As much as I have appreciated all the posts that have already been written on the subject, I have not been able to get Flash Player to work since upgrading to Firefox 3.6.8 over the weekend.
Here is what happens:
When I get to a site that needs Flash to display (i.e., the Parade magazine page for the Numbrix puzzle), Firefox displays the "additional plug-ins are necessary ..." dialog bar at the top of the screen.
Clicked on the "Install Plug-Ins" button, got the Adobe dialogue box, checked the "agree to terms and conditions" and clicked on "Install".
I get a pretty moving bar and Adobe says it is installed ... nope, not working.
Checked "plug-ins" on the Firefox "add-ons" menu, and no Flash Player listed.
Came here, read all the helpful advice.
Downloaded the uninstaller and the manual installer and ran both (yes, I closed Firefox first).
No Flash Player working, no mention in the "add-ons" menu.
Windows Control Panel says it is there, but Firefox doesn't seem to know that.
Is this some weird compatibility issue between the newest Firefox and the newest Flash Reader? If so, someone had better blink and correct it.
32Questioner: Don't spread rubbish on other peoples' threads. What an absurd statement to make.
If you have Win7 or XP, IE and or FF and Flash Player is not working, then it is YOUR system that has a problem and you should start your own thread.
Flash Player works just fine on all you have mentioned.
Not having seen any suggestions in the past week, I have tried a couple of other things I thought of.
1. I tried uninstalling Flash Player 10, removing the Flash folder under \Windows\system32\Macromed and reinstalling. Same error prompt from Firefox.
2. I upgraded to the next version of Firefox. New version still doesn't see Flash Player 10 as having been installed.
3. Uninstalled Flash Player 10 and reinstalled Flash Player 8. Firefox recognizes that Flash is installed (no more prompt to download) and it works on most of the sites I visit that have Flash content. However, there are a few whose Flash content apparently requires a newer version than 8 so this is not a 100% workable solution.
4. Installed Flash Player 9 over 8. Firefox error returns, uninstalling 9 required a reinstall of 8 to make Firefox happy.
My conclusion is that there is something about the way Flash Player 9 and higher interfaces with Firefox that changed from Flash Player 8 and that interface conflicts with something in Firefox on my system. Since this does not appear to be a universal problem, I will have to look at the Firefox add-ons and other plugins and see if one of those is the conflict.
Any further advice would, of course, be welcomed.
Hi K M, In your Post#10 if I had seen it would have told you to right click on that flash6.ocx and the uninstFl.exe and Delete them. The first was a very old IE file that never was removed and the other one most likely also.
However, now that you have moved on, what I would like to see is your Flash folder files. If you would like to post them, we'll be able to see what is now Installed and go from there.
Also in FF, take a look at your plugins and see if you have the SWF, any version or if there is more than one SWF there.
There is no Flash folder at present. I went back to Flash Player 8 which installed itself without needing that folder (it is in C:/Program Files/Mozilla Firefox/plugins).
The Flash plugins in the Firefox folder seem to be the right ones for FP8: NPSWF32.dll (1.298MB), GetFlash.exe (126KB), and GetFlash.exe.manifest (1KB). All are dated 03/21/2008 which also matched FP8.
There are no other instances of Flash Player, either in the folder or when I check plug-ins under Firefox>Help>Add-ons>Plugins. FP8 is showing up as "Shockwave Flash 184.108.40.206" which to my recollection is correct as well.
Hi, So your FF vs 3.6.8 or 3.6.9 works with that old of a Flash Player version? Just keep in mind that with almost every Flash Player version since then have included Security updates as well. Old versions of anything on a computer is what the bad guys look for.
Your original problem when you Installed Flash Player 10.1 was not Flash Player, nor was it Firefox not working. You had 2 old Flash files that were for Internet Explorer. That was the conflict.
As long as you are aware of the risks by having that old of a version of Flash Player on your system, that is fine.
I just think since I'm aware of this, to just advise you.
