15 Replies Latest reply on Jan 8, 2015 11:26 PM by HarleyTDavis

    Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode

    RampantSlime Level 1

      I am tryin to edit a multi angle concert. All Audio works fine until I right click my files, go to Multi-Camera and click enable. Then my audio doesnt play back anymore. I have "Audio follows video" selected in the muli-cam playback monitor as well. If i disable Multi-Camera on the files the audio works again. Please help. I sent the audio away to be mixed/mastered and want to get all my video editing done for when the file is back on monday.

        • 1. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
          Shadreck Rukweza Level 2

          If you send the audio to be mastered/ mixed then that means you will have to sync it with the multicam sequence and start the live cut from there, But when you need to cut out anything later make sure you use the in and out markers then extract.

          • 2. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
            RampantSlime Level 1

            I know I will have to re synch the audio after that is fine. I am using pluraleyes for all of that. My problem is once i have my clips synced. Here are the steps Im using after my clips are synched:

             

             

             

            1 - Create a new sequence called Multicam
            2 - Drag   already synchronized footage (all 3 cam angles + the 3 audio) "Sequence 1 sync" and place it on Video track 1 in "Multicam sequence" (sound is all good)
            3 - Select new file on Video track 1 in Multicam sequence
              - Right Click / Multi-Camera / Enable (now my sound is gone during play back)


            If I Rightclick / Multi-Camera / Enable again (disable) my audio comes back.

             

            Audio is fine that action occurs.

             

            If I go Window / Multi-Camera Monitor / Options Roll / "Audio Follows Video" it can be checked or not and still get no audio playback.

            • 3. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
              Jim_Simon Level 8

              You need to render the audio after enabling multicam.  (Just hit Enter.)

              • 4. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                RampantSlime Level 1

                I rendered the audio like you said. Now I have no sound at all on the multicam sequence with or without multicam enabled. Sound on original sequence still works. any ideas?

                • 5. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                  RampantSlime Level 1

                  my quick fix at the moment is cut audio from "sequence 1 sync" and paste it to audio in "Multi-Cam Sequence"

                  • 6. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                    Harryscopic Level 1

                    I'm also having trouble with audio in multi-cam enabled nested sequences in PPro CS5.5. It seems whatever audio routing is going on, it's not intuitive or what a user would expect, this needs improvement or a detailled explanation in the application help.

                     

                    I found a few threads like this one: http://www.dvinfo.net/forum/adobe-creative-suite/506135-ppro-cs-5-5-multi-camera-audio.htm l#post1725437 and it seems the only solution is to work audio separately.

                     

                    Would it be so difficult to have the application treat the audio and video just the way you already edited it in the source sequence?

                    • 7. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                      7marcin Level 1

                      I have similiar problem - when I select a clip and change camera in it, audio is gone. I have only 1 audio track...

                      • 9. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                        scottbrickert Level 1

                        Using PrPro CS5.5, I am having this same issue.  All the track output icons are visible in the synced sequence, so each track is enabled.  There are no waveforms visible in the nested sequence.  No audio output. How does this work?

                        • 11. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                          7marcin Level 1

                          It's Adobe. Do not expect their software will work as you would expect it to.... and they will not fix bugs - you have to buy new version...

                          • 12. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                            Kevin-Monahan Adobe Employee

                            7marcin wrote:

                             

                            It's Adobe. Do not expect their software will work as you would expect it to.... and they will not fix bugs - you have to buy new version...

                            7marcin,

                            That's not true at all. With CS6 we've had two patches: 6.01, and (6.02, 6.03).

                             

                            Info on 6.0.1
                            Info on 6.0.2/6.0.3

                             

                            Do we fix ALL bugs? No, that's impossible. We prioritize based on a number of things, a chief one among them is the bug report/feature request form: http://www.adobe.com/go/wish

                            • 13. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                              nikitab Level 1

                              Re: problem - I was able to fix this by deleting the parent sequence.  Going into the multi-cam sequence, reordering so that the audio track I want is on the first track.  Then setting up a new sequence that I turn into multi-cam.

