats.

               

              With AVCHD, it seems that a fast Quad-core CPU is about the minimum, and an i7 is very useful.

               

              With most other formats, the I/O sub-system, i.e. your HDD's will make a bigger difference. For NLE work, I recommend a 3x SATA II HDD setup, with the fastest disk as your System/C:\. This disk does not have to be that large, and 350 - 500GB should be large enough. The two extra HDD's should be 7200RPM min, and I'd go with two of these in the 1TB range.

               

              The allocation would look like this:

              C:\ OS, programs and probably the Page File

              D:\ Projects and their Scratch Disks

              E:\ Media files

               

              The RAM is important too, and for a 32-bit OS, I would look at a full 4GB. With a 64-bit OS, then I'd go with 12GB.

               

              The video card is less important, for NLE and image editing. Any of the latest ATI, or nVidia cards will work well. You can get good results with 512 MB, and will likely see little benefit from a 1GB card, at least not from your NLE or Photoshop. The price difference is minimal, so I'd probably go with the 1GB card, especially if one does anything in 3D.

               

              Get the biggest, best power supply possible, as NLE work, especially Rendering and Export, can put a load on the PWS, plus you'll have the 3 HDD's, and maybe a 1GB vid-card.

               

              Then, add as many fans as the case will take. Heat build-up is a common cause of failed Exports and Transcodes.

               

              If possible, I'd go with two burners, maybe a BD-capable multi-drive and then a DVD multi-drive. Having 2 burners can really benefit if one commonly delivers multiple discs of a Project. If you will be doing a lot of BD, then maybe go with 2 BD burners. I mix brands here, as some will read different discs better than others. My workstation has 1 Plextor and 1 LG, and I have found that some disc just play better in one, than the other. Neither is 100% with all discs, and both work well with most. If I had to lean to one of mine, it would be the LG, but it has been nice having the Plextor, as it has handled some discs, that the LG balked on - and vice versa.

               

              Good luck,

               

              Hunt

              • 4. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
                Koscieliska Level 1

                Yes, I am talking about AVCHD. Many thanks for your comments.

                 

                Andrew

                • 5. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
                  the_wine_snob Level 9

                  Andrew,

                   

                  With AVCHD, the CPU will be the most important single component, with the I/O taking backseat. Go with the fastest, multi-core/multi-thread processor, as you can. Still, the 3x HDD setup will benefit you.

                   

                  Regardless of the CPU and I/O, I'd still fill up the RAM slots for 32-bit OS and look at about 12GB for a 64-bit OS.

                   

                  Good luck and enjoy the new machine.

                   

                  Hunt

                  • 6. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
                    Steve Grisetti Adobe Community Professional

                    And thank you so much for supporting the book, Andrew!

                     

                    • 7. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
                      John T Smith Adobe Community Professional & MVP

                      Go here http://forums.adobe.com/community/premiere/hardware_forum

                       

                      Read "new computer" messages going back 3-4 months (actual message titles may vary... read more rather than less)

                       

                      For AVCHD you need an Intel i7 (overclocking is your desision... I do not)

                       

                      If you plan to use Premiere Pro, be aware that CS5 will be 64bit only, so you will want Win7 PRO 64bit and 12Gig of ram

                       

                      But, as I said, go to the hardware forum and read... and read some more!

                      • 8. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
                        the_wine_snob Level 9

                        And in your reading, per John T's suggestion, pay special attention to the comments from Harm Millaard.

                         

                        Happy reading,

                         

                        Hunt

                        • 9. Re: Best computer to edit PrE8
                          Koscieliska Level 1

                          Thanks Bill. Will do.

                           

                          Andrew