Hi, I have read all of your posts. I think there were several things going on from the beginning. Not due to anything you did, but some of it is the way a website advises a user that they need a "plug-in" or to "update Flash Player" when they already have. First there is confusion as to what is a plug-in? Well Adobe say Flash Player is a browser plugin and that is true. There is also for Firefox and other non-IE browsers a plugin and that is the SWF plugin. When Flash Player is Installed, that SWF plugin is also Installed into the browser. However, many times it doesn't get Enabled and therefore Flash Player does not work. The website detects that Flash Player is not working and that is true. They don't know that you have already Installed Flash Player, and you or a user may not know that the SWF is not Enabled. So you or the user think you need to Uninstall and Install again and so the cycle starts over. To me and others, I think of a plugin as something added to the browser as Java or Quicktime or any other plugin. I don't think of Flash Player as a plugin, no more that I think of Java as a plugin or Quicktime. They Install plugins for Firefox & the non-IE browsers, but in IE they Install ActiveX Controls. But each are more than a plugin.
Hope I'm not boring you, but the above is confusing. I think this is what happened in your situation. Your SWF may not have been Enabled. And I think after you removed the Flash file and then Installed again, the same thing happened.
It happens with the ActiveX Control for IE, it just didn't get Enabled and that is all that is needed, as the Flash files are already Installed, but for FP to work, that Control must be Enabled. That had happened to me over a year ago and that is why I am helping on the Flash Forum:-)
Hope this helps explain what I see as confusion in the way terms are used and what may have happened in your situation.
I have not been responding to website prompts about the missing plug-in. It is Firefox which has been prompting me, with its "Additional plug-ins are required to display all of the content on this page" drop-down. And I have been using Firefox's "install missing plug-ins" button.
Wouldn't you think that a Firefox-prompted plug-in download would properly activate? I know that's what I had expected, but for whatever reason it does not appear to be the case.
Hi K M, Well then if it was Firefox asking or telling you that you needed a plugin, then it still could have been that SWF that wasn't enabled. Here is how I look at this: I think the websites are looking for that browser SWF to be enabled. Clearly they are not looking at the Flash files that 9 times out of 10 are already Installed. If they were they would see them, right? No, they are detecting that SWF plugin or the ActiveX Control and not "detecting" it since it is not Enabled, they are saying the user has a missing "plugin". Users that use IE, most of the time they are told to update their Flash Player, when again the website is not detecting that ActiveX Control since it is disabled.
Since neither one of us can ask Mozilla Firefox or Microsoft, we can just keep our opinions:-) Maybe someone with more Tech experience will come along that can say.
I don't know how long you have used FF, but ever since vs 3.6.4, 3.6.6, 3.6.7 and 3.6.8 there have been problems with those versions of FF and Flash Player 10.0 and now the 10.1. I know what some have been. Now that FF vs 3.6.9 is out I am hoping that will resolve some of the issues. Have not had time to check what this latest versions is about tho.
By the way, and I hate to ask, but do you have SWF vs 10.1.82.76 in the plugins and is it Enabled? LOL
And do you have the correct FP files for FF in the folder? If so, can you not see the animation at that test site? I know that the FF site uses that DLM(download manager). Check in your add ons, plugins and extensions and see if you have a get_atlcom Class or a getplus or a DLM Control. You don't want any of them.
Let me know.
Okay, with your last post in mind, here is what I did and the results:
1. Checked Add-ons. Found Shockwave Flash 8 in there, as expected. Disabled it. Went to a page that I know has Flash content. No prompt from Firefox to download plug-in (I suspect because Flash 8 was there but disabled.)
2. Clicked "get updates" in Firefox add-ons dialog box. Firefox opened its usual page, listed Shockwave Flash 8 as "outdated". Clicked link to update.
3. Firefox goes to Adobe site, loads DLM, requires restart. Upon closing, Firefox reopens itself, downloads FP 10 with DLM. FP 10 installer wants Firefox closed to continue, close Firefox.
4. Firefox restarts after FP 10 install. Add-ons dialog box does not show either Shockwave Flash 8 or Adobe Flash Player 10 in list of installed add-ons. Clicked "get updates" again. No Adobe plug-ins of any kind listed.