                               

                              Adobe, you guys need to get your act together.  Your tool is a mixture of awesome and "what-were-you-thinking?!".  With multicam, it can be a simple sequence setting that determines which track is selected (track, all tracks, follow cam).

                              • 14. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                                HarleyTDavis Level 2

                                Hey.  They didn't balk the whole thing up completely....

                                They did handle audio like video, but separately.

                                Once nested, you need to enable multi cam for audio first.  start nested, nothing highlighted,  OPT +rightclick (alt for win) on the audio portion only.  Select to enable multi cam.  Now... ...If you have a lot of audio tracks, you'll be a little kludgy.  But if you opt clickholddrag the audio track under the master for as many audio tracks as you have, you can multi cam your audio and video separately.  Select each audio track and set the multi cam to a single camera that matches which are in your multi cam synch, and you'll be able to manually switch between them when you want by adding effects and keyframes.  Ta-DA.  Kludgy, yes, but the guy that showed this off on line just saved me a ton of work, I thought I'd pay it forward for the new year.  Did they get it perfect?  No.  They assume you want to actually edit your footage.  Wait... ...Isn't that what you wanted to do?  They just need to know how much editing!  Here's the goal:  PLANNING out your EDITS beforehand.  For a lot of us, there isn't that much time anymore.  There used to be.  I miss those days.  Please remember:  You must turn on all audio tracks before nesting, and all video, making sure there are video tracks for every set of audio ("cameras")--for the last part, I just create a blank, small sized video to go with my standalone audio in AME with the same frame rate as at least one other video and add it to a set so there is a camera associated ("Camera" refers to the video track associated).  Then you need to nest, opt+rightclick audio only, and select enable multi cam.  If you only have one audio source you want to hear, you can select it by Camera (the number corresponds to associated video track number; so you should have a video track linked to your audio).  Here's a good one:  IF you don't have spare video for one track, link it to a video once synch'd and turn off any audio you don't want (it may still play all audio).  If it plays all audio, start again, but unlink the audio you don't want before nesting, and it will be treated as extraneous.  Remember, it chooses audio by camera, which is the associated video track.  A limitation, perhaps, but not if you have AME and know your Quicktime formats (MOV is both a PCM sound only file, and a video format!  Format in Audition, then format in AME to get blank empty video.  If you size it right, you can get very little data added, and use it as a fade stepper.  Make it as big as your other video, and you can use it to fade-in\out to black while clipping.  Warning, files get pretty big, even when empty.

                                 

                                Where did I acquire this knowledge?  CreativeCOW

                                Apparently that guy got it from cs5.... ....who knew?

                                Adobe, here's your cue... ...All you'd have to do to appease anybody whose still a little abashed about this is add a menu item to a right click on a nested sequence: Audio Multicam>enable  which enables the multi cam for the audio and eliminates a single step for those lazy guys who just don't want it to be so complex a click.  Thank you for thinking of guys like me to begin with and making such a beautiful software app for this.  It has quirks, but I've been able to navigate them with a little extra prep.  For instance, I use high fidelity, high sample, 32bitfloat audio that premiere cs6 won't support native in a WAV file if the file is more than 4gb.  But, I like to multi cam and sync audio anyway.  I use AME (a nice little helper that is), and make stereo audio into PCM (so similar to WAV audio they are practically twins) with a blank movie, and I don't have to try and link it to another video later.  When in a movie file, premiere no longer worries about file size, it sees only a stream of sample data. 

                                 

                                Some old school Logic for those who need a refresher course:

                                First, it is assumed (as normal in the computing world) that you will do things in a set of predefined steps in any direct industry.  The same is true of most software, even if it offers a different method (you just have to know that the method is offered and how to activate it). SOOOO>>>>> if you do not select to multi cam your audio, it is assumed that you have some other audio track you want to use (flawed perhaps, as it requires a sync action again), or that the first camera holds the primary sync audio and the best audio.  However, this isn't exactly a WRONG assumption.  Old days, you built your cameras into the scene by frame, using audio as the sync reference (the clapper and "action!").  With celluloid, you had to listen to the audio first, sync that so there was no audible echo, then mark any video frames where it was out of sync and time shift the audio, or even stretch it to fit when frame rates weren't perfectly aligned (mechanical failures or limitations).  Moving on... ...Now we can sync our camera video by audio from the devices, then throw down an audio track and sync that in, and do even more later with our trusty software, and we can be reasonably sure the frame rates are the same, meaning that we shouldn't have to stretch audio.  We can break it into steps.  Old days, you had your video guys sync video and listen to a separate audio track for cues, mark the cues, clip to the cues, and then you had audio guys add effects, transitions and whatever else to your audio based on the cues, and wash it all down with some scrubb-cleaning.  No bubbles here boys and girls.  Audio was last in line.  This was the premise for premiere, I believe.  Take the way things are typically done in the industry, and try to match the software to it with a few extra features thrown in and a nice way to view the whole thing.  However, they took it a step further for the "Jack of All Trades" guy who's not afraid to scrub his hands to the marrow; you just have to ENABLE the feature that alters the standard workflow.  The same is true of most industry standard software.  Is your database multilingual?  Great! Enable that in your Microsoft SQL server so you can have worker bees in several countries.

                                 

                                To recap:

                                Remember, the primary audio track will be the one used (track 1) if you don't manually enable the multi cam on audio.  Build a blank movie with your desired audio (framerate matches other video; use AME) and place that movie on video track 1 if you want to use it as your primary (you can switch between angles later for video).  Another option: sync all the audio and video, then unlink your undesirable audio, from video 1, and link desired audio to video 1 (again, you still have your angle-switch). Do either of these before you nest and you'll only have one audio track to deal with, no guarantees on the function.  OR....Option 3: also before nesting, Turn on all audio in your original sequence (where all video and audio is laid out), make sure every audio is linked to a video or has a video track associated (if one video has two audio tracks, you'll need to link any stand alone audio to it's own video; use a little of the other options here), nest the sequence.  Unhighlight, then alt\opt +rightclick on audio portion only, select multi cam, and select the video track associated with your desired audio.  If you want to jump between audio tracks later at your leisure, you should dupe the tracks as you find necessary (however many audio tracks you want to switch between).  Quickest way is to unhighlight all, then alt\opt clickholddrag audio track below master and drop to duplicate.  Set the multi cam to which camera set you want to draw from, and it will appear in your multi cam monitor under "Audio" as the audio track number in your current sequence.  Now you can have one or more audio switch with the clips, or even switch with the video.  You can even multi cam the multi cam!  Nest this sequence once finished, into another sequence, and bring in another video or sequence.  Nest that sequence and multi cam to clip through two different locations after you synch to a certain frame where you want them to line up (unless you've already chosen in and out balances).  Now you can actually clip through your sequences and cut them together in a multi cam setup, Each with their own audio.  By clipping through with multi cam, you can set down baseline clipping, and use it to mark both audio and video changes (IE, same camera, different video).  Once clipp-marked (yes two p's), you can pick each clip, select the camera, select the audio.  What if your cam1 audio needs to run over into a cam2 scene and then cam2 audio cuts in after a few seconds?  Done and done.  Set the clipp-marks for the audio changes by changing cams first.  You can go back and alter the camera angle later.

                                • 15. Re: Why do I Lose Audio when I enable Multicam mode
                                  HarleyTDavis Level 2

                                  Thought I'd give you the short answer from my last post:

                                  nest your synced multi cam into a new sequence, opt\alt+rightclick audio track to get an audio-track-only menu, go to multi cam, enable.  do it again and select the "Camera" where the audio you want is linked (Camera refers to the linked video-audio set that is identified by the Video track number).  If you have stand alone audio, and\or any of your cameras have more than one audio source, you could have a problem (I have my own workaround; audio into blackscreen movie with same frame settings as at least lowest framerate movie, links audio to a video), you can try this next step:

                                  alt\opt + click and drag audio track you just enabled down below master to duplicate it.  Do this once for every "Camera", and you can select the audio track in multi cam monitor (corresponds to audio track number of the current sequence, not the original).  If you're like me, you make your cuts manually with the razor and then switch cams on your own.  You can do the same with a single audio track.

                                  NOTE:  Enable all audio tracks, and select from them later.  It does make things easier in one sense.