4 Replies Latest reply on May 21, 2016 9:30 PM by Colin Holgate

    Basic Question: Graphic or Movie Clip Symbols?

    media kat Level 1

      In CS5.5:


      1. For graphics that will not be twened, does it make a difference if they are saved as graphic or movie clip symbols?


      2. It seems that either graphic or movie clip symbols can be motion and color tweened. Is there a differnce with saving them as either a grpahic or movie clip?



        • 1. Re: Basic Question: Graphic or Movie Clip Symbols?
          Ned Murphy Adobe Community Professional & MVP

          As far as timeline-based tweening goes, graphic vs movieclip doesn't matter.  They can both be tweened on the timeline.  As far as code-based tweening goes, because a graphic symbol cannot be manually assigned an instance name, you cannot directly target it like you can for a movieclip.  You would have to use getChildAt() targeting to be able to manipulate the graphic using code.


          One primary difference between a graphic and a movieclip is that the movieclip can exist as an animation on a single frame of a parent timeline.  Regardless of how many frames you extend that movieclip along the parent timeline you will only see the first frame of it when scrubbing the timeline.  But when you test the file, the movieclip will play thru  while it is present.


          Graphic symbols can also be animations that get placed in a parent timeline, but they can only animate if they extend along that timeline for the same number of frames that they contain.  Unlike movieclips, if you scrub the timeline for such a graphic symbol you will see its animation play out as you scrub.  So if you have an animation that you want to place in timeline and you want top be able to see it animating while scrubbing the timeline, you would want to use a graphic symbol and spread it along the timeline for the same number of frames that the graphic contains.  If you extend it less frames it will not complete.  If you extend it more frames it will play over for as many frames as it has available.

          5 people found this helpful
          • 2. Re: Basic Question: Graphic or Movie Clip Symbols?
            sinious Most Valuable Participant

            Being the nature of the question is pretty basic I would suggest you use graphic unless you have a reason to need a MovieClip. If you don't know why you need a MovieClip, go with Graphic. It is much lighter weight on the processor and you'll get performance gains.

            • 3. Re: Basic Question: Graphic or Movie Clip Symbols?
              johnr31566033 Level 1

              Excuse me I would like to know about button and which symbol will it be the best use for any animation project for reusing the same character?

              • 4. Re: Basic Question: Graphic or Movie Clip Symbols?
                Colin Holgate MVP & Adobe Community Professional

                Any of these options should be reusable and could have a tween. The main difference between Button and MovieClip is that with Button you get rollover and pressed states without any code. You can get the same effect with MovieClip, but would need code to achieve that.

                2 people found this helpful