C:\Windows\system32\Macromed\Flash contains the following files:
Contents of the log file:
=O====== M/10.1.82.76 2010-09-09+17-50-34.093 ========
0000 [I] 00000010 "C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\Application Data\NOS\Adobe_Downloads\install_flash_player.exe"
0001 [W] 00001036 Software\Macromedia\FlashPlayerPlugin/Version 2
0002 [W] 00001036 Software\Macromedia\FlashPlayerPlugin/Version 2
0003 [W] 00001037 SOFTWARE\MozillaPlugins\@adobe.com/FlashPlayer/ 2
0004 [W] 00001037 SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall\Adobe Flash Player Plugin/ 2
0005 [W] 00001036 Software\Mozilla\Desktop\extensions/Plugins 2
0006 [W] 00001036 Software\Mozilla\Firefox\extensions/Plugins 2
0007 [W] 00001036 Software\Mozilla\Mozilla Firefox\extensions/Plugins 2
0008 [W] 00001036 Software\Opera Software/Last CommandLine 2
0009 [W] 00001036 Software\Opera Software/Last CommandLine 2
0010 [W] 00001036 Software\Opera Software/Plugin Path 2
0011 [W] 00001036 Software\Opera Software/Plugin Path 2
0012 [I] 00000014 C:\WINDOWS\system32\Macromed\Flash\NPSWF32.dll
0013 [I] 00000015 C:\WINDOWS\system32\Macromed\Flash\FlashUtil10i_Plugin.exe
0014 [I] 00000017 C:\WINDOWS\system32\Macromed\Flash
=X====== M/10.1.82.76 2010-09-09+17-51-06.700 ========
I have used Firefox since version 2.x; I had FP 9 before upgrading Firefox, which is when all my problems started. If it were not for the fact that the programming world is insistent on making site logins require Firefox 3.x now I would have stayed on the 2.x version (please don't talk to me about security holes to exploit; I am more concerned with having everything operate in a stable manner, which right now I do not have as a consequence of these forced upgrades).
Hi K M, I've read over your latest Installs, etc. I am assuming that when you right click on the NPSWF32.dll and then click on Properties, it is FP version 10.1.82.76.
Now when you go to plugins with FF, there is no SWF vs 10.1.82.76? I must say I have never seen so many problems Installing Flash Player into Firefox. First I cannot abide that DLM and wish Firefox would stop using it!! It causes more problems than it is worth, and finally even tho Adobe still uses it also, they have at least included the Manual Installers for IE and FF and other non-IE browsers. They are in the Troubleshooting Guide which I must say is fantastic since they have revised it. Great instructions, with screenshots and information for IE and FF, etc.
About 3 weeks ago, I Installed Firefox for the very first time. But I used the Manual FP Installer as I did not want any part of the DLM, etal.
Now, if you don't have the SWF, then look in add ons, plugins and extensions and see if you have any getplus, get_atlcom Class or a DLM Control listed.
When you Installed FP this last time, did you use the Administrator Account?
Did you have any realtime Anti-Virus running, or any applications in the system tray that uses Flash running?
Just a suggestion but if I did not have that SWF that you must have, I would use the Manual Uninstaller and the Manual Installer. Let me know if you want to do that. In my opinion it is better, since you SAVE them to the Desktop and then close all browsers and run from there.
Yes to your assumption that NPSWF32.dll reports version 10.1.82.76 when I check Properties.
No to the question about it appearing in the list of plug-ins in Firefox. I doublechecked just now to be certain. There are no Adobe plug-ins of any type (in the tradition of "fix one problem at a time" I have not yet attempted to load the "other" popular Adobe product, Reader into this browser). No getplus, no get_atlcom Class, no DLM Control.
Yes to my login being an Administrator account. No to real-time virus scanning (I know you'll have concerns about my system safety, but I am incredibly cautious about downloads, clicking on weird e-mail links, etc.) or other applications using Flash.
Is the manual installer/uninstaller different from what is at http://get.adobe.com/flashplayer/ ? Because I tried that already.
Hi, ok. That link you provided. As far as I know that link is different. When you used it did the DLM(download manager ) come up? The Manual Installers do not include options for McAfee or the Google Toolbar nor the DLM
I'll give you the links, that is all I ever recommend to any users here as they don't include the "extras". I do use that other link for Mac's, since I don't have a Manual one for that OS.
Yes, this tried to run the DLM and had the (in my opinion, worthless) McAfee option.
I remember running a manual uninstaller at one point but I don't remember whether or not I ever had a standalone FP 10 installer. I think this whole thing is starting to make me dizzy.
I'm beginning to think I'd have better success convincing the world to stop using Flash content than to make it work on this browser.
Hi, that's what I thot on that link. You have a pretty clean system and shouldn't be having these issues.
Download the Uninstaller and SAVE it to your Desktop:
Download the Flash Player Installer for Firefox and SAVE it to your Desktop:
Then Close All browsers, disable any applications that use Flash that are in the system tray (messenger services)
Use the Administrator Account. You only want to be looking at your Desktop.
RUN the Uninstaller, when it is finished, Reboot.
RUN the Installer, when it is finished, Reboot.
IMPORTANT If a red box comes up saying it is going to Install Flash Player, above the word QUIT is a small box you need to check to accept the license and it is very hard to see. Then you can use the INSTALL box.
Then check you Flash folder and make sure that SWF is there and Enabled.
Message was edited by: eidnolb add important info
Followed your instructions precisely. Flash Player 10 does not appear in Firefox's list of add-ons.
The same files appear in the Flash directory as I listed in post #19.
Apparently in some circumstances, FP 10 does not install properly on Firefox 3.6.x and I'm one of those circumstances. Maybe I will have to run IE (eccchhh) for those sites that FP 10 is required for and run Firefox with FP 8 for everything else.
I also posted in Firefox's support area a week ago. Got no response whatsoever.
Hi, well, I cannot believe that. Now Flash Player won't appear in your add ons or plugins or extensions. The Flash Folder, yes as you posted in #19. The SWF (Shockwave Flash) is supposed to be in the plugins.
Did you update to 3.6.9?
Did you get that red box?
Firefox's forum leaves a lot to be desired in my opinion.
I wonder if when you removed the Flash folder if that had anything to do with it? The Flash files, are they now in the Flash folder, or in another location?
I need to check the Windows Registry list for something.
Do you use Adblock or adblock plus?
You could try a different version of Firefox.
Let me know on the above. I'll check a couple of things also.
Yes, I updated to 3.6.9 (I think I posted that earlier but probably didn't mention the version number) but no change in Firefox not accessing the plug-in.
Yes, the install brought up the red box which has now become all too familiar to me; yes, I checked the "agree to terms and conditions" (which is the only way the installation button will un-grey.
I wondered the same thing about deleting the Flash folder, but the fact that subsequent installations recreated it in the same hierachy leads me to believe that's not the issue. All the flash files are in that folder.
I use Adblock Plus because the original Adblock is not compatible with Firefox 3.x; I tried going backwards to version 3.5.12 but the problem with SWF remains. I already know that if I went back to Firefox 2.x, FP 10 would refuse to install so I haven't bothered with going back that far.
There is no C:\Program Files\NOS folder.
Last night I installed Google Chrome just to see what would happen. FP 10 installed on it and runs without a problem. If I can't resolve this incompatibility issue with Firefox soon I may just abandon it and use the Google browser.
Hi K M, From what is going on with FF, I doubt is vs 3.6.9 is making any difference:-) I just was trying to keep track.
I asked about that red box, since I wasn't sure if it was being used with the offline Installers as well as the others. The only problem is that "accept" box is very hard to see if one is not aware of it. Using this I think is a change.
Ok, glad the Flash folder is back.
Now on Adblock plus. That may be a problem. I'll have to check on whether is can cause an issue with the Install of that SWF plugin. I know that Adblock, any popup blocker software can block viewing of Flash Content. Whether Adblock plus does, I'm not sure.
When I Installed FF, I used the 3.6.3 version, but may update to see how the new vs acts. I just don't have time at the moment.
Glad there is no NOS folder, since that is part of the DLM etal.
I hear Chrome is fast and since Flash Player is embedded, that seems to be a plus.
The Firefox support is lacking I think and their Search feature is not organized at all. The various "Results" it brings up for any particular search, doesn't relate to the Search and none of the results are dated and a lot of time is spent for nothing.
If you have time, check on the above to see if Adblock plus blocks the Install of FP. At the rate I'm going, I may forget:-)
Hi, well we gave it our best shot. Once in a while and this had to do with Bitdefender AV, that several people could not Install that SWF for FF. Since you don't have any, the only thing that we haven't discussed is any previous AV that could still be in your system. I've seen that happen also.
The only thing I would do if this were my situation is Uninstall FF completely, Uninstall Flash Player completely. Then I would Install a version of FF that I knew had not conflicted with FP. Then I would Install FP 10.1.
I had thought about Installing FF on my laptop, but don't want to use it as a test machine:-)
Thanks for the cooperation and let me hear if you get it solved.